Large Normal 229 | Manatee's Musical Mafia | Game Over

[Glitch]

the point of the case is that i dont he mistook the vc as its huge and on the top of the page and just 5 posts before jack posted . assuming he missed it is giving him the massive benefit of the doubt .

Okay. So you believe JV intentionally faked declaring L1. Why? For reactions?

[Glitch]

the point of the case is that i dont he mistook the vc as its huge and on the top of the page and just 5 posts before jack posted . assuming he missed it is giving him the massive benefit of the doubt .

Okay. So you believe JV intentionally faked declaring L1. Why? For reactions?

yes just like any of the other times people fake l-1 or fake hammers

1) why is that scum indicative?
2) who are people trying to get a reaction out of when they take l1 or fake hammer?

[Glitch]

We've got exactly 24 hours and I still haven't made my mind up. I will try and do as much as work and life allows for.

6007 is my last question I need Ralph to answer before I am ready for today to be over. Hoping he answers tonight. I have been holding back a few things to say until Ralph answers.

[Glitch]

^Not withholding information. Just withholding opinions until Ralph answers. Need one quick Ralph. Particularly just want to know who is the target of pressure when declaring fake l1 or fake hammer?

[Glitch]

Looter, ISO shelly and look for her talking to JV. That's what has made JV my top TR. Because while shelly freaking bussed the shit out of other scum, she laser focused PR hunted JV relentlessly.

I will be back in a bit but I'm officially done waiting on Ralph.

Intent to vote Ralph in 9 hours

[Glitch]

I'm with you on Titus being the scummiest on my list but JVs red check forces my hand and my TR on JV is my strongest read in the game. The WIFOM is strong and I know you could be right Looter but I have do go with my gut here. I really don't think JV is scum. I just hate that if I'm wrong it's a game losing mistake.

*takes a deep breath*
Ralph, good game brother. Please be scum.

VOTE: Ralph
L-1

[Glitch]

Stick to the plan.

[Glitch]

No that would make me immediately want to play with you as scum and perform the best scum theater of the game. I swear if you and Titus just won the three of us would make an unbeatable scum team.

[Glitch]

Best scum theater of all time*

If you're scum it just makes me want to play with you more because you've played excellently.

[Glitch]

The fact that neither of you admitted you just won the game as scum gives me more confidence that Ralph is scum. Nervous about this flip!!

[Glitch]

I'm sure we discussed this already but this game has fried my brain. How does ralph flipping scum make me locktown again?

[Glitch]

Looter if you are burnt out town then just know I'm here hoping you won't give up on us quite yet. Scum's plan must have been to drag this out and tire the town out. I'm sure it's possible to guess scum Ralph was instructed to drag this out by his partner or he chose to do so of his own plan.

[Glitch]

SHIT

[Glitch]

ITS JV ;_;

[Glitch]

OMG STOP I can't handle this!! My anxiety needs a flip!!

[Glitch]

This is totally how I would troll if I were scum but that's not the case. I just feel so much anxiety cause the whole game rests on this flip and I feel like I was the one who made the decision that this was the flip today. I almost went with Looter and voted Titus but the red check from JV made me go with Ralph.

[Glitch]

Holy freaking shit what is about to happen

[Glitch]

Vengeful is also town only, also I doubt two would be in a game.

Kinda lile 2 gunsmiths....

[Glitch]

Holy freaking shit what is about to happen

What do you mean? We're going into the night, make sure to wifom well my friend

What if JV knew Ralph was red because he is red with Ralph and getting Ralph killed D7 guarantees him to stay alive to win the game?

[Glitch]

INCREDIBLE

[Glitch]

Excellently played mafia team. Y'all deserve that victory.

[Glitch]

My reads were shit literally the whole game. Wow I suck at town ha.

Neighborhood was not that useful because I was always paranoid there was scum in it. Masonhood would have been useful or if a more skilled and experienced player had rolled my PR that knew better how to use it to town advantage. I am very interested in the mafia PT and the dead thread!

[Glitch]

Had shelly not interrogated JV for PR I would have thought really hard about voting JV today instead.

[Glitch]

Mafia isn't just about being right A50, but convincing others you're right.

Again if I respond to this I am risking eating a ban, so I won't.

But seriously, what has this site come to? It used to be there was a majority of GOOD scum hunters all over the place. Right now it's just trollers, people who can't even think, people who treat mafia as a "random guessing game", and people who want to have it their own way regardless of the cost because they probably have personality issues they try to compensate for at the expense of everyone's enjoyment. It's no fun AT ALL when someone decides to switch off their brain and just go gung-ho all throw the game. THANK GOD I wasn't a starter in this game (and I now TOTALLY understand why RV keeps replacing out of games)

If you're going to look down your nose at us it may be better to find another site to play on or only play in games that are invite only so you end up competing in games with playerlists only made up of players you deem worthy enough to play with you. This kind of stuff is really rude. It's fine if you only want to play with high-experience and high-skill players but don't be rude to those of us who aren't.

I may be an unskilled scumhunter but at least when I lose I can congratulate the winners and say GG to everyone, not be disappointed that the rest of my team weren't as good as me.

My tone in this is not snarky but just honest and neutral. No need to be rude to others.

[Glitch]

so jackson is cop or something that can disprove cop?

Btw Jackson is claiming a cop of some sort??

You're very red if they are green, since your claim disproves the other claim from DDL

what even is JV, full cop?

I'm not a full cop

FOR THE LAST TIME

can you roleclaim? stalling is anti town

While I think Titus and JV both played well, these are the posts that, IMO, won the game. These had me convinced JV was town as I took it as scum trying to PR hunt. I should have released this thought though after JV claimed and didn't get killed promptly. Damn.

[Glitch]

Yeah I really should have gone there but I'm so gullible with talkative players. I tried hard buy my skill level just isn't there yet. I would love a rematch with any of y'all in this playerlist. Maybe another game with Nero we can get along and I won't start off on the wrong foot. :p

[Glitch]

Even though my reads were all wrong, I did give 100%. Especially there the last day I analyzed everything I could. I underestimated scum and their ability to perform. Should have taken Norway's advice but oh we'll. Maybe next time.

I loved playing in this large. If anyone decides to mod another large normal soon let me know. I'll jump in and hopefully play better next time.

Also Nero I am sorry for death tunnelling you D1. It was all genuine but misfounded. Hope to play with you again where we can try again without so much tension.

[Glitch]

LOL A50, get fucking over yourself.

It's a game, and this was a particularly good one even though we lost. Being a sore loser and calling out bad play in a negative way is just a dick move. Nice job on turning the end of game banter into something toxic.

ANYHOO...

Massive effort posts, good scum theatre, hard bussing, consistent protown play and of course 1000 fucking posts lol.

You definitely won the game for scum JV, well done.

It wasn't even a matter of me not being able to convince others you were guilty, because I didn't think you were. You fucked up plenty, but not bad enough and not often enough to get yourself eliminated (and Ralph helped you by doing just as much).

My last game post is lol. Turns out I had you guys nailed. But I wasn't willing to vote it so can't really gloat.

Shoulda pushed harder to vote outside red-check and elim the obvscum... ah well. I learned a lot and had a lot of fun.

This is some quality content. I appreciate honest review and comments. It would be cool to have a spoiled spectator thread for some games in which a couple of solid pro players with a good site reputation provides commentary on play. What's good, what a bad, how to formulate reads on players, etc. That would be cool.

[Glitch]

SHELLY you were so fun and in this game. You should /in back into my mini normal. xD

[Glitch]

@mod: did you ever hear from Manateedude? While it's frustrating that he dipped I don't want to hold something against him particularly if he had something personal come up. Hope all is well with him.

[Glitch]

Dead thread best post award goes to a50 lmao

viewtopic.php?p=12156435#p12156435

[Glitch]

Haha yep.

Turns out A50 is a bit of a twat, but a sharp player. Might read a few of his games.

He makes me pissed the fuck off a good bit but he's a badass scumhunter. Points for that lol

[Glitch]

Thanks for modding and heading this up, manatee. It was one of my favorite games I've played so far and we appreciate you. \o/