Pikmin Mafia - Game over

[Xdaamno]

You know, I think we gain more info than we lose by not having an order.

What? I disagree completely.

Same.

Personally, I would find speculating on player order a lot easier than speculating on colour info, which is almost irrelevant (at the moment). Having a pre-set order restricts speculation to the player who designed the order, if anyone did.

[Gorrad]

It's the one on the first post.

[JamesThePhox]

I'm White. If that helps.

[dcorbe]

hmm. I was skeptical at first but now I actually think we're getting somewhere with this. I will reserve my comments until after everyone has claimed.

[dcorbe]

Claus?

[armlx]

It's going to degenerate into WIOFMy logic. The only way to verify someone's claim is to lynch them.

Not really, assuming Gorrad is right we can approximate scum per group and go from there.

Personally, I would find speculating on player order a lot easier than speculating on colour info, which is almost irrelevant (at the moment). Having a pre-set order restricts speculation to the player who designed the order, if anyone did.

Speculating on claim order in a free for all claim is way too speculative.

[Claus]

Oh, it is my turn.

I'm a Bulbmin.

[The Jester]

I'm Red.

[armlx]

That leaves Nightson, GS, and GW.

[Nightson]

White.

[armlx]

This last page has been very interesting to say the least. Waiting on the last 2.

[Nightson]

Limited to no access for the next four days.

[GhostWriter]

Red. Sorry, haven't been able to get to the library this week, due to not being able to find a ride. I can walk there, but it's a few miles, and I'm lazy, and it's hot, and I'm lazy, and it's far, and I'm lazy. Also, I pulled something. I've read enough to keep up, and you now have my color. I'm over a friend's house, he just came back for a trip, had me calling him the moment he got in so that I could use his computer.

[petroleumjelly]

Vote Count!
With 12 alive, it will take 7 to lynch.

1 armlx (Gorrad)
1 Ghostwriter (Kison)
1 Greasy Spot (skitzer)
Not Voting: armlx, Claus, dcorbe, GhostWriter, Greasy Spot, JamesthePhox, Nightson, The Jester, Xdaamno

[Claus]

I guess that's everyone? Where do we go from here?

[Gorrad]

We wait for GS. In the meantime, I want everyone to read the wiki entries on Purple Pikmin and Anode Dweevils and try and see where I'm going with this. So far, it's been about where I expected.

[armlx]

I don't see where you are going with this, but I'm willing to wait.

[JamesThePhox]

Bulbmins look like they can be converted into an enemy of Pikmin. Based on what the pikminpedia says.

Claus has never really settled too well with me. I would be fine with a Claus lynch.

Concerning purple pikmin - Anode Dweevils, it seems like Purple pikmin can 100% stun one when thrown, which is interesting, to say the least.

Also, I would like to point out that if Louie does come sometime today as a confirmed innocent, it's more than likely that we're dealing with a lot more enemies. In a normal 18 player setup, you would typically see around 5-6 enemies, but if a confirmed inno is coming into play, the enemy count could jump to 6-7, which means we could be in a Lylo situation, assuming the enemy can kill two pikmin in a row.

The Puffy Blowhog and Anode Dweevil can be linked to most of the night kills in the past. The only night kills we've been seeing are by consumption, possibly the Blowhog/Dweevil had a one-shot use of their abillity, and potentially the Blowhog was a Serial Killer, seeing as how Blowhogs don't consume Pikmin and that there was only one Pikmin that was resistant to the Blowhog: Zombieslayer (Purple pikmin). Unless there is another Blowhog that managed to hit a pikmin with a resistance to it, like a Fiery Blowhog, night kill immune but unable to kill at night (which seems likely due to the amount of Red Pikmin that have claimed.

Another way to look at it is that the enemy monsters could be hiding their fire/water/lightning/poison based attacks and only attack through consumption until there was a mass claim, such as this one, so they can attack simultaneously effectively winning the game.

Last thing I would like to point out is that white pikmin, when eaten, will do damage (potentially killing the enemy), so maybe White Pikmin have a bomb-like ability.

[armlx]

Oh wow, you claimed White and you don't even know what your own role does?

Vote JtP

Now THAT is a slip.

[Claus]

I thought we were waiting for GS to claim?

Bulbmins look like they can be converted into an enemy of Pikmin. Based on what the pikminpedia says.

I thought it was the other way around. Can you grab that quote?

Claus has never really settled too well with me. I would be fine with a Claus lynch.

Funny you never mentioned that before.

Also, I would like to point out that if Louie does come sometime today as a confirmed innocent,

Louie is the replacement mod. Not paying a lot of attention to the game, are we?

which means we could be in a Lylo situation, assuming the enemy can kill two pikmin in a row.

If we're in a lylo situation, why did you vote me so hastly, without much more than "his claim looked strange"?

Last thing I would like to point out is that white pikmin, when eaten, will do damage (potentially killing the enemy), so maybe White Pikmin have a bomb-like ability.

Also, What armlx said. "Maybe"? I know quite well what my role does.

Back to my vote in the previous days:

Vote: JtP

[armlx]

Bulbmin are enemies that can be converted to pro-Pikmin from what I have read in the Wiki, not sure what JtP is saying.

[Kison]

Also, I would like to point out that if Louie does come sometime today as a confirmed innocent, it's more than likely that we're dealing with a lot more enemies. In a normal 18 player setup, you would typically see around 5-6 enemies, but if a confirmed inno is coming into play, the enemy count could jump to 6-7, which means we could be in a Lylo situation, assuming the enemy can kill two pikmin in a row.

Last thing I would like to point out is that white pikmin, when eaten, will do damage (potentially killing the enemy), so maybe White Pikmin have a bomb-like ability.

These are wrong for many reasons...

FoS : JTP

Wait for Gorrad. Lynch + Gorrad dying = bad news if

I might have just broken this game

is true.

[Xdaamno]

Oh wow, you claimed White and you don't even know what your own role does?

Vote JtP

Now THAT is a slip.

Agreed, though I'd like more clarification from him before we speculate.

[Gorrad]

That admittedly looks very bad, but I really do think I'm onto something here. It rides rather heavily on GS, unfortunately.

[Xdaamno]

That admittedly looks very bad, but I really do think I'm onto something here. It rides rather heavily on GS, unfortunately.

How so?