mini 2126: the game is OVRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Comical]

Tough crowd.

VOTE: damn

[Comical]

Good timing to show up, wench.

[Comical]

Good timing to show up, wench.

I meant to say grinch, but it switched to wench. Still happy.

[Comical]

If you ain't first you're last.

i don't like this guy, seems a robot on his reactions

Is it because I already called you scum on Page 1?

Yeah, give him the 'ol 1-2

[Comical]

VOTE: clidd

Now that's a little uncalled for, huzzah!

[Comical]

Says, only fools rush in

[Comical]

im selecting the lynch tomorrow

Say it now before you get quick lynched.

[Comical]

Why do something tomorrow when you can do it today?

VOTE: Pine

[Comical]

It's interesting Okapoka wanted Fire to put L-1, but wouldn't do it themselves.
Not saying it's coming from scum, but I wouldn't skip getting a Harvey's tray when traveling to Toronto, if you know what I'm saying.

[Comical]

Why do something tomorrow when you can do it today?

VOTE: Pine

comical second scum, any normal town wouldn't change his vote on me

Foolish of you to assume that I am what they call a normal town.

I also didn't vote you in the first place, so what do you mean by change their vote?

[Comical]

but I wouldn't skip getting a Harvey's tray when traveling to Toronto

I have no idea what this means.

You're driving down the highway, where you gonna stop? Denny's, uh PASS!

[Comical]

Why do something tomorrow when you can do it today?

VOTE: Pine

comical second scum, any normal town wouldn't change his vote on me

Foolish of you to assume that I am what they call a normal town.

I also didn't vote you in the first place, so what do you mean by change their vote?

why would you vote pine ?

1. you are trying to gain towncred because you know i will flip town

2. you didn't explain why are you sheeping me

3. if we change to Pine, and he's your partner, it would be a hard buss to gain towncred by doing it

4. im a easy misslynch later, which is also a reason why you are trying to keep me alive

I think you need to be a little less worried about why I'm voting Pine, and a little more worried why you aren't voting Pine while saying he's hard scum.

[Comical]

At the present, I think it's incredibly likely that you are actually bussing Pine here

[Comical]

nice dodge

Darling, it's not a dodge at all. I'm just town, and you're flailing.

[Comical]

I really want people to notice that she didn't go after Pine yet calling them hard scum, and now has completely avoided talking of Pine in favor of yours truly

[Comical]

I don't need to shut down discussion yet. I will say I was lurking around ready to hammer if someone put to L-1, tbough., But now we have solid discussion.

[Comical]

I also do believe it's Pine-Clidd based on Clidd's posting. Early association, but whatever's clever

[Comical]

Wow, interesting. Everyone is starting to town read Clidd from that scenario.

Let that be remembered right now. I'm not saying I'm fully correct by any means, it's page 6, but that is something to be noted.

[Comical]

What's a main

[Comical]

i insist we lynch comical

it was very explicit what she tried to do there

she flips scum=Pine scum

You could have also went Pine to do so.

VOTE: Auro

I think I’m with the dog on this one.

[Comical]

i insist we lynch comical

it was very explicit what she tried to do there

she flips scum=Pine scum

clidd what does it tell you that no one else really seems to be seeing what you're seeing

I’m pretty sure I just had their number and Clidd is playing up what’s getting them townread.

[Comical]

I'm a newbie

[Comical]

Honestly, I think it's low-key Clidd way overreacting on nothing, and I feel it's possibly scum indicated. Like, I by no means am indicating that my previous statements of Clidd/Pine are by anyway actually true. That was my read theory based on a game that's gotten to page 6.

I feel Clidd has had a lot of overreaction for the sake of seeming like they're too upset to be scum, they must be town points.

[Comical]

For Vedith...

*Proceeds to chug entire glass of overpoured alcohol in a cocktail*

[Comical]

Im bored someone say something stupid

What’s an alt?

[Comical]

Alright, let’s do something. I feel scum aren’t in a hurry to get this game going at all.

@RCEnigma - What’s stood out to you the most?

[Comical]

Alright, let’s do something. I feel scum aren’t in a hurry to get this game going at all.

@RCEnigma - What’s stood out to you the most?

You’re allowed to say “When Comical questioned RCEnigma about what’s stood out the most.”

[Comical]

I don't think the Clidd vs comical stuff is all that interesting and Clidd is in this weird space where I'm reading the reactions around his wagon and not him per say.

Pine being caught up between the two is... Ok. He could be scum but he has precedent for town lurking that makes it unlikely he's today's lynch.

Same, Clidd bores me now.

I don't think the Clidd vs comical stuff is all that interesting and Clidd is in this weird space where I'm reading the reactions around his wagon and not him per say.

Pine being caught up between the two is... Ok. He could be scum but he has precedent for town lurking that makes it unlikely he's today's lynch.

Pretty sure Pine isn't scum.

This conjunction of a nilly is interesting. I wouldn’t think there’s enough content out of anyone yet to assume this? Especially considering the Clidd-Pine contraption of a contraband corkscrew of a case.

Pretty sure Pine isn't scum.

how do u and everyone else seemingly already have a read on pine lol

You can have a lot of laughs thrown your way. Laughs are good, always good.

Why are people saying Firebringer is open scumming? Is he normally all rough and rowdy?

[Comical]

lol but also on the flip we have alchemist who says hes the real scum of comical v clidd but the dude has three posts that arent walls or anyhting crazy like that

I think Clidd was kinda right that Pine's vote on him was weak, and Pine's overall entrance was weak. Additionally, if I drew 3 names from the 12 of you the odds that at least one of the names were scum is ~60%, and I know 3 slots interacting isn't exactly random but I think it's still a good way to look at it and I'm thinking both Clidd and Comical are Town. It's not like I'm 100% sure on Pine being scum but I think it's a good vote.

Why does Clidd vote me instead of Pine, though.

[Comical]

Oh mah bad then yo

[Comical]

Why do something tomorrow when you can do it today?

VOTE: Pine

comical second scum, any normal town wouldn't change his vote on me

Foolish of you to assume that I am what they call a normal town.

I also didn't vote you in the first place, so what do you mean by change their vote?

why would you vote pine ?

1. you are trying to gain towncred because you know i will flip town

2. you didn't explain why are you sheeping me

3. if we change to Pine, and he's your partner, it would be a hard buss to gain towncred by doing it

4. im a easy misslynch later, which is also a reason why you are trying to keep me alive

and these reasons

@comical

I think they’re absolutely fake reasons tbh. If you think Pine is scum individually, then I vote Pine, and from that you deduce Pine/Comical scum team, yet choose to go Comical instead of Pine based on a bussing theory that stems from the one Pine who is being voted by me anyways. I fail to see why that logic makes sense

[Comical]

Is he normally like that? Because if he isn't, that's definitely scum indicative derp

[Comical]

I heard 3 more

[Comical]

He’s still pushing me as being scum with Pine, but I haven’t even unvoted Pine.

If that’s the case, call my bluff and kill him then.

To be fair, I don’t think I actually think Pine-Clidd is the team, and I am more leaning towards Clidd being scum because he’s derp tunneling, and not in a townie way.

[Comical]

Yes, but Clidd, assuming you’re correct based on a page 6 read is insanely ignorant, and post game, if you are town, you should really take consideration in seeing the weaknesses in your play, in addition to learning how even if you think someone is scum, you still need to be able to work with said player in the case you are wrong, which you are here.

[Comical]

Yes, but Clidd, assuming you’re correct based on a page 6 read is insanely ignorant, and post game, if you are town, you should really take consideration in seeing the weaknesses in your play, in addition to learning how even if you think someone is scum, you still need to be able to work with said player in the case you are wrong, which you are here.

you kinda sound like you know you're talking to town

He probably is town.

[Comical]

And if you read that post from the perspective of me giving him the benefit of the doubt, that’s EXACTLY what I’m talking about.

[Comical]

I have an role that can confirm me eventually, you won’t have to worry about me; I never am not night killed this game.

[Comical]

Now that all these shenanigans are over with, let me give you my real scum reads.

It’s Auro-Eddie Cane, and they’ve come across as potential partners for me all game. I was kind of afraid to push them because I’m an unknown, and I was going to wait a little bit before seriously going towards them. I scum read them both individually, however, EC moreso than Auro.

But it’s still Day 1, I could be wrong. I see that.

VOTE: Eddie Cane

If you think I ever make this play as scum as an unknown here with Clidd tunneling me, and Dannflor just having voted me, so be it.

[Comical]

This also does risk outing me, of course, but whatever’s clever, ya know

[Comical]

Spoiler:

My mafia team doesn't have day chat, so I would like to tell them that Auro is not a PR.

I think the fact nobody has commented on me this game spews me town, because my partners haven't tried to fake interactions.

My mafia team has informed me we do, in fact, have day chat. Apologies.

I really like rce for town, and I know I can get him pocketed if I keep repeating that.

I have no opinion on whether either of those players share my alignment.

Its probably more exciting than this game.

it makes me sad that i invited u and ur not having fun

I wouldn't say

un

fun. Its not like I'm mad I'm here.

I have an idea. Let's make an alliance and kill people. This is an apocalyptic Earth we are living in, and fuck mafia and town, we need allies.

I would like to invite Pine, OkaPoka, Firebringer, Auro, and Alchemist to my alliance.

On one hand, I think clidd is scummier than Dann.

On the other hand,lynching Dann day 1 is funnier regardless of his flip.

I have never played with clidd but all of his posts sound like scum trying too hard.

Yes, but Clidd, assuming you’re correct based on a page 6 read is insanely ignorant, and post game, if you are town, you should really take consideration in seeing the weaknesses in your play, in addition to learning how even if you think someone is scum, you still need to be able to work with said player in the case you are wrong, which you are here.

you kinda sound like you know you're talking to town

Now look at all these posts. Yes, Eddie Cane has a personality where he can do this, similar to Firebringer in that manner, but the reason I think it’s scum indicative is this mixed with his pushes and his statements. This was all gut before his most recent posts. He was pushing Clidd as scummy try hard, similar to how I was, but then goes to say I seem to “know clidd’s town”.

However, look at EC’s posting with a mindset of him knowing that Clidd is town. His entire latter half of his ISO is fueling fire in a behind the scenes gamestate kind of manner.

[Comical]

Also, I’m trying not to use meta, but Auro is screaming scumAuro to me. Short quips, jokes, simple “to be fair” like comments.

And scum theatre looking posts with EC.

[Comical]

And Dann, if you’re reaction testing to see if a wagon was going to brew on me, it was going to be a slow build to it, not immediately.

If you’re actually scum reading me, which I by no means believe you are, which is good because I think you’re town, but if you are, you’re incredibly far off on your basis for it.

Penguin’s an early town read for light hearted, kinda just here playing the game, no real agenda like posting. Not setting themselves up positioning wise like EC.

[Comical]

So who’s trying to dance, because I’ll two step with the best of them

[Comical]

However, look at EC’s posting with a mindset of him knowing that Clidd is town. His entire latter half of his ISO is fueling fire in a behind the scenes gamestate kind of manner.

I wanna say that this is happening while at the same time the presence itself is seeming to still be at the forefront, but the gamestate manipulation is in full effect behind the scenes.

[Comical]

Eddie Cane has a personality where he can do this

You know who I am?

Even if I didn’t, I’d be able to tell

[Comical]

I wanna say that this is happening while at the same time the presence itself is seeming to still be at the forefront, but the gamestate manipulation is in full effect behind the scenes.

were you never taught that using big words for no reason does not make you sound smarter?

I’ll say short improper grammar and still make a case, I’m not worried about sounding smart, that’ll come across on it’s own

But I like the choice of discredit play.

[Comical]

I also realized there’s this aura of suspicion around me, and I’m aware that this is because, as I said before, I’m an unknown, and I clearly know you guys, so I am hiding things. I don’t expect me to stay hidden, tbh, but I’m trying.

[Comical]

This wasn’t a good player list for me to be an unknown in really. I just know every single player in this game too well, with the exception of Clidd, who is hands down the player I know the least here.

[Comical]

You don't know me very well if you think this is my mafia play.

To be fair, I have already stated that I don’t think people should think they are correct at this point in the game.

I believe pushing you here is the correct play. If I’m wrong, I’ll figure it out.

[Comical]

Before Day 1’s end, I’ll be outed. This game’s got too solid of a player list for me to want to miss out on it.

[Comical]

Your posting style admittedly sounds familiar.

Oh, definitely. I technically would say that I was casually “disguising my voice” earlier, and this past page that just got thrown out the window. Not on purpose, I just had stuff to say.

[Comical]

I guarantee you there’s a couple people here who will figure it out now. I’m going to let them figure it out, though, because I still need to see what Clidd does, how people start setting them up differently once they realize I’m not going to be an easy push for the day.

[Comical]

UNVOTE: EC

Real time interaction changed my perception of the gamestate.

[Comical]

You’re fine with me for now, skirt skirt

[Comical]

I might go back to Clidd.

[Comical]

Pretty sure Comical dislikes me as a player lol
@Comical if that's true then I know who you are

It is not true

[Comical]

I guarantee you there’s a couple people here who will figure it out now.

I mean...it's obvious...

It’s so obvious, haha

[Comical]

anyway, i need time to think . i am discouraged from reading all the last pages, but eventually i will.

the way she approached me now was in a better tone, without that arrogant and cynical persona that I was perceiving earlier

i'm probably wrong about her being lockscm

UNVOTE: comical

I actually feel I was more arrogant the last page

[Comical]

I specifically said I know everyone, including Luna Fox, who I didn’t know was a secret alt...?

[Comical]

Alchemist is pretty scummy. He comes off as Scummie when he’s town, but to other people.

The TvT push of Clidd.

He could be just correct town, though, but I wanted to put this out there in case I need to go back and see how my reads were developing later.

[Comical]

Also, I don’t believe I ever stated you were wrong and therefore scum.

I actually said the exact opposite

[Comical]

VOTE: Clidd

Day 2 onwards

[Comical]

Let’s just kill Clidd and move on. I need to know if they’re town or scum in my bones, y’all

[Comical]

but #525 still looks like it TMIs Clidd town

Everyone thinks I TMI all the time as town, but really, I’m just good.

[Comical]

I am really really trying not to speak with OkaPoka because I have a hard time calling him by his name, and until I’m fully outed...

[Comical]

I am really really trying not to speak with OkaPoka because I have a hard time calling him by his name, and until I’m fully outed...

HOKEY POKEY!!!!!!

[Comical]

Did somebody say L-2?

VOTE: Pine

[Comical]

Very disappointing. I put Pine to L-1 3 minutes after EC posts.

[Comical]

Hokey pokey

[Comical]

RCE is likely scum.

[Comical]

RCEnigma-EC-Auro

Less sure on ec even less sure on Auro

[Comical]

VOTE: RCEnigma

Next day!

[Comical]

The way he’s focusing on what “should have scum” is evident of knowing where scum actually is, and using it as a solid push for scum to make to get a mislynch on top of not seeming incorrect still.

[Comical]

Oka has been townie to me for a while now, and Alchemist has come across as town to me also from this day phase. Yesterday with Alchemist I thought he could have been scum for pushing a TvT route with Clidd and I, and I do generally think that could be a thing, but the more I’m accepting Clidd of just likely being town, it just makes sense.

[Comical]

I can see that reasoning, though I still don't think it's wrong to want to lynch on the Pine wagon rather than off.

I’m sure there’s still a scum or 2 on the Pine wagon.

RCE is just scum off the wagon.

[Comical]

RCE is likely scum.

Even if so, trying to dismantle my 1v1 with Alch implies he's likely partners with him.

Fair, actually. This gives me some better vibes with Auro actually, taken directly from Alch’s stash.

[Comical]

Alch clearly knew how I was, so if they’re scum together, RCE is faking not knowing

[Comical]

I think there’s slight RCE-Dann vibes out there, but I don’t feel like pushing that at all right now. Save for later

[Comical]

I have an obvious guilty on RCE. Yes, that’s me

[Comical]

I targeted RCE because I wanted to get someone I could trust to follow if town.

[Comical]

For the sake, I will not be full claiming, and we don’t have to lynch RCE today, as long as it’s ingrained in your head I have a guilty on RCE because neither of us last this game that means.

Don’t lynch me today, and scum either have to kill me tonight, or you guys can lynch me a bit later for surety on my night actions.

Sound good?

[Comical]

RCE is likely scum.

This was my opening to this day, and essentially I was going to leave it at that, try to coast out a few more nights, but here we are.

[Comical]

He's gambiting or scumclaiming. I went nowhere last night.

Claim.

[Comical]

Why do I feel like I'm the only person who hasnt figured out Comical.

Because I’m shy around you, and I’m hiding so you can’t see my love.

[Comical]

Luna’s not even a hidden alt.

[Comical]

He's gambiting or scumclaiming. I went nowhere last night.

Claim.

I'm an even night role.

Claim the role.

[Comical]

I’m an X-shot.

[Comical]

I wonder who’s discussing with RCE on what he should claim.

[Comical]

For the sake, I will not be full claiming, and we don’t have to lynch RCE today, as long as it’s ingrained in your head I have a guilty on RCE because neither of us last this game that means.

Don’t lynch me today, and scum either have to kill me tonight, or you guys can lynch me a bit later for surety on my night actions.

Sound good?

Actually, we specifically don’t have to kill either of us.

[Comical]

Eddie, would you consider Comical close to locktown at this point?

I'm the cop, so I don't need reads.

I think we should end up pushing here sometime today too.

[Comical]

So what was I doing again.
Oh yeah
VOTE: Penguin

Aren't you interested in what's going on between RCE and Comical?

Not right at this point, unless Comical says that whatever RCE is saying is 100% Lie based on role info.

He says I took an action last night but I'm an even night role.

Where’d I ever say you took an action last night? You said that

[Comical]

Well, I have a pretty hard guilty on RCE, and likely a counter claim to Eddie Cane, but he was pushing that as a “joke” claim, sure, but you can see I was seeing EC as scum yesterDay before our interactions anyways.

[Comical]

Auro, I actually don’t think you’re scum here. Alchemist, I could see you as scum, but I’m going to give you the benefit of the doubt because you seem like you’re genuinely coming to conclusions, and I feel I would gut scum read you if you were scum.

[Comical]

You said you tracked me.

Definitely didn’t.

You guys in your scum PT probably just assumed I tracked you, which means you made the night kill, which I feel also makes sense in this gamestate.

[Comical]

Why do we have to turn it into a 1v1? If we leave them both alive won’t it resolve itself?

Yep. That’s essentially what I pushed for too.

[Comical]

Idanyboy
Okapoka

They’re town.

Auro/Alch I cant fully town read here, but definitely leaning that way.

Luna going RCE could be bussing based on a guilty, because one scum would definitely bus here at least, but she’s rather hard bussing, so I still think it’s town indicative, but a step below Auro/Alch right now.

[Comical]

Don’t get me wrong, I’ll lynch RCEnigma. But I don’t think we have to have to today.

Dannflorr has town equity because of that and EC/RCE setting gamestate up against them both casually.

[Comical]

Spicey take:

Eddie Cane, Luna Fox, and Penguinpower are the scumteam.

Looks a little worse for Luna here, but regardless, I feel EC is scum here.

[Comical]

Well, I have a pretty hard guilty on RCE, and likely a counter claim to Eddie Cane, but he was pushing that as a “joke” claim, sure, but you can see I was seeing EC as scum yesterDay before our interactions anyways.

You claimed a guilty?

“There’s a scumchat?”

[Comical]

Spicey take:

Eddie Cane, Luna Fox, and Penguinpower are the scumteam.

I have no opinion on whether either of those players share my alignment.

how is the scum pt these days?

Its probably more exciting than this game.

This even looks like EC appeasing to Firebringer. Like ScumEC can easily get town read by certain players by acting like this.

[Comical]

For Firebringer: we raise our drinks to you on this one.

VOTE: Eddie Cane

[Comical]

Important question why go for RCE and not EC if you scumread EC or did you scumread RCE at day end?

May I answer this tomorrow if I’m alive?

If it helps, I definitely wrote a paragraph to Schadd about my exact reasoning for this.

I didn’t scumread RCE. I went in where I thought it could be an Inno or a guilty.

If I was going to get an Inno, I wanted a strong Inno from someone who I can work really well with, and nobody screams that more to me here than RCE.

[Comical]

Don’t get me wrong, I’ll lynch RCEnigma. But I don’t think we have to have to today.

Dannflorr has town equity because of that and EC/RCE setting gamestate up against them both casually.

This is 100% a scum!FL move to hold a 1v1 without actually needing to have the 1v1.

Prove your guilty.

I will after you claim.

[Comical]

If you’re going to try and 1v1 me, we need to be incredibly concrete.

Claim RCE. If you’re somehow town in this, just claim.

[Comical]

if I flip green

[Comical]

So hes picking the wrong 1v1.

Why would I pick “the wrong 1v1” as scum?

Actually, you should full claim too.

RCE claims, EC claims, then I claim. You can change the order on them.

[Comical]

If you’re going to try and 1v1 me, we need to be incredibly concrete.

Claim RCE. If you’re somehow town in this, just claim.

I won't. If you were town here you wouldn't hardclaim a guilty without being sure.

You're scum here.

If you’re a Vig, you could just shoot me then.

[Comical]

Isn’t that what your trying to imply here and threaten me? I’m actively sitting here allowing for you to shoot me, cause my flip does confirm you as scum.

[Comical]

I don’t think EC needs to claim.

I actually specifically need him to claim. At least if he’s serious about the cop claim, because I do kinda counterclaim that.

[Comical]

If he’s a cop, awesome, we have him and an Inno.

Then RCE is caught scum, then that would be 3 conftownies going into night, possibly with a protective out there still

[Comical]

OH FUCK THERE ARE NO COPS

[Comical]

Where is Comical hard claiming a guilty?
This game is getting confusing.

I have like a 95% hard guilty and the fact there are no cops makes it even moreso that I’m right here.

@Luna - Me not paying attention is a townie movie, right?

[Comical]

I request the service of any vigilantes out there. May we work together to create a game solve?

[Comical]

If you’re going to try and 1v1 me, we need to be incredibly concrete.

Claim RCE. If you’re somehow town in this, just claim.

I won't. If you were town here you wouldn't hardclaim a guilty without being sure.

You're scum here.

Do you really believe this to be true regardless of who Comical is?

Depends. If it was someone that wasn't familiar with soft guiltys and psuedo investigatives I could give leeway to a misinterpretation.

I don't have a role that false positives afaik

. A vanilla or neapolitan wouldn't be enough to hardclaim a guilty on.

Aight, I’m a Gunsmith.

RCE has a gun

[Comical]

I didn’t target EC because he joked about being a Cop, so if I ever pushed him for having a gun, he would have been able to use that and go, see I am a Cop! But i forgot there was no cop

[Comical]

Lol I'm an even night gunsmith

I’m an X-shot Gunsmith.

[Comical]

Lynch in me/comical today as direct CCs.

Why does your mind instantly go to that? That’s scum indicative. I was about to say leave us both alive, get another result from both of us, then can kill in us.

Double town gunsmith IS possible.

[Comical]

The fact RCE says his role isn’t false positive is something.

@RCE - We were the same role in Detective Penguin as town, why does your mind immediately go to that?

I clearly saw that you had a Gun. In what world does scum see that and push it as a guilty?

[Comical]

This is a Schadd game.

I’m gonna tell you right now, my X is a 6.

[Comical]

I am a 6 shot gunsmith. I completely believe there is another town gunsmith on the same side.

However, RCE could just be a scum gunsmith.

[Comical]

Hmm. So scum!Comical would have to be a rolecop or a gunsmith to know RCE's role. It is a strange push because he would assume RCE is a vig if he's gunsmith, which just gets him shot. I'd imagine he's a better night kill n2 with GS results. Rolecop with another fake gunsmith gambit, maybe.

I was also actively trying to figure out if RCE was a Vig or not because if he was, I would have stepped away for a second.

He claimed it super fast, AND it does solve the has a gun thing, I think it’s likely town, but tinfoil scum, if that makes sense.

[Comical]

Hmm. So scum!Comical would have to be a rolecop or a gunsmith to know RCE's role. It is a strange push because he would assume RCE is a vig if he's gunsmith, which just gets him shot. I'd imagine he's a better night kill n2 with GS results. Rolecop with another fake gunsmith gambit, maybe.

I'm actually inclined to believe FL is t a rolecop here. He'd see I'm even night and propose me for the nk before I get a result. Idk if scum gunsmith is a thing but I could see scum viewing a possible vig as a threat and claiming a guilty there.

But why do I claim the guilty over another one of the partners who could get away with more than that.

I specifically full outed this day phase too for it, which lowers credibility on claim.

[Comical]

Also, why would I EVER claim the 6 shot aspect of it?

[Comical]

Fair. I didn’t wanna claim, though. You can see from the beginning I was originally gonna just push it softly like that to get more results.

[Comical]

I feel like we should just mass claim.

Town with guns needs to be outed.

[Comical]

Like, it sucks because I don’t wanna push her, but I think it’s Luna.

[Comical]

I don't even think town with guns need to be outed, could just as easily be mafia docs and no town with guns. That said, with 2 VT dead, yea, mass claiming should be fine. I like the logic puzzle of parsing claims anyways.

Essentially, yeah.

[Comical]

So everyone, just claim when you come on.

Earlier you claim, the more cookies you get

[Comical]

Noting the people who aren’t claiming.

I feel mass claim is best in this scenario.
protective, you’re likely gonna die soon, but nobody will trust your protective claim later in the game, so speak now or forever hold your peace.

[Comical]

UNVOTE: EC

[Comical]

Oka,

Clidd, EC, Dann, and Idanny makes sense as all town in multiple scenarios. Why are they being pushed by you AND you’re refusing to claim?

[Comical]

Yeah. Are you VT

[Comical]

Add myself and RCE, that’s 6 people who I can see as town.

Penguin
Luna
Okapoka
Alchemist
Auro

There is a world where all scum are in this list, and I believe we might be in it.

[Comical]

Tracker or watcher

[Comical]

Follower or voyeur

[Comical]

Dann, and Idanny

I say we make a Dan townblock. Doesn’t seem to fail very often, so let’s d’ot.

[Comical]

Classic PP.

Who got the fruit

[Comical]

Why do we have to turn it into a 1v1? If we leave them both alive won’t it resolve itself?

This is a town mindset.

[Comical]

danny whats ur thought on the eddie cane

I thought could be scum but that read doesn't excite me as much anymore

This is kind of where I’m at too.

And RCEnigma I’m really kind of just feeling is actually town now. The whole way that went about, unless scum figured out what I was, and they tried to claim my role first, but idk. We’ll figure that out sometime, I guess, but gut wise I’m feeling pretty strongly townRCE, and I feel like that wouldn’t be the case if he were scum.

[Comical]

Who was pushing Dann yesterday besides Eddie. Scum is likely in there

[Comical]

Dannflor (5):

RCEnigma

,

Auro

,

Firebringer

,

Eddie Cane

, Luna Fox

Pine

(7): Alchemist21,

Firebringer

, OkaPoka, Dannflor,

Auro

,

Comical

,

Eddie Cane

Luna Fox is probably scum, yeah.

OkaPoka increasingly became scummier, but I still feel he might be town. Dann “could” be scum, but I feel he is a mislynch setup in this gamestate.

[Comical]

Oh, scum with Auro

[Comical]

Auro, Luna Fox, Alchemist

[Comical]

Penguin/Okapoka are backup possibilities, followed by Clidd/Dann/RCE/EC

[Comical]

Dannflor (5):

RCEnigma

,

Auro

,

Firebringer

,

Eddie Cane

, Luna Fox

Based on this, I think we should lynch Luna. Auro was the only one on both wagons, and I think that’s scum indicative.

[Comical]

I think there’s a chance I’m 100% correct, and I’m at the point where I’m very accepting of me being wrong, but I feel from what I’ve got it makes sense.

This is if RCE isn’t pulling a giant fast one, EC isn’t lolcoasting scum, and Dann was being setup to be a mislynch.

If not all of those are true, then this doesn’t necessarily make sense as a solve, but I think each of those do make sense, and OkaPoka/Penguin I’m giving the benefit of the doubt for now, but I think going with this solve is a solid idea. It also will help you guys town read me depending if I’m way off or way right, either way could help you read me as town tbh, but I do feel like moving on ahead with the game in this path is beneficial.

[Comical]

Why is Okapoka scummy to you, Comical? Or is he just not-towny

Obnoxious devil’s advocate play in Day 2. He was townie in Day 1 for me, but something about the way the RCE-Comical changed his game positioning, whether that was due to him pivoting or it happening naturally is up for debate.

[Comical]

I’m not confident in the solve, but I don’t expect to be confident in solves if I do get something that spot on. I’m more confident in my pool.

[Comical]

Luna Fox - PP don’t seem very likely to me, and I do like PP’s crumb, which seems townie.

VOTE: Luna Fox

[Comical]

Luna Fox also fits the bill as someone who saw a townie guiltying a townie, and wanted it to continue

[Comical]

Also, learning from Detective Penguin, the last time RCE and I went at it, we were TvT

[Comical]

I actually feel if I’m wrong on one of those three, it’s Alchemist.

Auro vs Alchemist can look like scum theatre, but Auro just looks obv scum for the majority of this game in general, and he was asking a lot of fluff pointless questions, and made sure people noticed the 1v1 and had thoughts on it.

Auro just feels like sure scum, I felt this yesterday too. This is drastically different than the game I just played with him, and I think he got hyperactive based on being scum.

[Comical]

Luna Fox - PP don’t seem very likely to me, and I do like PP’s crumb, which seems townie.

VOTE: Luna Fox

If you're really gonna push this then you better bring out the big guns.
VOTE: Comical

I feel like I just did a giant radar sweep of an area, you pinged up on it, then you are coming out here to yell at me, knowing a radar scan just happened, and you just openly ran out and said “IF YOURE GOING TO FIND ME, YOU BETTER HAVE CAUGHT ME ON THE SCANNER”

[Comical]

more importantly is why are u mad at boon for voting you

I get mad at people that scumread me for no reason.

I have reasons, and I believe I stated them. Why are you saying there is no reason?

The reasons could be wrong, but from my perspective, the reasons are completely valid, and if you’re town you should see that. You might see them as incorrect reasons in that case, but there are reasons. This is a misrep.

[Comical]

*changing the narrative, not misrep

[Comical]

@RCEnigma - we should both target Auro tonight.

[Comical]

Protective, pick one of us to protect.

[Comical]

I still feel my pool is likely correct, so if Luna is town, who are scum in OkaPoka, Oka, Alchemist, Auro.

Possibly all 3 are in that if you are town, Luna

[Comical]

It’s not that I think your questions are bad, a lot of people get offended for being scum read but for the most part, I don’t usually scum read people who are playing badly. Most people who’ve been here a bit have a solid understanding on how to play scum, so surface level scum play is actually stronger than not, and it’s keeping up with that stuff.

Chainsawing used to be a strong scum move, then it became easily caught out, Hatcheting was huge and under the radar for a while, now it became pretty big and already scum don’t really hatchet too much anymore. It just keeps going in circles.

Side note, I’m actually creating a Board Game since I have a few games in stock right now, and it’s kind of like a Pokémon meets Chess like game, maybe add a little Dominion. Cryptid theme.

[Comical]

I might have to figure out a way to play online for some play tests...if anyone’s eventually interested. Not sure when, might not be for a while, but I do plan on getting a rough draft of mechanics sometime this week. I’ve had the specific game mechanics down since I was in high school (i graduated 2012...) now it’s just time to create a prototype.

[Comical]

It's mildly frustrating that Comical didn't check me last night - considering Boon himself gets paranoid of me a lot, and I seem to get pushed on bad reasoning merely because I have more content and it's easier to find reasons to scumread me (woo, WF all over again!). Sigh.

I almost did after EC joked cop.

[Comical]

Ok Auro. Those WF quotes are enough for me to give you some breathing room here.

UNVOTE: Auro

Lol, right when I think I could be wrong on Auro, this happens. Auro/Alch team.

Auro did correctly town read in a recent game almost too much and i thought he was possible scum for it.

[Comical]

I'm thinking Luna. Her reaction to fakehammer was towny but then I noticed this tell.

I misread cult!RCE as town just recently in a game where I was trying to lynch cult.
I'm hard-townreading Boon from his unawareness of Cop (heavy doubt he'd fake), his progression on me ending at {let's check Auro} which is sort of unnecessary as scum, his inconsistency in reading me, and consistency between his claim and play.

Besides, you didn't even account for the possibility that I was stating a lock read on Comical to see how he would react. tsk tsk

Why can't mafia be just as unaware of the Cop stuff though? I don't see how that's AI.

Why can't mafia be just as unaware of the Cop stuff though? I don't see how that's AI.

Because it's Boon.

Here’s the difference, they’re right. As scum, I would heavily be faking it if I did that. As town, it’s legit.

[Comical]

eddie are you just flexing with how much you can get away with as scum on ms.net to prove how we all suck

Let it be known that this is definitely what scum-Eddie would be doing this game.

That said I don't really have any issue with him thus far.

+3

[Comical]

However, if RCE AWAS A maf Gunsmith, hed know he has a gun.

RCE’s likely just town.

Penguin vs Luna is likely TvS, where the S is I’m not sure. SS probably town.

I’m hard gut reading Dann as town, which means EC is scum, but i don’t think they’re ever scum together, but I do think ts getting planted that they could be if one of them flips scum.

Auro’s scummy af, but he did do this in Espeonage’s game to me where he was town.

However, he did do this in Espeonageks game to me...where he was town...if that makes sense.

[Comical]

HokeyPokey is setting things up. And Alchemist/Auro look super SvS, tbh.

Auro
Luna Fox
PenguinPower
Okapoka
Alchemist

I feel I’ve seen this list before...where oh where was it...?

[Comical]

Add myself and RCE, that’s 6 people who I can see as town.

Penguin
Luna
Okapoka
Alchemist
Auro

There is a world where all scum are in this list, and I believe we might be in it.

Oh, right

[Comical]

Luna knows. I have believe she said that to setup some discrediting if she’s scum.

She’s the one that points out me not paying attention is townie.



Guys, I’m not good scum anymore. I’m town here

[Comical]

But I’m pretty great as town right now.

[Comical]

Luna knows. I have believe she said that to setup some discrediting if she’s scum.

I mean, you just linked back to a post from several days ago with the exact same reads that you have now. It's not really up for debate that you're being consistent in this case.

That said, one data point does not a trend make.

To be fair, that was purposeful.

My dry sass doesn’t come across well over typing, but I think that’s comical in its own right

[Comical]

I’m hard gut reading Dann as town, which means EC is scum, but i don’t think they’re ever scum together, but I do think ts getting planted that they could be if one of them flips scum.

Why can't we both be town?

Eh, you can both be town.

I was kind of thinking out loud.

I’m gonna lol trust you right now anyways until I need to not

[Comical]

I don’t think Dann flips scum. I think he’s a designated mislynch

[Comical]

I think EC is being used by scum in that regard

[Comical]

Alchemist/Okapoka still making sense, I feel.

Hokey Pokey’s threat towards me made me a little more sure on that, however I have a tendency to scum read Okapoka naturally, so I don’t think that’s as strong a read.

I feel like we should stick to my pool. Generally when I’m forgotten/ignored, it means my pool is correct.

Look at Titus vs Alisae. Look at that game I mislynched PP.

I actually don’t think I’m 100% correct here, but I think I have some good odds.

Usually when I’m not overly confident I actually do better than that too.

I think Dannfloor is town.

[Comical]

Oka Poka is a fine vote, but it’s not the best one. Still figuring out who.

Probably Alchemist.

[Comical]

Y’all keep saying Danny, and it’s really throwing me off

[Comical]

I’m usually 60% correct or above, and generally do not make the wrong decision late game

[Comical]

EC and I also have opposite reads.

[Comical]

Is that way of reading it...because you’re part of the informed minority?

[Comical]

VOTE: Okapoka

[Comical]

I feel like we should stick to my pool. Generally when I’m forgotten/ignored, it means my pool is correct.

When you keep changing your reads rapidly and haphazardly, you don't think being ignored is a consequence?

I thought someone said I was consistent

[Comical]

Lynch Hokey Pokey

[Comical]

I thought someone said I was consistent

Contexts
You've been incredibly inconsistent about me.

Town tell. Ask Luna.

[Comical]

Nah, we’re lynching anyone with a Gun, tbh.

It’s far past the time to avoid that.

Also, clears should not be considered clears.

[Comical]

Unless a maf doc flips

[Comical]

VOTE: idany

this game ain't big enough for the both of us

There’s 3 of us.

And Idany is town

[Comical]

im a doctor vig

do i have a gun

This is not okay right now, btw.

This just gives scum options to go out

[Comical]

I thought someone said I was consistent

Contexts
You've been incredibly inconsistent about me.

Town tell. Ask Luna.

I'm not sure I like how you keep telling people to ask me about your town tells when you've been pushing me.

Honestly, you need to get past this. I’m far passed seeing you as the most likely scum.

[Comical]

Idany is even more obv mislynch bait than Dannflorr. He’s the “i don’t know where to go!!! I’m gonna go somewhere I don’t have a read on!”

Instead of the blatant obvious that scum is somewhere in the midst of everything.

Idany has zero reason to have allowed RCE and I to just resolve ourselves, ESPECIALLY if we are actually both town, which I believe we are.

In this regard, Idany should NEVER be lynched before RCE/Myself die

[Comical]

VOTE: idany

this game ain't big enough for the both of us

There’s 3 of us.

And Idany is town

You’re not a Dan.

Disagree

[Comical]

Idany is even more obv mislynch bait than Dannflorr. He’s the “i don’t know where to go!!! I’m gonna go somewhere I don’t have a read on!”

Instead of the blatant obvious that scum is somewhere in the midst of everything.

Idany has zero reason to have allowed RCE and I to just resolve ourselves, ESPECIALLY if we are actually both town, which I believe we are.

In this regard, Idany should NEVER be lynched before RCE/Myself die

Sometimes scum just...freeze?

Why is it more likely scum have frozen here then?

It’s day 2. They’re not in any real danger this day. Why would scum be frozen here?

[Comical]

I go by Danny/Danathon in the real world.

[Comical]

I mean - that’s a player thing and not a game state thing.

We’re not reading player by player, there’s a full scum team still out there. So it would have to be a Team thing rather than a player thing here, which DOES make it a game state thing

[Comical]

I just don’t think Idany or Dann are scum

[Comical]

Honestly, you need to get past this. I’m far passed seeing you as the most likely scum.

Sorry, I didn't see it.

Well, it’s there. I don’t even think I’m still voting you nor have my past like few pages of content been pushing you.

You are 100% still in my pool, but I don’t care to push it right now tbh.

Okapoka/Alchemist/Auro are in my focus right now, while PP/LF I’ve kind of pushed to the side and let handle themselves.

[Comical]

Why should we town read you rather than think you’re scum saying we should be town reading you?

[Comical]

Y’all, you think my Boon puns are something else, you should have seen me when I worked at the San Francisco Dungeon.

WELCOME...TO THE DAN DAN CISCO DAN GEON. HOPE YOU HAVE A DANTASTIC TIME

[Comical]

No, no IDan

[Comical]

Actually, go for it. I’m probably playing devil’s advocate for the sake of it, and I’m not actually super super town on them. They could be scum.

But I’m just not gonna vote it unless I’m hammering outta nowhere