BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[Krazy Katz]

PS boon update your f'n op for replacements plz <3

-K

[Krazy Katz]

Not day 1
Venus and Mars [Nancy Drew 39 + Shiro]
Sore feet [Xtoxm + The Worst] Xtoxm
Chkflip
Conspire
Auro
Chronos

Not enthusiastic day 1
Jjh927
Titus
The Fonz
nomnomnom

Not strongly outside of day 1 material yet
George Bailey
BooneyToonzExpert
Kakeguri Addicts [Mary Saotome + Yumeko]
Vecna
Davesaz
Mechanic

This is roughly where I'm at rn I think

-K

[Krazy Katz]

Actually George probably should be in tier 2

[chkflip]

Your voting pattern indicates you were scum reading quite a few people (or at least wanted more from some of them). Can you differentiate which was which as of now? I'm sure things have changed since those votes, but you haven't really posted as much about it.

Pedit: okay, so is that basically "town lean" "scum lean" "scummier lean / I want to see more" or...?

[Krazy Katz]

Case to be made for moving booney up but ehhh

[Chronos]

I should probably also ISO Katz at some point as I feel they are in my blind spot

[Krazy Katz]

Pedit: okay, so is that basically "town lean" "scum lean" "scummier lean / I want to see more" or...?

not day 1 - town lean

not enthusiastic day 1 - either dissonance or null / faint leantown

day 1 - poe scum / few reasons to townread

[chkflip]

Is the town lean list randomized or is that in order of strength?

[Krazy Katz]

Vecna I do think is town I just don't care if he's not going to do any work into establishing who an acceptable second target for his millerize would be or help us deal with the clusterfuck of crunch bullshit his role seems to necessitate

this is just shit I'd much rather be out of the game early rather than spend the whole game dealing with it just to save one "meh, nulltown off roleclaim" slot

[Krazy Katz]

Is the town lean list randomized or is that in order of strength?

more or less close to the order they were in OP since I just copy/pasted that and then ctrl+x'd them up when I remembered how I felt

[chkflip]

What specifically made Fonz bump up the list for you?

[Krazy Katz]

I remember liking one post from dave in rvs but now I don't remember which one it was and rereading now I don't see anything that jumps out at me as townie

maybe I need to go back and reread in context but his play since then has been pretty underwhelming

[chkflip]

I didn't ask about dave but he was next.

[Krazy Katz]

I think I kinda liked 1228, not sure it's super outside scumrange but it was enough to move him to tier 2 for right now

[chkflip]

I think the nature and fluidity of Fonz' posts make him town even if he and I disagree on needing Vecna the fuck out of this game.

While dave's lack of content concerns me,

maybe

, I can't remember a town game of his that I was in/modded that he wasn't just perpetually behind in. So by the breadth of what he's putting out when he can reads as town to me.

But I could be reverse blinders on both those guys since I don't actually know what their scum game looks like. Not really a D1 concern to me, though, since I feel strongly in my capabilities to look deeper into that the longer I (hopefully) live through this.

You unvoted Fonz long before that post. Nothing else jumped out at you to bump him up prior to that?

[Krazy Katz]

I think the thought process in 325 combined with the george push was enough for me to move on to BTE in terms of content pushes. I don't think on review that'd be enough to keep him in tier 2 though, his more recent content has been much better than like anything in the first half of his iso

[chkflip]

K NOW YOU ASK ME A THING

That's how this works, right?

[Krazy Katz]

idk want to just hit us with a list?

[chkflip]

I don't like lists, personally, but Fonz, dave, jjh, KA, and sore feet are town reads/leans for me. This interaction bumped you up out of null which holds over half the playerlist if I'm being completely honest with myself. I'd like more from a LOT of fucking people. I'm obviously out for Vecna, but I can get behind a Mechanic lynch if their return post is balls. Titus is being weird but I'm holding out on that for now because I'm just not that interested in lynching there without due cause.

So, while I only have the one major scum read, quite a few of my nulls (Mechanic, Titus, Mars, George, maybe Michael Scott) are ones I'm keeping a good eye on. And tbf I wasn't really that interested in Mechanic until I asked because I kind of forgot they existed. Not a telling thing for me, particularly, because I can space on what a toaster is called on a low spoon day.

That's more or less where I'm at right now.

I feel like I should probably have more scum reads but nothing major is popping out at me like it should.

[Krazy Katz]

yeah feel like scum is either a) doing nothing or b) one scum or two are doing a pretty good job of emulating town tone right now

I'm not locktowned on auro or nancy I just don't think either is at all appealing as a day 1 right now

[Krazy Katz]

Wait why is KA town for you again?

[GeorgeBailey]

yeah feel like scum is either a) doing nothing or b) one scum or two are doing a pretty good job of emulating town tone right now

That's what scum wants you to think

[GeorgeBailey]

Vecna I do think is town I just don't care if he's not going to do any work into establishing who an acceptable second target for his millerize would be or help us deal with the clusterfuck of crunch bullshit his role seems to necessitate

Do you have an idea for the second target?

[chkflip]

Their entrance to the game and then their ISO 3 post calling everyone morons. The roleplay feels like it's coming from a place of fun instead of a place of "I need a bullshit filter so I'm not scumread".

[Krazy Katz]

Not really, no, and while town will need to decide if Vecna isn't getting d1'd right now him giving no direction on his feelings makes it easier to say he should just go