SIR Disease Mafia - Game Over!

[pisskop]

What role did he crumb hoc?

[Hoctac]

He said he had some amazing ability but wanted to claim it after scum had used up their two nightkills. But then I think he claimed he was immune to infections anyway?

[pisskop]

amazing and totally not scummy

[Hoctac]

VOTE: pisskop

This guy maybe.

I’m down with this.
Because I feel as if this flips Scum, I was wrong on Hoctac.
If this flips Town, I’m right and Hoctac and Arti are scum and Town should just shoot them tonight.

VOTE: pisskop

So much for Hoc+poss being unaligned, huh? Now we're both scum apparently.

[pisskop]

hmm well maybe its a pr. that kind of behavior isnt out of question for town with a pr or w.e.

[TrueSoulEnergy]

VOTE: pisskop

This guy maybe.

I’m down with this.
Because I feel as if this flips Scum, I was wrong on Hoctac.
If this flips Town, I’m right and Hoctac and Arti are scum and Town should just shoot them tonight.

VOTE: pisskop

So much for Hoc+poss being unaligned, huh? Now we're both scum apparently.

So much for you guys getting lucky eh?
The more I pay attention the more accurate I become.
As such I can say that I was wrong on it being TvW and it’s actually WvW.

VOTE: Hoctac

[pisskop]

The more I pay attention the more accurate I become.

is tse usually this blustery?

[Firebringer]

How does anyone have A50 and FB as top town tier?

Wow rude. I am very townie.

[Firebringer]

FB doing nothing is unsurprising, I consistently scumread him for that,

Wow rude.

[Firebringer]

i am the apathy. it is me.

i dont have much to say on my scumreads. ive talked about my pisskop read over and over and over again, stemming back from saudade's posts. nothing pisskop has done has convinced me otherwise. firebringer's slot i thught was scum as of yday and his own play has just been discussing meta and whimsy. dont like how he made a big show of you pocketing him when he also called you naturally scummy. feels like blatant buddying.

fuck im wrong about nahdia

[Firebringer]

nero is def town tho. and he thinks nahdia is scum.
nero can have good reads. should i trust his reads.

[Firebringer]

i just realized im very close to making ms tee paranoid of me. All i have to do is call her town a dozen more times.

lampshading your own scumminess is never a good look imo.

silly nat, lampshades are cool

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Almost50

good enough for me.

[Firebringer]

i feel bad nat that i didn't come in here and rejuvenate the game for u. But i can't be the fire that lights this game a blaze right now. Its just not the mood im in when it comes to this game.

[Nahdia]

it would have taken nothing short of an inferno, friend.

ill look over a50's iso from today and consider it in more detail soon.

[davesaz]

Id keep you alive if you helped me but u arent so bye bye

So instead we lynch an infected and advance the scum wincon?

Sounds great.

Remind me why lynching infected advances scum wincon.
The way I read the setup it helps town not scum.

[davesaz]

Cheeky, can I just sheep you?

Please do.

Also A50/Nero not SvS.

Agreed!

And yay! =D
VOTE: Almost50

Sorry buddy. I'm not convinced by the claim issues but I want to see where this goes, and if your lynch gets us the associatives we need to solve the game, I'm in!

Why so exuberant about sheeping a bad vote?

[davesaz]

My answer to your question at Dave pertaining to myself was going to state exactly that! I don't think I am scumhunting well or very actively. I am definitely jumping on things as they appear. I am not reading back and making the cases I've promised. These are all facts.

Sadly, they don't make me scum, just underwhelming.

Well, they could make you scum and this could be lampshading (is that the right term?).

[pisskop]

The way I read the setup it helps town not scum.

eli5

Remind me why ot helps town to lynch infected.

wtf is with the guy with 'the thinker' as an avatar arguing with negatives?

[davesaz]

5a. Town Win Condition: Eliminate the mafia conspirers and all infected players.
5c. Mafia/Infected Win Condition: Gain parity with the town.

-infected -> town win. +infected -> scum win. This is an extremely simple concept.

Now, if the inferior logicians around here are talking about this:

5b. Town Alternate Win Condition: Have half or more of all living players gain permanent immunity to the disease.

Even

if

there is an infected->immune path (which is not publically proven to exist)
having someone become infected could trigger the mafia/infected win condition if the immunity lags behind infection.
Which means it's

still

in town's best interest to lynch at least some of the infected.

Scum lynch
If not scum lynch, then infected
If not infected, then useless

Whatever we do, don't lynch useful town.

[Covid 19]

Day 4 VC #9

Auro (0):

Hoctac (3): TrueSoulEnergy (6730), davesaz (6704), OkaPoka (6486)

Aristophanes (1): gobbledygook (6025)

LicketyQuickety (0):

TrueSoulEnergy (2): Hoctac (6722), pisskop (6724)

CheekyTeeky (1): Almost50 (6040)

Alchemist21 (0):

Nahdia (1): Nero Cain (6134)

Flavor Leaf (0):

Almost50 (3): CheekyTeeky (6546), Aristophanes (6555), Firebringer (6737)

Nero Cain (1): Alchemist21 (6138)

Firebringer (1): Nahdia (6231)

pisskop (1): LicketyQuickety (6490)

Not Voting (2): Flavor Leaf, Auro

With 16 alive, it takes 9 votes to lynch a player.

This phase will end on June 12, 2020 1:00 PM EDT (GMT-4:00) or in (expired on 2020-06-12 13:00:00).

Moderator Notes

1: If you have regular weekend V/LA, you must either notify me each time or set V/LA tags each time.
2:

Please note the prodding rules. You are prodded after 32 hours of inactivity on Tuesday-Friday.

3: I'm now modding this game on mobile as I can't get my computer to connect to the site. I'm not sure how long this will last, but it's possible that'll be the case through the rest of the game. (In practical terms, there shouldn't be too much of a difference. Errors are more likely and vote counts will take somewhat longer to make.)

[pisskop]

So again, why does lynching infected, who arent infecting more people, better or equal to lynching scum?

[pisskop]

Youre postulating that its perfectly acceptable to lynch a cultist instead of the leader. thats a losing proposition

[pisskop]

besides, hoc is hella-not scum. Youre using this hood as an excuse to not play. Weve already flipped 2 people from it, I am confirmed not original scum, and hoc is superfuckintown

[davesaz]

You aren't confirmed anything.
I just got through posting that lynching scum is best.
I'm not voting you nor even attempting to wagon you.
And Hoctac is absolutely not super anything. I'm fed up with people town reading someone for doing nothing.