Pikmin Mafia - Game over

[mikeburnfire]

Vote Count!
With 14 alive, it will take 8 to lynch.

4 JamesThePhox (dcorbe, Kison, Xdaamno, Claus)
3 windkirby (JamesThePhox, Nightson, The Jester)
2 JDodge* (Greasy Spot, windkirby)
2 Greasy Spot (skitzer, Gorrad)
1 Kison (armlx)
1 GhostWriter (GhostWriter)
1 armlx (JDodge*)

Deadline on Friday the 13th, at 11:59 PM EST.

[dcorbe]

I'm here as well. I don't really see a GS lynch as productive for today. I'd much rather see the JTP lynch go through.

Though there's a strong case against GS I'd like to hear more of what he has to say first, and if need be we can build a stronger case for a GS lynch tomorrow.

^^^

I didn't know this guy was playing. wow.

You haven't seen my name in all the vote counts? I'm sort of lurking because I'm satisfied with my reasons for a JTP vote. I'm paying attention, though and I'll have more to contribute tomorrow. I'll also gladly answer any questions asked directly of me as I feel I have armed myself with sufficient information to back up my predecessor's opinions.

[dcorbe]

And BTW, the 13th of june is fast approaching. We have plenty of time as a town to make a decision but I don't think it would be a bad idea for everyone to write a short summary of their current position as an insurance policy so that we don't accidentally miss the deadline because of some ambiguity.

[JDodge]

Jdodge, you vote someone and claim you have a case of reasons, and people are naturally going to be interested in why you are voting that person. When you fail to come up with said case, it makes it seem a lot like you were voting off stone nothing.

Answer the damn question and stop avoiding it, scumbag. Why is it

absolutely imperative

that my vote be explained

before anything else can be done to move the game forward?

I'm more inclined to think that those demanding a case whilst contributing nothing else are more likely to be scum.

[armlx]

I never said the game could not move forward. I simply said I was waiting on your case. Apparently, other people were too.

Stop trying to straw man your way into a case you build as you go.

[JamesThePhox]

I'd rather see a windkirby lynch. Personally.

[armlx]

I'd rather see a windkirby lynch. Personally.

I can see that as well as a jdodge lynch. I just connected that he was replacing Pyrodwarf.

[JDodge]

I never said the game could not move forward. I simply said I was waiting on your case. Apparently, other people were too.

Stop trying to straw man your way into a case you build as you go.

Yet you aren't doing anything to move it forward. Why is that?

[armlx]

I prefer a Kison lynch to both. I have stated why. If absolutely no one agrees with me, I'll move along with a case on both.

Editted out the quote pyramid - MBF

[JDodge]

You have a case, you bitch at me for not presenting mine, you don't present yours.

Why is this?

Editted out the quote pyramid - MBF

[armlx]

I never said I had a case on either. I said I would make one if no one agrees with me on my primary suspect, whom I have already posted a case on.

Editted out the quote pyramid - MBF

[JDodge]

So you're suspicious of them, yet you don't have a case on either?

Editted out the quote pyramid - MBF

[windkirby]

Stop stalling and post your damned case.

[JDodge]

Stop stalling and post your damned case.

I'm not stalling. I'm contributing by having a useful discussion. If anything,

you're

stalling.

[armlx]

So you're suspicious of them, yet you don't have a case on either?

Arguing with you is possibly one of the dumbest things possible.

I have reasons I have found them suspicious which I have already stated, but I do not have a full PBPA case on either.

rebelkidrules (3:11:26 PM): jdodge1019: uhjdodge1019: i acknowledge and concede points all the time
rebelkidrules (3:11:34 PM): this is the most incorrect statement currently in chat

Editted out the quote pyramid - MBF

[windkirby]

Stop stalling and post your damned case.

I'm not stalling. I'm contributing by having a useful discussion. If anything,

you're

stalling.

Useful discussion? Contributing? Now you're just lying through your teeth. If you were

truly

interested in useful discussion, you would tell us why you voted. Instead, you're avoiding the topic by saying that armlx has been giving less contribution than you have, a lie, but even if he was, it shouldn't matter because both Claus and I (as well as others, I believe) have both asked as well for your case on armlx, although it's becoming painfully obvious it doesn't exist. At any rate, I can hardly see how

I'm

the one stalling, but as already pointed out, I'm not going to get into a long argument about how your failure to explain what we would

like

you to explain is somehow the fault of mine. Just letting you know that my vote on you is looking pretty solid. (Except in my case, I'm happy to explain it if anyone would like.)

[mikeburnfire]

Prodding Xdaamno, Kison

[Xdaamno]

Responding to prod. Will keep an eye on this over the next 24 hours, then post.

[JDodge]

Arguing with you is possibly one of the dumbest things possible.

I have reasons I have found them suspicious which I have already stated, but I do not have a full PBPA case on either.

rebelkidrules (3:11:26 PM): jdodge1019: uhjdodge1019: i acknowledge and concede points all the time
rebelkidrules (3:11:34 PM): this is the most incorrect statement currently in chat

So I am to understand that you do not have an actual case for either at this time, and your suspicions are based more in the theoretical?

Why do you bring quotes entirely out-of-context from out-of-game sources into this in a vain attempt to discredit my arguments?

Editted out the quote pyramid - MBF

[Claus]

Jdodge made me re-read pyrodwarf.

unvote. Vote Jdodge.

Let's see what happens.

[Claus]

s/Jdodge/Jdodge_2/

[Kison]

As irritating as it may be that JDodge is not giving his case, this is kind of what he did during Day Two in his previous role.

I'm starting also to suspect WindKirby and Kison less, based on a quick re-read of them both.

- My second choice would be kison - if only because he was at Jdodge's, GS' AND Gorrad's wagon by the end of day 2.

What changed here?

armlx, you've mentioned many times you dislike Pyrodwarf. What in particular bothers you?

Unvote

because I like JtP's post 586. WindKirby, how scummy am I?

Vote : xdaamno

. Lurking Master Mofo. Also, ignored my request of his other supposed JamesThePhox scummy vibes(May 22nd). Also has maintained JtP suspicion into today yet unvoted him yesterday after his weird JDodge + Kison vote. Not paying attention or simply placing votes he doesn't feel strongly about.

Not sure about JDodge/Pyrodwarf. I find Pyrodwarf's reaction to Zombie's lynch to be the scummiest part of his play. JDodge 2.0 is acting as dumb as JDodge 1.0. He needs to post his case, but it seems clear he lacks one. Wouldn't mind lynching him but I would prefer Xdaamno.

[Nightson]

I'm not sure JDodge being annoying equates to him being scum. This annoying "Why should I tell you my case" thing doesn't seem scummy to me.

[The Jester]

Which is why you should instead be voting for WK, I wouldn't mind a JtP lynch if it came down to it.

[Gorrad]

*headdesk*. JDodge, please understand. You're saying you're promoting discussion, yet are not bringing up posts to discuss. This isn't clever. It's not useful. It's being a hypocrite. To expect ANYONE to follow your lead acting that way is absurd. That said, I hate to admit it but the fact that you acted JUST as scummy D1 has made it so that I cannot in good faith vote you for acting like this.

On top of this, keep in mind that cases are what help us improve. By NOT posting a case, you're screwing over someone who could use the advice in later games. And that's just being a jackass.