Everybody has named guns and everybody has rope
(pops) - I want to see this setup play out but I'm not sure whether this should be higher than NewD3 or not. It's an interesting auction and can lead to chaos when people go into a bidding war on the bullet with their name on it. edit: actually yeah, this isn't a normal role-wise and the hidden aspects of chaos while somehow also being balanced deserves a freaking medal of ordered chaos. And the 72h cooldown avoids time dependency which makes the setup more balanced and fun
NewD3 Draft
(Ircher) - An interesting mutation on the draft mechanic. The alignment-based draft makes this play like a non-role madness non-bastard GestIdea setup during D1, and that's why this setup deserves to be called interesting despite being based off a Normal setup and being a Normal role-wise.
Friday Night Mafia Draft
(student) - An intentional damper on the swing (or die) is eh, but otherwise I like this setup basically being a Booster Draft but with parts of your role.
Unwanted Ability Draft
(TL) - The uncontested drafting mechanic is much more suited for chaotic and swingy setups like this one. It is meant to be used with abilities of varying power, if it were used for a balanced list of abilities that would ruin the novelty of the drafting mechanic and end up leading to mountainous more likely than one with a varied list of abilities. However the latter introduces swing, but swing is a problem with the drafting mechanic itself.
Modifier I Hardly Knew Her
(BBmolla) - A modifier draft setup with a delegation of power roles. The inherent gating of roles is a damper on the chaos, but this seems like a fun setup.
Kerset's "Loud Day 1 Vote"
(Kerset) - This is a standard "pick your power role" setup. I am not sure if Strongman affects abilities. Seems scumsided and not very innovative.
Evil Draft
(NK15) - You somehow made the draft mechanic less fun than mountainous! I would give you a medal, but this is not a good thing.