Pikmin Mafia - Game over

[Kison]

Keep in mind that armlx was one of the primary reasons that WindKirby was taken down. I'm mulling this over. I wasn't here at the end of yesterday due to another deadlining game. I'm writing up a post now based on things I went through during Night.

[Kison]

Also, once again that damn red text had me thinking JDodge was scum.

Black = scum. Not red.

[Claus]

Okay, here is the plan. We do nothing until the deadline arrives, then we jump on a random deadline wagon!


... Worked the last two days, didn't it?

But seriously, I'm back from my LA. I'll read two newbie games which need me more then address this one.

[armlx]

JDodge was killed. There's no reason JDodge should have been killed, especially over ME (confirmed innocent). Who was JDodge pushing? You.

The level of WIFOM you are getting into here is pretty insane.

[Kison]

I'm struggling between whether or not I should vote for Claus, here. On one hand he pushed the SonicKid deadline wagon when there were two other competing wagons he could have safely slipped onto. Yet for the entirety of yesterday he pushed for JtP, up to the point where it looked inevitable that WindKirby would be lynched(at which point he tacked his vote on). Until I remembered his role in the SonicKid demise I was going to place my vote on him, but I'm much less certain at the time.

The other three I have my eye on are GhostWriter, Xdaamno, & Blazerunner/Dcorbe.

I didn't find much in my rereads of Xdaamno and Blazerunner/Dcorbe where they referenced the two scum, but I'm going to have another look into this. GhostWriter tacked his vote onto WindKirby at the last minute after massively lurking. I think previously he was threatening to vote JDodge if he didn't explain his case on armlx. His very next post is a hammer on WindKirby. So you really need to step it up a bit.

Why those three + Claus? Primarily because of interactions between the two scum and the rest of the players. Again with armlx, I liked his role in taking down WindKirby. Also :

Sonic >>>> JDodge IMO so...

Vote Sonic

Much rather see a JtP lynch though.

Adding that JtP line doesn't really do much from a scum perspective. There was no way in hell JtP was going to get lynched over one of the other three, and were he to push for someone who he perceived as Town rather than the scum he was currently voting, it doesn't do much for his image. Definitely not sold on armlx being Town, but I don't think he's a good candidate for lynching today. Gorrad, if the only reason you're voting him is because of JDodge winding up dead, then I highly recommend you reconsider where your vote is, because he is right in saying that your vote rests on a foundation of WIFOM, which is very weak.

I am going to

Vote : GhostWriter

. I would gladly exchange this for Xdaamno, who has been

massively

lurking throughout the entirety of the game. Also, take a look at Dcorbe. He states he's content with his JtP vote, then promptly asks everyone to give their opinions of their top suspects. He posts absolutely nothing for 8 days yet manages to slide his vote onto WindKirby at the end of the wagon.

[Gorrad]

...epiphany

Everyone needs to claim their color right now. Order...by the first page

Gorrad
Xdaamno
GhostWriter
skitzer
Kison
armlx
Greasy Spot
JamesThePhox
Claus
The Jester
dcorbe
Nightson

I might have just broken this game

I'm first, coincidentally, so I will restate that I am yellow. Y'all who will, inevitably, argue that we're giving up an asset here- the possibility of scum actually targetting someone with the corrisponding color is small enough that it's not worth saving compared to what we could gain from this.

[armlx]

If you are counting on an even split among colors, I doubt it.

[The Jester]

What could we gain from that?

Just asking before we jump right into that decision.

[Kison]

If you are counting on an even split among colors, I doubt it.

Also please keep in mind that if you actually intend to go through with this you will out every power role in the game, as they seem to have alternate colors.

[armlx]

Also please keep in mind that if you actually intend to go through with this you will out every power role in the game, as they seem to have alternate colors.

Thats a legitimate concern as well.

[Gorrad]

Oh? So far the only power role we've seen is me, and I'm still yellow.

[armlx]

He's referring to the fact we are assuming that the Purple/Whites are power roles.

[Gorrad]

Hmm, we'll see. I've managed to crack the setup. I'm 85% sure of it. I will definitely not say any more than that, as doing so allows the scum to organise their claims.

[armlx]

Hmm, we'll see. I've managed to crack the setup. I'm 85% sure of it. I will definitely not say any more than that, as doing so allows the scum to organise their claims.

If you are counting on an even split among colors, I doubt it.

Otherwise, I support a mass claim.

[Kison]

If you're 85% certain then I suppose I support this. If you're wrong, though, I'll smack you with a salmon. Hard.

And yes, I am assuming purple = role. Not sure what you mean by white, Armlx. But if Gorrad is yellow, then that actually means some roles may be standard color.

[armlx]

Not sure what you mean by white

There are white Pikmin. Thats what I mean.

hen that actually means some roles may be standard color.

Also assumed.

[Gorrad]

Ok, up next is XDaamno. Color?

[Kison]

Hence the 'may'

[armlx]

Hence the 'may'

No, when I said that I meant we generally assumed that to be true, not that the fact it was an assumption is bad.

[Nightson]

I don't have a problem with people claiming colors.

[Kison]

Kindly request a prod on Xdaamno

[petroleumjelly]

Vote Count!
With 12 alive, it will take 7 to lynch.

1 armlx (Gorrad)
1 Ghostwriter (Kison)
Not Voting: armlx, Claus, dcorbe, GhostWriter, Greasy Spot, JamesthePhox, Nightson, skitzer, The Jester, Xdaamno

Xdaamno has been prodded.

[Xdaamno]

Meh. I was just coming in to check on this thread, anyway.

Colour claims seem like a good idea in theory, but mike will likely have proofed them to an extent.

[skitzer]

Vote: Greasy Spot

And yes, I'm fine with the color claim.

[Gorrad]

Meh. I was just coming in to check on this thread, anyway.

Colour claims seem like a good idea in theory, but mike will likely have proofed them to an extent.

That's great. You're up next!