In post 1121, jankofan wrote:Actually it does hold water, because after the adorable ML they can just shoot the FN and pooky seems widely townread anyway.
The free ML + killing a widely townread slot gives it its positive utility.
Scum then NK the FN on N2 and are left with only one conftown
To be clear, shooting town!pooky would've been the best scum!kill fmpov because it secures the ml on my slot.In post 1125, Piergeiron the Paladinson wrote:In post 1121, jankofan wrote:Actually it does hold water, because after the adorable ML they can just shoot the FN and pooky seems widely townread anyway.
The free ML + killing a widely townread slot gives it its positive utility.
Scum then NK the FN on N2 and are left with only one conftown
Those are fine assumptions, but mafia killed the [supposed] town power role. Their intentions with the kill were clear, and their highest priority is obviously not to frame your slot.
This is not a reason, you've simply shown me how on of his reads progressed.In post 1120, jankofan wrote:Day 1:
Pooky scumreading koba day 1 while they push tn
Koba backseats tn and starts pushing adorable/someone else
Pooky progresses to locktown/enabling koba
I would hope that a desire to win would fuel your desire to eliminate someone you believe to be scum. Is this meant to be an additional response to my request for reasoning on your vote?In post 1123, jankofan wrote:Also pooky literally antagonized adorable to the point that they transcribed the whole chat to seperate themselves from pooky's presence, plus it lead to their eventually peacing out. it was antisocial and not cool and that fuels my desire to rope them straight up ngl
You shouldn't have to look for your own slot's towntells, Adorable's alignment is in your Role PM.In post 1124, jankofan wrote:I think thats actually a significant town!tell. Like pooky being deadass creepy in neighbor chat and adorable venting about it in the main thread, really because there was no where else to do that because it was obvious that she needed to make that known to *someone*.
How then can this be a misplay? PookyTheMagicalBear is alive. You are the leading wagon. What is the point of suggesting a theoretical alternative as the most likely scenario when it doesn't even line up with what iw actually happening?In post 1127, jankofan wrote:So if pooky's town, then scum misplayedor just assumed I'd be a free ml either way.
You actually think towncasing yourself is something I shouldn't be doing in this situation?In post 1128, Piergeiron the Paladinson wrote: You shouldn't have to look for your own slot's towntells, Adorable's alignment is in your Role PM.
Yeah I'm still waiting to be enlightened on why thats the case,In post 1130, Piergeiron the Paladinson wrote:How then can this be a misplay? PookyTheMagicalBear is alive. You are the leading wagon. What is the point of suggesting a theoretical alternative as the most likely scenario when it doesn't even line up with what iw actually happening?In post 1127, jankofan wrote:So if pooky's town, then scum misplayedor just assumed I'd be a free ml either way.
i dont think i antagonized them ^^In post 1123, jankofan wrote:Also pooky literally antagonized adorable to the point that they transcribed the whole chat to seperate themselves from pooky's presence, plus it lead to their eventually peacing out. it was antisocial and not cool and that fuels my desire to rope them straight up ngl
That only holds if her only intentions were to vent. There's other ways to look at it where her intentions were to take attention off of herself and get her neighbor eliminatedIn post 1124, jankofan wrote:I think thats actually a significant town!tell. Like pooky being deadass creepy in neighbor chat and adorable venting about it in the main thread, really because there was no where else to do that because it was obvious that she needed to make that known to *someone*.
Honestly this in itself is kind of a scum tell. Why are you trying so hard to defend yourself that you're digging into you predecessor's posts to find 'towntells'?In post 1128, Piergeiron the Paladinson wrote:You shouldn't have to look for your own slot's towntells, Adorable's alignment is in your Role PM.In post 1124, jankofan wrote:I think thats actually a significant town!tell. Like pooky being deadass creepy in neighbor chat and adorable venting about it in the main thread, really because there was no where else to do that because it was obvious that she needed to make that known to *someone*.
I never argued that your logic makes no sense; I am arguing that it does not nearly suffice as evidence toward your claims when you have not provided anything else that even resembles support for your push on PookyTheMagicalBear.In post 1132, jankofan wrote:Yeah I'm still waiting to be enlightened on why thats the case,In post 1130, Piergeiron the Paladinson wrote:How then can this be a misplay? PookyTheMagicalBear is alive. You are the leading wagon. What is the point of suggesting a theoretical alternative as the most likely scenario when it doesn't even line up with what iw actually happening?In post 1127, jankofan wrote:So if pooky's town, then scum misplayedor just assumed I'd be a free ml either way.
But with town!pooky gone I don't actually have a chance of surviving the day so the logic still applies given that I'm still alive and the day's kill could still be redirected
Maybe I'm missing something but why isn't cats in this?In post 1043, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:I have finished my first full re-read of the game and plugged your posts into my data analysis spreadsheet and the preliminary results are:
**DRUMROLL**
Highest Likelihood Scumteams:
1. TN/Adorable
2. Piegoron/Raya
3. TN/Piegoron
Full HEATMAP attached below:
Please do not self-vote.In post 1144, jankofan wrote:okay I'll self then? Am I L-1?
