[SETUP] Alternate-KP (Open 13p)

[Isis]

I would keep it at 13p since this seems to lean scumsided as it stands. But not so much I want to remove entire roles.. I think.
I'd maybe nudge it by making the rolecop a motiondetector

[Isis]

you could split it into an odd night and even night vig

I don't get the gripe with a PR having a lot of agency if you don't want certain slots to have more agency then play vanilla setups
It's a vig, not a governor, if you have a bad vig and want to win the setup have good reads and eliminate them

[Isis]

doccing the desperado cleared player over and over is a little boring but not the end of the world I guess

[Isis]

Indecisive on the doctor maybe

[Isis]

I think the Indecisive modifier fits the setup, it should be a pretty fun play pattern since it's actually defensible to just not protect the desperado cleared player sometimes even though you could. If you really don't like the Indecisive modifier then Even Night would be preferable rather than 2-shot since the 2-shot doctor might feel a little bad for shooting N1 before a D2 desperado incident. (2 shot Novice would more or less fix that concern but I don't expect that to be more appealing than indecisive.
Once you have a vig, doctor, and despie I think you want the more powerful roleblocker rather than the motion detector on the scum side of things.

[Isis]

i like that setup better than several approved opens fwiw

[Isis]

You can make it work however you want as long as you specify since it's an Open, but the normal way it would work is that the Vigilante is macho on both even and odd nights but can only perform kills on even nights.

[Isis]

I think so.

[Isis]

This is a good candidate for becoming an approved open setup if it tests well.

I checked with T-Bone and he said you can go ahead and queue to moderate this as a first time mod if you'd like to, if you have me as a backup mod. There's plans add more flexibility like this in the future so we can test more setups.

[Isis]

You should edit the OP to match the final setup since you linked the OP in the in-to-mod

[Isis]

The open queue has been unpredictable lately, but hopefully it fills

[Isis]

despy generates oddness/evenness issues in a 9p so it's just a named townie unless a protective role can connect

I think a cop and an IC against a mafia with PRs is considered balanced and a jk and an IC against a mafia with PRs is also considered balanced but the latter has boring game play from JK targetting the IC too often

So the most balanced mutation of this is IC+Cop. It isn't a setup I'd want to play but it's fine.