Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

Flavor Leaf · Post Post #3775 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 7:46 am

In post 3772, PenguinPower wrote:I was the first one to clear Chennis....

I believe you. Like, hands down. You don’t have to try to convince me you cleared Chennis.

JJD/Vecna is very possible too.

PenguinPower · Post Post #3776 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 7:47 am

You just said I went along with it when

a.) We didn't intend to target the same person

and

b.) I was the first one to post my results.

Bingle · Post Post #3777 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 7:52 am

I'm actually starting to lean croag as the copscum.

Bingle · Post Post #3778 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 7:53 am

I do want croag to come in here and respond to the narrative of the hood before we EoD tho.

Bingle · Post Post #3779 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 8:00 am

In post 3774, Flavor Leaf wrote:PP/Vecna is the 1v1 tomorrow

Um...

No?

We reevaluate based on whether JJD is a CPR doctor or a (What's the other option? Regular? I can't remember flips.)

If CPR doc, it's probably marquis because that's the only way night actions line up.

If not CPR, we need to look hard at what happened the last few days to find his partner.

Judge Joseph Dredd · Post Post #3780 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 8:29 am

In post 3747, Flavor Leaf wrote:
In post 2055, PenguinPower wrote:
In post 2051, Flavor Leaf wrote:Chandra
Kagami
Penguin
Judge Joseph
Possible pops?

Have at least one scum in them likely
That's a very bad list, FL.
Pp’s first Day 2 post

You gotta give to him though. 2 gave already flipped town, and I know I am, so if PP is town (and I do believe he is) that's 1 scum out of 5. Bad list indeed.

Croag · Post Post #3781 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 8:43 am

In post 3777, Bingle wrote:I'm actually starting to lean croag as the copscum.

10/10 post write it again

Judge Joseph Dredd · Post Post #3782 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 8:48 am

@chenn: What did I tell you? You will NOT be able to lynch the scum today. Nobody wants it.

Tinfoil: PP/Croag + chenn scums is plausible.. from an independent PoV. I have a TR on all 3 though so of this is the case they can win (and it pleases me that Bingle loses in this situation).

VOTE: JJD

Let's do this.

Judge Joseph Dredd · Post Post #3783 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 8:49 am

Btw, I am the Paranoid Doctor. After the 2 flips from my hood we deduced that Chenn is the CPR Doc.

Judge Joseph Dredd · Post Post #3784 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 8:56 am

Also, Monger dying to a PGO is a silly proposition. It was only plausible on D2 because we didn't know better. Now we know there has been 2 deaths every single night, so where do the extra kills come from?? (One from the CPR doctor?? Cool. How about the other one? It's been 3 nights so far with 2 deaths each).

Vecna · Post Post #3785 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:12 am

In post 3728, Flavor Leaf wrote:I’m actually a confirmed Vigilante now, so it’s funny I’m getting voted

Or potentially scum with Marquis and some unknown shenanigans happening.

Bingle · Post Post #3786 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:13 am

In post 3776, PenguinPower wrote:You just said I went along with it when

a.) We didn't intend to target the same person

and

b.) I was the first one to post my results.

In post 3780, Judge Joseph Dredd wrote:
In post 3747, Flavor Leaf wrote:
In post 2055, PenguinPower wrote:
In post 2051, Flavor Leaf wrote:Chandra
Kagami
Penguin
Judge Joseph
Possible pops?

Have at least one scum in them likely
That's a very bad list, FL.
Pp’s first Day 2 post
You gotta give to him though. 2 gave already flipped town, and I know I am, so if PP is town (and I do believe he is) that's 1 scum out of 5. Bad list indeed.

Holy crap is this shade ridiculous.

Hey, that list FL said had one scum? It had ONE SCUM!

Bingle · Post Post #3787 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:14 am

In post 3785, Vecna wrote:
In post 3728, Flavor Leaf wrote:I’m actually a confirmed Vigilante now, so it’s funny I’m getting voted
Or potentially scum with Marquis and some unknown shenanigans happening.

In post 3755, Bingle wrote:Marquis is the only method by which Fish Monger died that has claimed.

Potential alternatives: JJD is CPR doc who hit a buddy on N1. Actual vig who shot Fish is not cc-ing because they hate us and actively want to lose the game. The n1 kill was actually on a fakeclaiming PGO.

I want to lynch JJD, which will solve that potential issue. If JJD flips CPR doc, he was probably lying about targeting ofhrz and Marquis looks a hell of a lot worse.

If the N1 kill had been on a PGO, I don't see how marquis could have known that when he claimed, given that FL was a claimed vig at the time and could well have acted. That's a ballsy move that I'm not even considering. It could mean FL and Marquis are scum together, except that I've spent the last two nights talking Marquis down from murderlating FL. So for Marquis to be scum, both me and FL have to be scum (which is dumb) OR JJD has to be scum (he is, but that's not directly indicative of Marquis scum) in which case the first correct choice is to LYNCH JJD.

teal deer: I don't show the work when it's basic addition.

Bad Vecna. I already had to shout down stupid scumreads on 'quis today.

Bingle · Post Post #3788 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:15 am

Dunno where that penguin quote came from.

Vecna · Post Post #3789 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:15 am

In post 3744, Flavor Leaf wrote:
In post 3742, chennisden wrote:surface read is fl/bingle
Vecna said we’re specifically unable to be scum together, but I’m not entirely sure why.

I retracted this straight after because it was based on false logic

Judge Joseph Dredd · Post Post #3790 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:18 am

In post 3786, Bingle wrote:Hey, that list FL said had one scum? It had ONE SCUM!

He said "at least", and PP was TRing chandra, so..??

But anyway, lynch me and get it over with. If you're town you are pushed to a corner and it please me. If you are scum no more hiding behind a SR on me and -hopefully- someone will get things right.

Bingle · Post Post #3791 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:23 am

ATF noted, die scumfuck.

Also, I typed up a joke for you before the thread lock and FG made it disappear.

Vecna · Post Post #3792 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:25 am

In post 3787, Bingle wrote:
In post 3785, Vecna wrote:
In post 3728, Flavor Leaf wrote:I’m actually a confirmed Vigilante now, so it’s funny I’m getting voted
Or potentially scum with Marquis and some unknown shenanigans happening.

In post 3755, Bingle wrote:Marquis is the only method by which Fish Monger died that has claimed.

Potential alternatives: JJD is CPR doc who hit a buddy on N1. Actual vig who shot Fish is not cc-ing because they hate us and actively want to lose the game. The n1 kill was actually on a fakeclaiming PGO.

I want to lynch JJD, which will solve that potential issue. If JJD flips CPR doc, he was probably lying about targeting ofhrz and Marquis looks a hell of a lot worse.

If the N1 kill had been on a PGO, I don't see how marquis could have known that when he claimed, given that FL was a claimed vig at the time and could well have acted. That's a ballsy move that I'm not even considering. It could mean FL and Marquis are scum together, except that I've spent the last two nights talking Marquis down from murderlating FL. So for Marquis to be scum, both me and FL have to be scum (which is dumb) OR JJD has to be scum (he is, but that's not directly indicative of Marquis scum) in which case the first correct choice is to LYNCH JJD.

teal deer: I don't show the work when it's basic addition.
Bad Vecna. I already had to shout down stupid scumreads on 'quis today.

So mechanically youre totally fine with a town with these cops also having 3 town vigs?

HUH.

Colour me intrigued in this narrative.

Flavor Leaf · Post Post #3793 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:25 am

In post 3780, Judge Joseph Dredd wrote:
In post 3747, Flavor Leaf wrote:
In post 2055, PenguinPower wrote:
In post 2051, Flavor Leaf wrote:Chandra
Kagami
Penguin
Judge Joseph
Possible pops?

Have at least one scum in them likely
That's a very bad list, FL.
Pp’s first Day 2 post
You gotta give to him though. 2 gave already flipped town, and I know I am, so if PP is town (and I do believe he is) that's 1 scum out of 5. Bad list indeed.

Lol, false, the list is 100% accurate.

It was a perfect list at this point. Chandra flipped scum.

Flavor Leaf · Post Post #3794 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:27 am

In post 3782, Judge Joseph Dredd wrote:@chenn: What did I tell you? You will NOT be able to lynch the scum today. Nobody wants it.

Tinfoil: PP/Croag + chenn scums is plausible.. from an independent PoV. I have a TR on all 3 though so of this is the case they can win (and it pleases me that Bingle loses in this situation).

VOTE: JJD

Let's do this.

I’ve already been saying that.

And town loses if you’re lynched and town essentially

Vecna · Post Post #3795 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:28 am

The more people keep talking like this, the more im starting to believe in a Bingle + FL scumteam.

Which is....quite the accomplishment really.

Id have totally bought and voted for a JJD scumwagon, but this shit just feels wrong on so many levels.

Vecna · Post Post #3796 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:29 am

Yeah JJD, stop the fucking selfvoting and play properly if youre town.

Thats not how you laid down to die last game you were town and I was literally deathtunneling your ass. So why do it now.

Flavor Leaf · Post Post #3797 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:30 am

My gut really wants to read jjd as town, but everything does line up to him. Hmm...I’m trying to figure out if he’s just been setup hard, but idk where.

Marquis could be scum, i agree.

Flavor Leaf · Post Post #3798 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:30 am

In post 3795, Vecna wrote:The more people keep talking like this, the more im starting to believe in a Bingle + FL scumteam.

Which is....quite the accomplishment really.

Id have totally bought and voted for a JJD scumwagon, but this shit just feels wrong on so many levels.

If Bingle and i were scum, there were much easier routes we could have taken to win the game.

Vecna · Post Post #3799 (ISO) » Mon Sep 16, 2019 10:33 am

He cannot be scum, unless scum had another way to dispose of kagami N2 though.....

I could see, in a far-away fantasy land how the claimed parity cop was instead a reflexive suicide bomber or w/e that is called in proper naming convention, and played the way he did to attract the N1 kill and drag a scum with him.

The missing N2 kill, meh. I dont see how that one came from scum really.

Marquis was also pretty town by play at every stage of the game, except for more recent. But thats mainly just him being absent.