Pikmin Mafia - Game over

[mikeburnfire]

Vote Count!
With 10 alive, it will take 6 to lynch.

2 Porochaz (Claus, armlx)
1 Greasy Spot (skitzer)
1 The Jester (Nightson)
1 Xdaamno (Kison)
Not voting: dcorbe, Greasy Spot, The Jester, Porochaz, Xdaamno

Prodding: dcorbe; The Jester; Porochaz; skitzer

[Porochaz]

*bump*

I concur.

I think I'm just gonna go ahead and

Vote Porochaz

. The issue was his lurking here, which reminds me a lot of his behavior in Weather Mafia as Mafia Godfather (post every few days with something really short and semi-relevant). Though it looks like a small sample size, I can see the pattern already developing. Also another ongoing to support this.

ok armlx what do you want to know?

[Claus]

Who are your scum buddies?

[skitzer]

Mod: dcorbe has not been on the site for quite a while. He needed replacement in my game, so maybe you should look for a replacement.

I'm still pretty content with my vote. Purple Pikmin are strong, so whatever the Purple Pikmin's ability is (if they have one) is likely to be strong. I don't think there would be two in a game.

[Porochaz]

Who are your scum buddies?

I think the question really is who isn't my scumbuddies. Seriously though, any proper questions?

[The Jester]

Here's what I got.

Xdaamno, lurks, and doesn't say his own opinion too much. Seems to follow the majority.

dcorbe replaced, so he hasn't said too much. Once talks about setting up a GS lynch tomorrow if they can get more evidence. Once says he'll contribute more the next day but doesn't post until eight days later with a vote: WK.

Ghostwriter, handful of wagon-jumping. Defended sonickid. I agree he there are more scum-tells on Poro/GW then dcorbe.

Vote: Poro

I still don't like dcorbe's trying to setup a later GS wagon when he didn't feel it "productive" at the time.

[armlx]

Mod: dcorbe has not been on the site for quite a while. He needed replacement in my game, so maybe you should look for a replacement.

I'm still pretty content with my vote. Purple Pikmin are strong, so whatever the Purple Pikmin's ability is (if they have one) is likely to be strong. I don't think there would be two in a game.

I don't like this logic at all for infinite reasons.

FOS Skitzer

, I think he is just fishing for a lynch on an easy to lynch player.

[skitzer]

What makes Greasy Spot easier to lynch than others? I think he has been incredibly dodging lynches so I wouldn't call him easy.

[armlx]

What makes Greasy Spot easier to lynch than others? I think he has been incredibly dodging lynches so I wouldn't call him easy.

How is his dodging lynches incredible? What has he done to deserve a lynch besides his reactions to the dumb wagons so far, which is what he does every time regardless of alignment hence him being an easy lynch.

Also, how is his purple claim questionable in the slightest? With the info we have about whites, why do you suspect purples have some kind of role too powerful to have 2 of in the game?

[Kison]

Skitzer, please both answer Armlx's question and explain why you believe Greasy Spot is your preferred lynch.

I'm also curious about why armlx and Claus both seem to have largely ignored me as a lynch candidate for the past two days.

[Claus]

Because there were better candidates?

Yesterday we claimed and lynched JtP for his "I'm a bomb" thing. Today we're comparing the reds.

[Kison]

Yes, better candidates, but you two seemed pretty certain(well, armlx, at least) that I was scum for a good while. I haven't heard a peep about it in a long time, which is strangely odd to me.

Post 11: Only serious vote is Kison
Post 14: Drops the suspicion on Kison, without a good reason, when attacked.

Ah. I forgot about this guy.

Unvote

Vote: Porochaz

Dcorbe, I dunno - a lot of his behavior, again, surrounds lurky tendencies, but he's lurked his way out of the game. Seriously, though. Dcorbe hasn't posted in this game in

a month

. That's ridiculous...

Could we please get a replacement/prod on Dcorbe?

[armlx]

Replacement on Dcorbe is better, he was replaced elsewhere too.

[armlx]

Yes, better candidates, but you two seemed pretty certain(well, armlx, at least) that I was scum for a good while. I haven't heard a peep about it in a long time, which is strangely odd to me.

The mass claim changed things. We now have possible set up or role based things to add to behavior.

Your vote seems kinda OMGUS though.

[Kison]

*shrugs* Claus speaks the truth - GhostWriter came after me and vanished when I started questioning him about it, then seemed to drop the suspicion as a whole after he resurfaced(maybe it was before, can't recall). I'm also not sure about Xdaamno, I'm getting more of the feeling he's simply lazy town than scum, but he seriously needs to start participating on a more regular basis. With Dcorbe, it's as you said - he needs to be replaced. Porochaz is here to respond to wagon pressure.

[armlx]

What about The Jester?

[Kison]

Reading through his posts, I don't find a whole lot that sticks out as particularly scummy. Perhaps the only thing I really don't like that I caught was how he tried to get the benefit of the color claim out of Gorrad on multiple occasions.

The problem with him, also, is that content from Jester/UA only begins very deep into the game, because UA was a nonexistent player. There is far less to analyze from him.

[Porochaz]

Porochaz has this game on his get back to within a short period of time list.

[skitzer]

armlx: I'm just amazed that I've been voting Greasy Spot every day now, and some people have actually agreed with me, but he hasn't been lynched yet.

Why I want to lynch him? I don't believe that this whole color claim thing is what it's meant to be. For starters:

Gorrad- Yellow
Xdaamno- Red
GhostWriter - Red
skitzer - Blue
Kison - Blue
armlx - Blue
Greasy Spot- purple
JamesThePhox- white
Nightson- white
Claus- bulbmin
The Jester- Red
dcorbe - Red

There were 6 red, 3 yellow, and 4 blue. Now, if any one claimed red pikmin became a yellow pikmin, then the numbers are 5-4-4, which is almost equal. Therefore, I'm not completely sold on the whole "red pikmin are scum" case.

Also, some selected posts:

HAHA...Don't get your panties in a bunch just yet. You pikmins are way too uptight. No wonder mod called you stupid.

I don't care if you call this semantics, it just seems so obvious that it must come from someone who isn't a pikmin.

No I'm a pikmin alright, just not a stupid pikmin like the mod called you all.

Don't know exactly about this, but aren't purple pikmin supposed to be slightly stupider than the other colors?

What the Hell...It's Hammah Time!

VOTE: ZombieSlayer54

What the Hell...It's Hammah Time!

VOTE: ZombieSlayer54

This was a strange hammer on Day 1. Especially with the lowered lynch vote.

IN many posts, he also pushes arguments off to the side (such as the "you stupid pikmin" slip and JamesThePhox's bomb ability. Also, I mentioned earlier how scum sonickid defended Greasy Spot. I believe there is perfectly enough reasoning to lynch Greasy Spot.

[Xdaamno]

Xdaamno (...) Seems to follow the majority.

Out of interest, what's the basis for this? If it's

only

my 'x, because that's who everyone else is voting' statement, then I don't think you understood what I was saying - I was going off statistics before I had analysed anything.

Which reminds me, I should probably analyse something. Hold on.

[Xdaamno]

I'm thinking either dcorbe('s replacement) or Jester here. If Jester's reasoning on my last post was indeed that single post, I think he was being jumpy. He was a lot more confrontational before these last two posts, not sure why.

I'm also not sure about Xdaamno, I'm getting more of the feeling he's simply lazy town than scum.

Right - though I want to play with you some other time, Kison, preferably not in a large game

[Claus]

Hey Skitzer,

There were 6 red, 3 yellow, and 4 blue. Now, if any one claimed red pikmin became a yellow pikmin, then the numbers are 5-4-4, which is almost equal. Therefore, I'm not completely sold on the whole "red pikmin are scum" case.

Except that this assumes that all "normal" pikmins are telling the truth, which would leave 3 out of 10 scum. One of those I know the alignment, so it would mean only 2 scum left. Don't you think that is a bit too little?

Then yes, we do have some scum among the colored pikmin.

Anyway - colors aside, what do you think of my re-reads of the reds. Do you disagree with the case on Porochaz? Why?

No I'm a pikmin alright, just not a stupid pikmin like the mod called you all.

Don't know exactly about this, but aren't purple pikmin supposed to be slightly stupider than the other colors?

The first quote was already beaten to death, but this second one really makes no sense - Are we supposed to roleplay our roles now in Theme games?

Really skitzer, don't push the "slip" points anymore. These are all null-tells.

Also, I mentioned earlier how scum sonickid defended Greasy Spot. I believe there is perfectly enough reasoning to lynch Greasy Spot.

Can you make the "sonickid defended him" argument again?

Also, I think there is enough reasoning to lynch Porochaz. Would you take a look at my case and compare it with your case on GS?

[armlx]

What Claus said about your first 2 points. And as said it was his death post that Sonic defended GS with so it means nothing due to WIFOM reasons.

[skitzer]

What I mean by the 2 point is that if GS is a purple pikmin, they are stupider than other pikmin. So he would be stupider than other colored pikmin, therefore that doesn't make sense.

What exactly makes the slips null tells? Have they faded away into nullness?

I'll check on your case on Porochaz later.

[armlx]

What I mean by the 2 point is that if GS is a purple pikmin, they are stupider than other pikmin. So he would be stupider than other colored pikmin, therefore that doesn't make sense.

Thats the dumbest argument I've heard against him so far......