Bad Idea Mafia III: Still Bad, Less Broken [GAME OVER]

[petapan]

don't shoot yet

[petapan]

let's hypocop

innocent brassherald

[petapan]

hello murdercat

[petapan]

nice

[petapan]

my feeling was that it was the best strategy given it's no longer breakable by mass claim. leaves info if a cop dies. also gives me an excuse to slow the game down

[petapan]

Is there anyone in our game with a history of quoting role pm, self hammering in lylo or anything like that?

i love too throw game's

[petapan]

Thats not really a good fake cop choice given the setup in the description

dont wanna get into it too much but we dont know if the goons can daykill

Did I hypochondriac cop right?

yeah

[petapan]

dont wanna get into it too much but we dont know if the goons can daykill

@mod: do we know if goons can shoot?

as discussed in the signup thread only the daykilling townie role pm is public. cops should keep this in mind

[petapan]

Hypo inno MurderCat.

My first game in years on this site. I can count on one hand the number of people I recognize in the game.

I'll be honest. I thought the thread was going be locked by now too.

i played w/ you once

[petapan]

Hypo inno MurderCat.

My first game in years on this site. I can count on one hand the number of people I recognize in the game.

I'll be honest. I thought the thread was going be locked by now too.

i played w/ you once

I think I either played with toogeloo or we talked before. iirc we both learned mafia on gamefaqs waaaaaay back forever ago?

I was bad at it then and I continue to be bad at it now, but it's fun and Among Us hasn't been scratching the itch properly so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

i played on gamefaqs once or twice waaay back in the day lol

[petapan]

is the mafia theory consensus on this site still that freely giving out your town reads == more harm than good?

asking for a friend

that went away a long time ago

[petapan]

pface is literally scum

tbh having played a marathon with him this is basically how he talks

[petapan]

personally i would kill him because the mods are my enemy

[petapan]

don't think questionable hypocop results are scummy and trying to argue it is is suspect

[petapan]

you motherfucker

[petapan]

inno penguinpower

[petapan]

Hey so...not everyone has even checked in since the beginning of the game. Check in or get shot. By me.

lots of lurkings from zoraster, very scummy to me

[petapan]

how funny would it be

[petapan]

probably not, no. i still hate you though

[petapan]

that's a contender for most relatable post ever made in any mafia game ever.

[petapan]

that is an awful fucken shot and hopefully the mod rejects that on the basis of you using the wrong wording

[petapan]

innocent on micc

i'm so fucking tilted the two most obvious townies in the game got vigged back to back

[petapan]

i don't trust him to

[petapan]

tbf that is the purpose of the game

[petapan]

kinda liked micc talking about the value of having the same person shoot

[petapan]

my hypothetical hero shot would be penguinpower

[petapan]

I'd like to point out that Micc only reinforced the idea, which was originally... mine.

oh yeah nvm

[petapan]

if you're town and haven't shot, you need to shoot one of esurio/toogeloo/ds/micc if you have the chance


t-bone/poker/zor are innos, brass is a soft innocent - d3f's hypo was on him and i assume he wouldn't get shot

i hate the shit out of every shot and PP's was scummy as hell but he's not a concern right now

kill:diamondsentinel

if he's town fuck it

micc should probably die too

[petapan]

hi

[petapan]

if any of toog/esurio/micc is actually town, you should daykill one of the others i guess

tbh i thought that was game over until i realized we don't actually know the mafia win condition and there are not votes so it's probably not parity

do goons have daykills? who knows

[petapan]

well don't be brassherald, don't shoot anyone until your cooldown is over

if none of those people shoot then just shoot one of them after 24 hours pass from start of day, the game is a lock

[petapan]

lol

[petapan]

you guys are mean

[petapan]

hahaha I haven't posted in here since day 3

strategic lurking probably wouldn't have been nearly as effective a strategy if the days lasted longer, but... here we are.

still almost backfired! then someone forgot the rules

[petapan]

kill:petapan

just as good now as later i suppose

[petapan]

after all it truly was a bad idea mafia

[petapan]

Bad town play, too much quick killing. Was I the only one that joined this game and tried to scumhunt?

i was trying, but, uh, well

[petapan]

i don't know that the cops dying was even that bad given that leaving them alive had the potential to trigger an endgame scenario faster (not that i knew that at the time)