BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[RCEnigma]

He's stating the opposite, actually.

Chk gets me.

[RCEnigma]

They all received them before bte claimed he was the one that sent them. You're missing the point.

Apparently I am, so please explain it to me like I’m 5.

They all claimed to get the item around the same time then the boon post happened = less likely to be a scum play initiated by bte

As opposed to

George softing preemptively, then vecna and Fonz claim around the boon post = more likely a scum play initiated by bte.

[Venus and Mars]

You're the one that brought the claim timeline up?

nani the fuck

No, RCE did, he is making some case between the BTE claim and the timing of when the recipients received the barbs and I still don’t understand what his point is.

[Venus and Mars]

I also don't buy that hardclaiming was a reaction test if you're actively trying to force one type of result.

No, it’s just the truth.

What “one type of result”?

By making people townread you for it you nullify that whole bit about wanting to see if people tr you postclaim to get their hands on whatever you send.

Why shouldn’t people tr me? I just hardclaimed and in case you’re living under a rock, I’ve been blatantly crumbing it the entire damn game.

[Venus and Mars]

They all received them before bte claimed he was the one that sent them. You're missing the point.

Apparently I am, so please explain it to me like I’m 5.

They all claimed to get the item around the same time then the boon post happened = less likely to be a scum play initiated by bte

As opposed to

George softing preemptively, then vecna and Fonz claim around the boon post = more likely a scum play initiated by bte.

I still don’t see why any of that couldn’t just be coincidence? Of course if GB and BTE actually were to flip scum, I’d obviously have to re-evaluate that.

[davesaz]

As far as I can tell RCE was the only one who didn't TR you anyway. Though keeping track I have not been so could be wrong.

[chkflip]

I'm p shaky at best with VnM and this claim business smells fucky.

[Venus and Mars]

If this is at all relevant, I read a few of BEF’s scumgames and he made a lot of scummy pushes in those and hard tunnely pushes in those, so he hasn’t really done that here so far. I also can’t tell how much of RCE’s read is based off of wrongly sr me and how realizing he’s wrong would impact that.

[Venus and Mars]

As far as I can tell RCE was the only one who didn't TR you anyway. Though keeping track I have not been so could be wrong.

What could be?

[Venus and Mars]

I'm p shaky at best with VnM and this claim business smells fucky.

Why would I be making this up? FACT: 3 slots tonight will be playing in the Boonus round, that I know of. You are just being bad but RCE knows what I’m saying checks out, hence why my vote is still on him.

[Venus and Mars]

The main reason I claimed was because of the whole barb thing. I didn’t remember who claimed it and I needed to know if I needed to switch my picks or not. I STILL don’t know whether or not this was necessary because I still have 0 clue what the barbs actually do.

[Vecna]

Titus

Venus and Mars [Nancy Drew 39 + Shiro]

Sore feet [Xtoxm + The Worst] Xtoxm

The Fonz

Chkflip
RCEnigma Mechanic TrueSoulEnergy

Conspire [Hydra of ???? and ????]

Vecna
Davesaz
Krazy Katz [Amrun + ????]
Michael Scott [Auro + Volxen]

nomnomnom

Kakeguri Addicts [Mary Saotome + Yumeko]

Jjh927
George Bailey
BooneyToonzExpert
Chronos


Do people have good reasons to be townreading any of the people in red?

[Vecna]

Hmmm ok, guess I actually have plenty of people I dont mind going. The other people are just so much more present in this game.

BTE and Dave also havent made a very strong impresison.

[Venus and Mars]

Titus

Venus and Mars [Nancy Drew 39 + Shiro]

Sore feet [Xtoxm + The Worst] Xtoxm

The Fonz

Chkflip
RCEnigma Mechanic TrueSoulEnergy

Conspire [Hydra of ???? and ????]

Vecna
Davesaz
Krazy Katz [Amrun + ????]
Michael Scott [Auro + Volxen]

nomnomnom

Kakeguri Addicts [Mary Saotome + Yumeko]

Jjh927
George Bailey
BooneyToonzExpert
Chronos


Do people have good reasons to be townreading any of the people in red?

I bet the game on Titus!town. I’ve seen her scumgame and this isn’t it.

[Venus and Mars]

Titus

Venus and Mars [Nancy Drew 39 + Shiro]

Sore feet [Xtoxm + The Worst] Xtoxm

The Fonz

Chkflip
RCEnigma Mechanic TrueSoulEnergy

Conspire [Hydra of ???? and ????]

Vecna
Davesaz
Krazy Katz [Amrun + ????]
Michael Scott [Auro + Volxen]

nomnomnom

Kakeguri Addicts [Mary Saotome + Yumeko]

Jjh927
George Bailey
BooneyToonzExpert
Chronos


Do people have good reasons to be townreading any of the people in red?

I bet the game on Titus!town. I’ve seen her scumgame and this isn’t it.

I wish Amun could start playing and the other hydra partner is Krazy.

[davesaz]

I'm not sure why hardclaiming it was necessary. The barb recipients were all identified if you were paying attention.
The concern about claiming endangering your TRs is valid but short-sighted/shallow. I doubt it will have much effect, other than to have painted a target on yourself.

The role by itself doesn't conftown you. There is no reason the role must be restricted to town. I think the role is town more likely than not. It's not inconceivable that someone could doubt.

[Venus and Mars]

I’m not in favour of lynching Fonz, SF, or Nom today and Titus, probably never.

[Venus and Mars]

I'm not sure why hardclaiming it was necessary. The barb recipients were all identified if you were paying attention.
The concern about claiming endangering your TRs is valid but short-sighted/shallow. I doubt it will have much effect, other than to have painted a target on yourself.

The role by itself doesn't conftown you. There is no reason the role must be restricted to town. I think the role is town more likely than not. It's not inconceivable that someone could doubt.

I really don’t understand how anyone who played in LNT is doubting I’m town because of this. It’s seems super obvious to me that this is never a scum role. It didn’t paint a target on me in LNT and the entire playerlist knew what my role was, so why should this game be any different? It’s in scum’s interest to keep me alive and pocket me, so that I will enter them into the BR. Town just needs to have faith that my reads are better than in that game.

[chkflip]

So much for secret town reads.

[RCEnigma]

I'm not sure why hardclaiming it was necessary. The barb recipients were all identified if you were paying attention.
The concern about claiming endangering your TRs is valid but short-sighted/shallow. I doubt it will have much effect, other than to have painted a target on yourself.

The role by itself doesn't conftown you. There is no reason the role must be restricted to town. I think the role is town more likely than not. It's not inconceivable that someone could doubt.

The endangerment was more so to establish the claim wasn't a pro town move. It also assumes all trs are town so, fair.

[Venus and Mars]

I'm not sure why hardclaiming it was necessary. The barb recipients were all identified if you were paying attention.
The concern about claiming endangering your TRs is valid but short-sighted/shallow. I doubt it will have much effect, other than to have painted a target on yourself.

The role by itself doesn't conftown you. There is no reason the role must be restricted to town. I think the role is town more likely than not. It's not inconceivable that someone could doubt.

I obviously missed it, so yeah I honestly wish now I hadn’t hardclaimed. The most annoying part of it, is woats are STILL wrongly sr me. Sorry Auro but I don’t have unlimited patience and my claim ought to have been the end of that.

[davesaz]

I think Titus is likely town. I have had success in scumreading her in the past and tend to keep a close watch.
The Fonz doesn't seem much different from recent town games. Would like to know how he got into the red. Can't remember if I've seen him as scum.
Did Conspire fade when I fought back against their awful attempt at casing me? Worth looking at.
I don't remember seeing any of the fire from nomnom that showed up in TM. Definitely worth serious pressure.
Kakeguri Addicts had a couple of posts that I thought seemed ok. Scum!them could have put in extra effort to look townie. Very weak TR and needs to be paid attention to in any case.

[Venus and Mars]

So much for secret town reads.

I’m only responding to Vecna’s sr. Are you trying to find out who I selected?

[chkflip]

WOATS BE GAMETHROWING LMAO

VOTE: Venus and Mars

Eat rope. I already warned you about your vernacular.

[Venus and Mars]

I think Titus is likely town. I have had success in scumreading her in the past and tend to keep a close watch.
The Fonz doesn't seem much different from recent town games. Would like to know how he got into the red. Can't remember if I've seen him as scum.
Did Conspire fade when I fought back against their awful attempt at casing me? Worth looking at.
I don't remember seeing any of the fire from nomnom that showed up in TM. Definitely worth serious pressure.
Kakeguri Addicts had a couple of posts that I thought seemed ok. Scum!them could have put in extra effort to look townie. Very weak TR and needs to be paid attention to in any case.

I thought Nom’s posting looked townie and natural but I don’t really have a lot of experience playing with them. Fonz sounds tonally like town, plus he is solving. I don’t understand current sr on him.