The fallacy here is thinking that winning team mafia at all implies generally "good at mafia".In post 14, popsofctown wrote:I think it's dumb
Jingle, suppose you're right, and Kagami is wrong, and you go on to kick Kagami's ass in team mafia by exploiting the mechanic correctly, then you get a fancy banner all year that says how good at mafia you are, then I queue up for a bunch of large normal and minithemes with you that year and Kagami Sherlock Holmes's me every time Irandomlyam scum and powerwolfs me everytime Irandomlyam town, and we are just mislynching Bingle d1 all year: I'm going to start to feel your banner is rather silly as an award that implies "good at mafia" when you won a event with deliberately included mechanics perpendicular to mafia.
Fundamentally different skill-set regardless of how the selection meta pans out.