Open 81 - The New C9 - Game Over

[roflcopter]

ding ding ding! korts gets another point.

armlx becomes more scummy.

[Korts]

Yay! Points! Are they edible?

[StrangerCoug]

How many posts are on forbiddanlight at this point, by the way?

The word "posts" should be "votes". My apologies.

[roflcopter]

they can be traded in for cookies at a rate of 3 for 1.

so you're one point away from your first cookie!

[Korts]

they can be traded in for cookies at a rate of 3 for 1.

so you're one point away from your first cookie!

Double yays! Cookies! [/OT]

[Korts]

How many posts are on forbiddanlight at this point, by the way?

The word "posts" should be "votes". My apologies.

I don't know, I'm lazy to count.

[StrangerCoug]

The reason I was asking is because I don't want to kill forbiddanlight before she gets a chance to claim. I'm going to wait for Lowell's defense before I do anything about her, though.

[roflcopter]

it takes eleven to lynch, we're nowhere near that point.

[roflcopter]

er, nine to lynch since there were nightkills, but you get the idea.

[armlx]

he claimed because Lowell asked the masons to claim and he happened to be one.

In that case, he is just dumb for listening to Lowell.

[Korts]

he claimed because Lowell asked the masons to claim and he happened to be one.

In that case, he is just dumb for listening to Lowell.

And this (rofl being dumb/listening to Lowell) puts rofl's claim in a completely different place on the time scale, basically nullifying your point that you were trying to prove with the "wagon to claim" statement:

armlx, you just aren't going to admit that making legitimate points against you like rolefishing and poisoning the well make this obviously not omgus, are you?

I don't think a single person here agrees with you on the role fishing part, as evidenced by the fact you were wagoned to claim after your posts about it.

Because listening to Lowell about the mason claim isn't even remotely linked to the rolefishing point.

[roflcopter]

you have officially earned your cookie.

[armlx]

It invalidates the connection, but not the point that he is seeing things that aren't there.

[StrangerCoug]

I counted four votes on forbiddanlight right now, by the way, so roflcopter's right about being nowhere near lynch point.

[StrangerCoug]

EBWOP: armlx, what connection are you referring to?

[Korts]

*eats Cookie*

I win, I'm going home now. G'night, folks, that's all for today!

[armlx]

EBWOP: armlx, what connection are you referring to?

The relation between his claim and his being wrong.

[forbiddanlight]

Well, in case you all DO want to kill me shortly, I might as well point out I'm a vanilla townie. No claim here, continue voting at will. I'm actually quite astounded that that one statement got a wagon on me. To be honest, I was justifying intuition. I don't feel that StrangerCoug is town, but I'm maddeningly incapable of backing that up with much more, hence why I only FoS'd. I didn't want to start the bandwagon because I didn't have any "real" evidence. If a wagon started, my intuition would be more justified, and I also might actually find the reason that I'm suspicious of him, other than what I said. I also think at this point there is probably at least one scum on my wagon (since they should pretty clearly know I'm not scum). Given that, I will

vote Vamparific

since from what I can tell, he just waltzed in and jumped on the running wagon. Pretty easy way to hide as everyone was accusing me of attempting to do. I also am supsicious of StrangerCoug, but since that's not likely to go anywhere, let's hit the other one who looks mildly scummy here.

Also, I have 5 votes on my wagon. Thanks .

[armlx]

Claim doesn't really help. Vote stands for now.

[Greasy Spot]

Still not clear where to put my vote at the moment. forbiddan and greasy are acting weird, lowell seems more scummy in the background of the thread then he is in isolation, but nobody stands out from the pack.

How am I acting weird? Because I suggested a theory. I don't see you suggesting any kind of theory.

At least I'm not spitting out craplogic and trying to pass it off as truth like Armix is doing.

You can't tell me masons outing themselves really hurts the town.

It does. Anything that gives the mafia more information in who to target at night is going to hurt the town, especially if the "pay off" for the town is getting 2 confirmed innocents who won't likely last long.

Masons are nothing more than glorified townies that can talk at night. Their vote is no more powerful than anyone else's. Now that the masons are outed (if they truly are masons) the odds are better for the town to lynch scum. So yes it does technically benefit the town to have them come out. We won't spend our time trying to lynch them. And it provides some cover for the other townies.

[forbiddanlight]

Claim doesn't really help. Vote stands for now.

Well, I just wanted to make sure I got my claim of vanilla townie out there before you all pushed the lynch. At least then you know you aren't killing a doc or a cop.

[iamausername]

You ask us which we think is scummiest yet there is no case against Strife so how could I possibly decide right now?

What do you mean by "there is no case against Strife"? Do you mean that you don't think he's done anything scummy, or just that no one has pointed out what scummy things he's done?

That's exactly what I mean. I haven't seen anything scummy yet and you and rofl pushing his lynch haven't shown anything that gives cause for his lynch at this time.

So do you think there

is

a case against armlx?

Hi, Greasy Spot, this question would still like an answer.

It's pretty absurd that we've already had three claims at this point (albiet one of them involuntary). If everybody could stop doing that now, that'd be lovely.

[BlakAdder]

Could you elaborate on what you mean when you say "making assumptions" is part of the game of mafia and what exactly you were making assumptions about?

Pretty simple, really. If everyone waited until they were totally sure that someone was scum, deadline would roll around before we reached a majority. Also, my assumption was voting for roflcopter, obviously.
Also, I don't think I need to justify my intuition, but whatever.

[iamausername]

Also, I don't think I need to justify my intuition, but whatever.

No.

[armlx]

Masons are nothing more than glorified townies that can talk at night. Their vote is no more powerful than anyone else's. Now that the masons are outed (if they truly are masons) the odds are better for the town to lynch scum. So yes it does technically benefit the town to have them come out. We won't spend our time trying to lynch them. And it provides some cover for the other townies.

It benefits the town just as much as if rofl had A) waited till closer to lynch and B) not revealed his partner, and benefits the mafia less.

Also, I don't think I need to justify my intuition, but whatever.

But you do. Intuition is not valid reasoning.

It's pretty absurd that we've already had three claims at this point (albiet one of them involuntary). If everybody could stop doing that now, that'd be lovely.

Agree. No claims until L-2 people.