Another thread about WotM/WotC but its about replacements

[Alisae]

A game can start with a playerlist that is okay with each other, but mod generally doesn't know whether everyone will be okay with the incoming replacements.

This is a problem. We should come up with a way to deal with this situation.

I think this sums up what I wanna talk about.
As a mod, what is the best way to make sure someone replaces in that the playerlist is okay with.
A recent example was the game I took this post from, momo replaced in, and because I would rather stay on site and not banned, I replaced out instead of saying a bunch of shit that would get me site banned. As a mod, how do you prevent something like this happening.

[Alisae]

That's a breach of site rules now, modkill the offending player, their slot is compromised through their own actions. Hey, that also solves the problem

tbf that probably happened before the new rule

[Alisae]

PP by that logic shouldn't player blacklists be something that's enforced since what if an alt is used to get around a blacklist

[Alisae]

The only thing I can really think of to avoid this issue is for players to preemptively tell mods who is on their blacklist before any actual replacements are needed. As a mod I'd be appreciative of anyone telling me that upfront.

This is where we are currently. Unless the players pre-emptively tell the mods to exclude, replacements are basically not going to be screened retroactively.

Is this good enough?

I’m happy about this considering the new replacement rules

[Alisae]

If I announce "X replaces Y" and a player PMs me saying "Please no" then I'll be a little annoyed that they didn't speak to the person and tell them not to replace into their games, but I'll honour it.

The problem is when you tell people not to replace in your games yet they do it anyway

This
so much fucking this