MafiaScum Idol Season 1 (And the winner is...)

[CaptainMeme]

I especially liked learning For Forever because I hadn't heard that (or anything from Dear Evan Hansen) before and it's a really striking, unique, powerful song.

I'm really surprised it's not one you knew before considering how good that submission was - I've gone back and relistened to that recording a ton already. It was actually just incredible.