Open 765: Haunted Village (Over)

[NorwegianboyEE]

Instead, I'll ask you a question. Do you think Fake-PP is scum? And apart from that, who are your other scumreads?

Phoenix and Benhalkum both seem kinda sus.
Also i’m thinking Beta Sapphire and Hoptic needs closer examination.
There are also a couple people that seem to have been awarded a "strong townread" from many, even if the substance in their posts makes it seem a bit unwarranted. I’ll leave you to figure out who i’m talking about. I’d prefer it if you were thinking independently rather than having me explain everything. This is assuming you are on the town’s side.

[tris]

@tris
Can you post your current reads? My impression is that you are like the most inconspicuous player here. Nothing sticks out of the ordinary. And i kinda wish it did.

Unstuck in Time
Vorkuta
PenguinPower
Hoptic
Gamma Emerald
you as well

are some townreads. There's some people I need to take a look at more.

Maybe Salt goes on that list.

If you had to guess the scumteam now who would it be

Let's say: S_S, RCE, and fakePP. but I do need to look at the second two's ISOs

VOTE: Something_Smart

[tris]

i might be townreading wrong

[RCEnigma]

Instead, I'll ask you a question. Do you think Fake-PP is scum? And apart from that, who are your other scumreads?

Phoenix and Benhalkum both seem kinda sus.
Also i’m thinking Beta Sapphire and Hoptic needs closer examination.
There are also a couple people that seem to have been awarded a "strong townread" from many, even if the substance in their posts makes it seem a bit unwarranted. I’ll leave you to figure out who i’m talking about. I’d prefer it if you were thinking independently rather than having me explain everything. This is assuming you are on the town’s side.

No thanks I like being spoon-fed.

[RCEnigma]

i might be townreading wrong

And scumreading wrong, I think at least 2 of those 3 scumreads are town.

Also what an arbitrary question to ask.

Dayvig: Vorkuta

[tris]

only one of them is really a scumread

[RCEnigma]

[Gamma Emerald]

@tris
Can you post your current reads? My impression is that you are like the most inconspicuous player here. Nothing sticks out of the ordinary. And i kinda wish it did.

Unstuck in Time
Vorkuta
PenguinPower
Hoptic
Gamma Emerald
you as well

are some townreads. There's some people I need to take a look at more.

Maybe Salt goes on that list.

If you had to guess the scumteam now who would it be

Let's say: S_S, RCE, and fakePP. but I do need to look at the second two's ISOs

VOTE: Something_Smart

I think SS is town rn

[tris]

why is that?

[Something_Smart]

Why do you scumread me?

[tris]

I don't know. sorry.

I'll figure that out or change my mind when you post more.

[PenguinPower]

Huh...I don't like S_S's read on Ben.

The read itself or the reason behind it?

Reason.

I mean I don’t tr the slot, but I was talking about the reason.

[Something_Smart]

I don't know. sorry.

I'll figure that out or change my mind when you post more.

So it's a gut read?

I mean I don’t tr the slot, but I was talking about the reason.

Elaborate. What's wrong with it?

[tris]

I don't know. sorry.

I'll figure that out or change my mind when you post more.

So it's a gut read?

yeah

@mod V/LA 12-15

[PenguinPower]

Your making the assumption his partners did/were able to explain it to him

And that, even if they did that he would understood what was being explained

And that, even if he did that he was being genuine in his statement. Those same partners could have told him to play dumb.

[PenguinPower]

I see a grammar error I can’t change!!!

[Platinum Phoenix]

SS how far have you gotten through reading wise?
- Phoenix

[Something_Smart]

Your making the assumption his partners did/were able to explain it to him

I mean, he had to explicitly choose a role and sign off on the role choices...

And that, even if they did that he would understood what was being explained

I should think he would understand "this is an open setup with no third parties"

And that, even if he did that he was being genuine in his statement. Those same partners could have told him to play dumb.

Sure they could have. But it's not likely.

SS how far have you gotten through reading wise?
- Phoenix

Haven't. Gonna read a bit now.

[Something_Smart]

Twenty pages in, and so far I can say that my call on Norwegian was a good one.

[Something_Smart]

I think Penguin is town.

For posterity, this is circa page 26.

[Something_Smart]

im inclined to agree

mafia is really stupid for choosing such a shitty PR

This just occurred to me. It's likely that

a specific scum player

wanted to be a zombie because they heavily expected to be lynched early.

[Something_Smart]

And caught up.

Don't have much in the way of reads, probably for the best. My reads upon catching up after replacing in are almost always trash.

[Beta Sapphire]

I am disappointed that neither Menalque nor ofrhz realized that Gamma Emerald was a reference to Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire.

I think I did know that (from gtkas maybe) but ofhrz suggested the name and I kinda thought it was funny

-M

[Beta Sapphire]

SS you seem tonally different here than in, for instance, pfup

Should I be concerned about that?

-M

[Beta Sapphire]

It does not help that your interaction with Norwegian is weird and that’s a slot I’ve liked less as day has gone on (although I haven’t read the last ~10 pages)

I still like scum in (RCE, vork) and would currently lean towards it being RCE

-m