Scummies Nominations 2019

[singletonking]

FWIW, RAS's cheating may make RAS's achievements much less impressive, but they make Elsa Jay's in his the Non-Reviewed Game neighbour thread much more so. I was planning to nominate that for a scummy anyway, and given that RAS was a townie in that game, it's fairly explicable how scum ended up losing even after Elsa talked a townie into faking an innocent on him.

I don't think RAS cheated in that game.

Scum lost because the game was townsided and made a bad mechanical decision late game to kill RAS.

I still think that deserves a scummy regardless

[RadiantCowbells]

welcome to the mod/dead thread for Non-Reviewed Game! you're either here because you died or because you're one of the people who helped create this beautiful chimeric game. currently, this is the complete list of who can view this thread:

awestfie

[singletonking]

Yeah, I just went back and found that.

[RadiantCowbells]

feel free to nominate elsa with either his team or as a body of work nominee ofc

sorry that the RAS situation happened.

[callforjudgement]

RAS cheated, this post is pretty much proof (note that awestfie was in a spoiled spectator thread by that point), and this post makes it all the more certain.

The setup was ridiculously townsided, though, so scum may have lost anyway despite Elsa's brilliance.

PEDIT: I've already nominated it for Kodak Moment, because the dead thread was basically just full of people being amazed at the play (even though we couldn't see the actual post until later). Scum's play besides that wasn't particularly special that game. (I haven't looked at Elsa's other scumgames.)

[RadiantCowbells]

i mean

"this setup was ridiculously townsided" is a point in elsa jay's favor in terms of deserving a nomination, not against.

[callforjudgement]

Yes, I know. That's also part of why I nominated it.

[chennisden]

elsa jay needs to win it tbh.

[Nancy Drew 39]

He nominated himself for Kodak Moment...really?

Quick, FL, nom this for post of the year.

[Nancy Drew 39]

should probably just antinom everything in those games tbh, they are all tainted.. :/

+1

[Nancy Drew 39]

The scumteam nom is tainted considering one of the members knew everyone's role probably.

Yeah cuz RAS was probably spoiled.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I think it's inherently tainted given there were effectively 4 scum.

Please just remove it.

+1

If you don’t, it makes a mockery of scumteams that didn’t have outside information.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Wow, actually a lot of tainted noms.

Antinom:

RAS Moment of brilliance and Kodak Moment BooneyToonz X
awestfie Hannibal Lecter BooneyToonz XI


Scumteam Goodfellas in BooneyToonz XI maybe? RAS was part of it in a hydra, but maybe we should just remove him from the nom and let the rest of the team stand on their own merit.

There will be new noms to replace the bad.

But I feel badly for people who won alongside RAS in any game. I would feel so cheated if I thought I worked on a team that had solved something or outplayed the other side only to learn that it was fruit from the poisonous tree.

Happened 4 times to me, that I actually know of.

[Nancy Drew 39]

welcome to the mod/dead thread for Non-Reviewed Game! you're either here because you died or because you're one of the people who helped create this beautiful chimeric game. currently, this is the complete list of who can view this thread:

awestfie

[Flavor Leaf]

The scumteam nom is tainted considering one of the members knew everyone's role probably.

@Boon do you think your nom is tainted here?
If so I can remove it.

I actually didn't give the Notes account spoilers in that game, but Ras did have Awestfie in that account, and DEB's scum play was essentially coasting and having Awestfie dominate the game, which was just Ras.

Remove it.

[Alisae]

The scumteam nom is tainted considering one of the members knew everyone's role probably.

@Boon do you think your nom is tainted here?
If so I can remove it.

I actually didn't give the Notes account spoilers in that game, but Ras did have Awestfie in that account, and DEB's scum play was essentially coasting and having Awestfie dominate the game, which was just Ras.

Remove it.

you got it captain.

[Boonskiies]

viewtopic.php?f=94&t=79399
his personal thread from Boonin' It In The Slums and he claimed Masons with himself to save himself, and fake meta'd himself. The sociopath...-.- This game was so hard tainted. Aggravates me.

This guy also made me lose my scum streak I was on.

[Alisae]

btw
I don't think people actually know this, but I feel like this is something people should take for granted:
Indeifnitely banned users cannot recieve scummies.

So like, I know it may seeeeeeeem tempting to spam the form with anti-noms
but I'm pretty sure you could be spending that 1min doing something else

Anyhow I'ma work on updating the stuff now

[Flavor Leaf]

Nominating Saudade for Moment of Brilliance

for Large Normal 220: Jazz Mafia

Saudade had near perfect reads and through his Loyal Neighborizer role was able to create a masonry which POE'd the game out. While this was a town sided setup, the confidence and elongated discussion, he was able to become the main player who helped lynch 4 scum back to back. Despite Flavor Leaf being a damn boonskiies playing devil's advocate, and everyone arguing against his reads, he was able to create actual discussion and eventually was able to convince every single player to eventually join in on his preferred lynches, which caused a near perfect town game. I debated nominating the majority of players, as I truly believe every single town player in this game was somehow part of helping lead to a town victory. Everyone played a part in this, but Saudade lead town, and thus, the nom is to him.

[Alisae]

I'll make sure to include this as well

[Alisae]

okay I think thats everything updated.
The RAS/Awest noms removed
and the new noms added.

[Almost50]

Nominating Saudade for Moment of Brilliance

for Large Normal 220: Jazz Mafia

Saudade had near perfect reads and through his Loyal Neighborizer role was able to create a masonry which POE'd the game out. While this was a town sided setup, the confidence and elongated discussion, he was able to become the main player who helped lynch 4 scum back to back. Despite Flavor Leaf being a damn boonskiies playing devil's advocate, and everyone arguing against his reads, he was able to create actual discussion and eventually was able to convince every single player to eventually join in on his preferred lynches, which caused a near perfect town game. I debated nominating the majority of players, as I truly believe every single town player in this game was somehow part of helping lead to a town victory. Everyone played a part in this, but Saudade lead town, and thus, the nom is to him.

I OBJECT! (Not really, but I still feel bad about my whole team getting lynched consecutively).

[Jingle]

I think the best way to get over this is to spam this thread with scummy nominations. Go out there and do things worth being nommed for, dammit. We all know I'm too lazy to do it.

[RadiantCowbells]

There's plenty of categories with no noms!

Find someone worthy of Paragon / Corleone / Modfather / Best Mechanic and nominate them damnit

[Creature]

RAS