For the purposes of keeping this a nice, clean PBPA, I'm going to ignore posts 0-3, since they are entirely crap. Not bad, just irrelevant chatter about gimbo "always being like this" and "I'm not a fan of random voting, hense me skipping that part"
Post 4:
gimbo, leed us to the scum boss.
First minor contradiction here. First he said "Gimbo is always like this". Now, I'm willing to bet most of hte games you've played with him, he wasn't scum.
Now you're basically trying to pressure him into leading hte town to the Godfather. Huh?
Post 6
im confused about the cop investigation talk, is that this game? i thought this was day one....
Fishing, much? This reads like he didn't even bother to check the rules, and as such has no idea about roles - and is therefore fishing for information. IME, most town players don't automaticaly try to push for claims as soon as they think there may be roles about.
Post 7 is a hurried backtrack on this - "I guess he was talking about another game" - looking to avoid fishing accusations, much?
Post 8
vote forbiddanlight
please dont vote yourself and hunt scum thanks.
I'm assuming that's meant to be read as "please don't vote yourself, hunt scum, thanks." Commas go a long way to making sentences readable.
SO, hang on, you're asking her not to vote herself, but you're voting her, presumably (no reason other than the implied one was ever given) because she's voting herself. Wouldn't it have been smarter, and a teeny bit less scummy, to just suggest she unvote herself and explain? Hmm? Admittedly, we all got caught up on this, but this looks a bit eager to start the wagon rolling to me.
Post 9
town should never vote for himself or herself, ask to be replaced.
im also callin her bluff at the sametime seeing if she really wants to be in this game, thanks for ruining my plan guys.
Okaaaaay... having modded (off-site) myself, I'm pretty sure flea would rather not find another replacement at this point.
"I'm calling her bluff and seeing if she wants to stay in this game, thanks for ruining my plan, guys"
Now, um, wasn't the majority of hte forbiddan lynch based on the fact she tried to first explain her self-vote off as a plan, then as some kind of freak-out? And also, the last two posts here seem to indicate that Killa has no motive to vote forbiddan other than to "call her bluff". Never, not once, does he say "I think forbiddan is scum because 'X' and 'Y'". Everyone assumes the vote is there for the same reason as theirs, but it looks like Killa is trying to get on the wagon without ever actually indicting himself when it goes wrong, as he knows it will.
Post 10
lol i figured youd cop out and say, "i was baiting scum" ive seen this done before, your not fooling me. dont play the poor me im under pressure, vote = myself i dont want to play anymore then try to turn me into scum for voting a quiter who cant handle pressure.
So, you now bring up this whole "I knew you'd cop out and call it scum-bait" (I'm paraphrasing, my fingers refuse to drop to this level without quoting); and also attempt to discrdit one of forbiddan's defences before she actually used it. It's taken you this long to explain your vote, and the only exlpanation is "I knew what you were doing all along, har-de-har!". Yuck. Also, getting a little personal here.
Post 11
from what your saying, first your saying i was having a bad day so i voted my self, then your saying you had a plan all along. to me it seems like you really wanted to quit and voted yourself and then later retracted and pretended it was all a master plan.
No. That's was not what forbiddan was saying. Twisting her words here. This isn't what forbiddan said at all, it's just your interpretation of it - and it's a false one. If she'd wanted to quit, she would have asked to be replaced. And y'know what - I'm actually beginning to think it may have been a masterplan after all now. Everyone else is happy to vote on forbiddan's weak defence of her self-vote, but you seem to be the only one trying to put extra words into her mouth. I bet your scum-partners were cringing here.
Post 12
ive allready stated what i think of self voting if your town.
so dont self hammer, thanks. unless your scum
Ugh. Icky, icky, icky.
A verbal slip here from Killa, in which he basically admits he doesn't believe forbiddan is scum, but he is still willing to continue to lynch her. It looks here like the only reason the Killa7 BW ground to a halt is the timely hammer from Gimbo(now LlamaFluff.) It might have been interesting to see what might have happened if Gimbo hadn't stepped in with what looks like a protective hammer to me: "Must stop discussion of partner before mislynch is derailed!" Interestingly, Gimbo was also one of the first to jump onto forbiddan, along with Killa. Hmmm.
Post 13
Bogre wrote:
We need to look at those who hopped on the wagon, positions like 5-9, IMO.
It was too quick for my liking.
its k7 and i didnt "hop on"
Ummm. he never mentioned you, at least, not in the bit you've quoted here. Pre-emptive defence, here.
Post 14
I dont like the way gimbo acted around the hammer of fl and his "shit post" but knowing gimbo he allways acts spazzy so its hard to tell if hes over anxious scum or just being a crazy player as allways. i need to look into the farie case the wagon came pretty fast.
None of this ever happened. Only anti-town players or scum offer to look into cases but never do, IME. Also - more excusing of Gimbo's
kerrazy
style, before anyone really even considered a serious BW on Gimbo.
Post 15 onwards will be tomorrow.
