Open 84 - Fire and Ice Mafia - Game Over!

[Alabaska J]

/tehconfirmzors

Also, roflcopter, try not to speedlynch me in three hours before I can get on and pull a cosmic t-rex.

If we had lost that game…

[Alabaska J]

Confirm.

Woah, I'm playing with a guy I replaced in a game. Weird feeling.

[Alabaska J]

but alabaska, we won that game because i'm so awesome, so i don't see what the problem is.

lol thank god for your awesomeness roflcopter . But yeah, that was the quickest random lynch I have ever seen. I'm am really surprised darla survived as long as she did.

Confirm.

Woah, I'm playing with a guy I replaced in a game. Weird feeling.

Yeah, have fun in that game by the way. It's a veritable shitstorm of stupidity.

Korlash isn't even defending himself anymore lol.

[Alabaska J]

I WAS gonna OMGUS roflcopter for last game, but seeing as he already has a few votes on him, I'll just

vote: Joubert

for stealin' my avatar gag.

[Alabaska J]

so...now what?

Now we lynch chubbs.

Reasons?

Do not question the great roflcopter.

unvote, vote: ChubbsMcLubbs

Also ,it is fairly obvious why there is a wagon on him at this point. If you

really

don't see it I'll fill you in.

---

ChubbsMcLubbs (3): Snix, roflcopter, Alabaska J
roflcopter (2): forbiddanlight, Joubert
orangepenguin (2): somestrangeflea, ChubbsMcLubbs
somestrangeflea (1): Geddingsworth
Snix (1): Eldritch Lord
armlx (1): Scigatt
Sun Tzu (1): mik5

Not Voting (3): armlx, orangepenguin, Sun Tzu

[Alabaska J]

Im just not used to the forum version of this game. I tend to wait till I actually have a reason for voting people out. And it feels akward giving a bs reason for voting someone out just on the basis of their name or avatar.

So

Unvote:Vote: No Lynch

Lol. Alright. You throw the third vote and someone, you votehop, you unvote to appease the town instead providing reasons, and now you vote nolynch. This is not looking good for you, my friend.

[Alabaska J]

I think the belly-up move is much more indicative of noobscum than noobtown. I think Joubert is trying to keep his hands clean of chubbs' lynch because they are on separate scumteams and Joubert is assuming chubbs is town.

[Alabaska J]

Mod, roflcopter isn't voting chubbs anymore (see the post you edited)

I have no idea what you mean!

Also, seeing as I believe chubbs and Joubert are both scum, I have no problem voting either of them. However, I believe the chubbs wagon has more strength at the moment, so my vote stays.

[Alabaska J]

Everyone but roflcopter (already answered it), chubbs (obvious), Joubert (obvious), and I (already answered it) need to answer this question: If we were to lynch one of chubbs or Joubert today, who would you choose? Please review both cases carefully before answering this question.

[Alabaska J]

Everyone but roflcopter (already answered it), chubbs (obvious), Joubert (obvious), and I (already answered it) need to answer this question: If we were to lynch one of chubbs or Joubert today, who would you choose? Please review both cases carefully before answering this question.

WOAH

seriously?

you scum need to stop being so obvious.

alabaska is one of the scum. probably joubert's partner given how hard he's trying to keep things on chubbs, but this false dilemma makes it possible that he's the other scumgroup too.

getting more and more likely that chubbs is just newbtown making some newb mistakes.

this made me lol.

Also, I never made a false dilemma at all. I just wanted to see what everyone's opinions of Joubert and chubbs were.

Still think chubbs is newbscum not newbtown but I have no problem lynching Joubert atm.

Joubert please defend yourself. After your defense I will decide whether or not I will vote you instead of chubbs.

Also, it is

really

unlike armlx to lurk this much. I have a feeling he forgot to put this on his watched topics…

[Alabaska J]

that was an easy one to catch - i played caiaphas in JCS my sophomore year of high school

sweet.

I soooooo wish I could one day be as good as the actor who played Judas in the movie…can't think of his name…he died a few years ago too :'(

[Alabaska J]

that was an easy one to catch - i played caiaphas in JCS my sophomore year of high school

sweet.

I soooooo wish I could one day be as good as the actor who played Judas in the movie…can't think of his name…he died a few years ago too :'(

Carl Anderson, RIP, greatest Judas ever.

I've been pushing my music teacher to do JCS for our musical, but she is an old, worthless bat who refuses to do anything with the slightest bit of class. Okay, that may be a tad harsh.

If you've got someone with the vocal range to sing Jesus, I say go for it.

[Alabaska J]

way to not respond to my point about being joubert's partner, alabaska. instead you just tried to put a little distance between the two of you by talking about how you're possibly willing to lynch him. and yet you still prefer the chubbs lynch.

I've already said I think chubbs' actions are more indicative of noobscum than noobtown.

Also,

mod prod chubbs

I don't think he's posted for quite some time.

[Alabaska J]

now all we need is joubert…

[Alabaska J]

Joubert's defense is teh suck.

unvote, vote joubert

Also, armlx, I agree there is some bussing going on here.

[Alabaska J]

FUCK i hammered :/

That's what I get for reading the thread at 1:00 in the morning :/

[Alabaska J]

Also, @ whoever asked me about chubbs' behavior being noobscum instead of noobtown: I tend to associate cautious voting (unvoting ssf in the way he did after feeling a little pressure, voting nolynch) to be noobscum moves. Noobtown do this too but are much more defensive when they do it.

[Alabaska J]

EBWOP:Also, I forgot to unvote, so my vote is technically on armlx.(So Alabaska didn't hammer)

unvote

I'm willing to hold off voting at least until Joubert posts again.

Thank god. I'm not Rosso Carne; I don't like hammering that quickly. Also, me answering your question simul'd with you asking me to answer your question.

Before Joubert is hammered, I want to hear what armlx thinks is fishy. Then I think we a re god for the most part, although I personally would like everyone to check back in to state they are good with their vote (this is probably wishful thinking but w/e).

[Alabaska J]

him not paying attention. I would call that a nulltell.

[Alabaska J]

Oops.

vote ChubbsMcLubbs

vote chubbs mclubbs

PoS: Geddingsworth

for the oops.

[Alabaska J]

fos: roflcopter and Snix

[Alabaska J]

oops i think I fos'd the wrong person. Posting on memory alone has never gone well for me…

[Alabaska J]

yep

Fos: mik5, unFoS: Snix

[Alabaska J]

Also, I think we should speculate on whether we think bodyguard died saving or was killed directly.

Attention all: Bodyguard is just my term for Doctor. The Fire and Ice Setup says as such.

[Alabaska J]

My vote on Chubbs is basically a place-holder, as I enter the day with him as my biggest suspect from the carry-over. Gedd gets the PoS for the oops comment, which is now upgraded to an

FoS: Geddingsworth

now that I realized he hammered. rofl gets an FoS as I think he rushed Joubert when Chubbs was a better lynch. mik5 gets an FoS because, after a reread, his vote on Joubert was the most opportunistic IMO.

[Alabaska J]

And to Alabaska, I concede that I was too eager to vote Joubert. (not that I was alone), but when you say that Chubbs was a better lynch I completely disagree. Hindsight is always 20/20 and you only say that he was a better lynch because of the fact that Joubert was found to be a townie. Chubbs looked just as scummy as Joubert at the time, so it is pointless to speculate on what we should have done. If we learned anything from our last mistake, we shouldn't start an immediate bandwagon against Chubbs.

I consistently said yesterday that chubbs was a better lynch. This has nothing to do with Joubert flipping town at all.

I am happy with a mik5 lynch at this point also, but currently will keep my vote on chubbs until he posts.

[Alabaska J]

So apparently my being incorrect about Joubert makes me scum? BTW, how do you know that Chubbs is still a better lynch? He could be just as townie as Joubert was, and from his posts it sure seems so. I refuse to start an immediate bandwagon against Chubbs before he has said a word.

No, I never said that. Your posting yesterday in relation to the wagon makes you scummy.

[Alabaska J]

Please elaborate..............from reading my posts, I thought I gave a perfectly reasonable explanation as to why I voted Joubert.

It was a reason others had given before you, just reworded, so it doesn't matter all that much if it is reasonable or not.

[Alabaska J]

As I recall, your vote for Joubert was given with no explanation at all. Your exact words were, "Joubert's defense is teh suck." In fact, [/b] you hammered Joubert

, but ended up lucking out because of a technical error. I fail to see how my explanation that was similar to everyone else is any more scummy than your non-existent explanation.

I voiced my opinions about Joubert before the second vote was cast, I believe. Reading the thread instead of blatantly misrepresenting people is a much better thing to do if you want to look town.

[Alabaska J]

You think I am scummy because my reason for voting Joubert wasn't original and unique enough. Had it ever occured to you that multiple people may use the same reason for a vote? Doing so doesn't make you any more/less scummy, it is simply a justification for why you voted a certain way.

The way you posted it looks like leeching. Your vote, out of all the votes, looks the most like scum jumping on.

[Alabaska J]

Im still here, I just don't have much to say.
If anyone has anything they want me to respond to I would be more than happy to provide an answer. Ive just done more observing than talking since the whole bandwagon against me on day 1.

Please do more talking. I want you to respond to the fact that you were very wishy-washy and cautious about being in the spotlight day one. Reasons? Also, why did you begin "observing" once there was pressure put on you?

[Alabaska J]

Alabaska, you could say the same about you because of your first hammer, gedding because of the second, or anyone else that voted after roflcopter. I will repeat that having the same reasoning is not necessarily indicative of scumminess.

*sigh* it is not just the fact that you used the same information it is the way it was done. You leeched; your post makes it look like you are a dutiful townie adding something to the argument when you are not actually doing so: you are just rewording the argument presented.

Why are we discussing this? We should be focused on chubbs today; you are a secondary candidate for lynch in my eyes.

[Alabaska J]

Im still here, I just don't have much to say.
If anyone has anything they want me to respond to I would be more than happy to provide an answer. Ive just done more observing than talking since the whole bandwagon against me on day 1.

Please do more talking. I want you to respond to the fact that you were very wishy-washy and cautious about being in the spotlight day one. Reasons? Also, why did you begin "observing" once there was pressure put on you?

Good. Content is a start. Now answer the above.

[Alabaska J]

Vote Ged

Quick hammer turnarounds like that are beyond scummy.

Agreed. Now post your thoughts on chubbs and mik5, please, the other people I am willing to lynch today. Also, roflcopter.

[Alabaska J]

f your kill fails and the other mafia kill succeeds, that means you shot an opposing mafia. please make that obvious by relentlessly trying to lynch that person. we will help you lynch them before we lynch you.

its a good deal, you should take it.

I have a bad feeling about this…but we'll see.

Also, I am liking the Geddingsworth wagon more and more and now that chubbs is actually posting content, well, my urge to vote him over Geddingsworth is waning fast.

unvote

, I will read them both again, and put my vote where it needs to be.

[Alabaska J]

After a quick isolation reread, they feel like scumbuddies O_o.

They both vote SSF. chubbs jumps on second, possibly imitating his scumbuddy. Ged panics, and starts distancing immediately once rofl posts his case. Ged distances the whole of day one, even leeching my reasoning that chubbs looks more like noobscum, before hammering Joubert after a sudden flip-flop. Begins the day with more bussing, probably hoping we will lynch his partner really fast because of yesterday, clearing him because he jumped on first. Ged also joins in on questioning chubbs when the flavor of the month becomes trying to get him to post content instead of just lynching him right away. Ged asks him some question after I do, and chubbs

answers his first

; this is important because he would naturally (especially as noobscum) want to pay attention to his partners posts more than mine. Interestingly enough, chubbs fingers Ged as the most townie player in his eyes, for some BS about how his vote on chubbs was actually a town move. I guess during the night, after chubbs became a bit disenfranchised with his partner after his partner's attempted bus (as noobscum tend to do), he was pm'd and told to go with it. Realizing the distancing going on, chubbs tries to play his part in the gambit, thus fingering Ged as the most town.

The Ged wagon has more gas, so I will comfortably put my vote there.

vote: Geddingsworth

[Alabaska J]

That's the fourth vote I believe.

[Alabaska J]

So, just to be clear, Alabaska, you think my brilliant scum strategy is to try as hard as I can to get my only partner lynched? Bussing is a fine tell and all, but there's a line between bussing and stupidity.

This is exactly what I thought you would say. My opinion isn't changing, sorry.

---

Geddingsworth (4): Scigatt, armlx, roflcopter, Alabaska J
ChubbsMcLubbs (2): Geddingsworth, Snix

Not Voting (6): ChubbsMcLubbs, Eldritch Lord, forbiddanlight, mik5, orangepenguin, Sun Tzu

[Alabaska J]

what's the buzz tell me what's a-happening are we in agreement about this Geddingsworth-chubbs thing or am I off my rocker?

[Alabaska J]

you're off your rocker.

pretty sure ged's mafia anyway though.

take him to pilate.

*takes ged to pilate*

Pilate: Geddingsworth, tell me why you aren't mafia. Why should I spare you?

Geddingsworth: I do not say I am mafia. These are your words.

Pilate: I WASH MY HANDS OF YOUR DEMOLITION *hammers*




Who wants the role of Pilate?

[Alabaska J]

itt we play jesus christ superstar mafia

this needs to get modded NOW

/pre-in

[Alabaska J]

HAmmer is at 7 guys, not 6. I need more time to take a look at the man of the hour and other potential cases than I have tonight. Should have a good idea of whether I think Ged is scum or not tomorrow evening/late afternoon.

I HAZ MAED DIZZCKOVERY! someone in this thread has not seen JCS

[Alabaska J]

I HAZ MAED DIZZCKOVERY! someone in this thread has not seen JCS

That would be true. Why should I see it?

It's a good

movie

musical

rock opera.

[Alabaska J]

Alabaska, as far as your thoughts on me and Ged being mafia together because i answered him first instead of you. I saw his post, and started my response. and in the time it took me to write out my first response to Ged you posted your questions to me, which i saw after i clicked submit. me answering him in a post before you was a factor of the time it took me to write my responses, not an indication of us being involved as mafia.

Also my reasoning for him being townie wasn't BS in my opinion. Like i said before i think the mafia was setting it up for me to be the lynch of Day 2 with no questions asked. first post of Day 2 was Ged's vote for me with no reasoning. I just thought that it was more likely to be townie falling into the hype, rather than mafia starting a bandwagon. Although the latter is still very possible, even fairly likely. Based on posts by various individuals ive changed my mind bout him.

vote: Geddingsworth

This post seems to fit my theory.

Anyway, what is that, L-2?

[Alabaska J]

gd it. ^5 roflcopter

go town and whatnot.

[Alabaska J]

armlx was obv fire

other than that, good game all!