Mini Normal 2177 | Town Win

[shellyc]

a pagetop for shelly

[Not_Mafia]

I hate Herta’s non-commital waffling around the leading wagons, he could be the 4th scum

[JacksonVirgo]

Apparently that wasn't enough for a prodge.

SO...

Sup

[JacksonVirgo]

Shelly welly really be mad.

That wasn't even enough for a prodge.

Not_Mafia is acting anti-town. Thar she blows I'm gucci now

[Zurel]

This is what I came up with after rereading.

Town Read/ Town Lean:
Noraa
Shoshin - I think she is doing an active scumhunting and although in the beginning I was dismissive because I couldn't understand her logic for voting Taylor, as the game proceeded, her line of thought became clearer.
geraintm - Hiraki called him out for not contributing, but even though he didn't post much, I think so far what he posted made sense and I could see the attempt at figuring out the game. I particularly liked him calling me out for my vote on Fuzzy (476) which he called shitty.
JacksonVirgo - I had explained before, but I think their suspicion on me was town indicative. If he was scum, he had more than enough chance to pocket me but he didn't.
Tayl0r Swift - I still think her Town but after rereading Shoshin's points against her (in the early part about why Shoshin believed Taylor was scum), there are a certain points that pinged me as rather strange. But I'm not going to think too much about them for now.
Hiraki - I think in the case of Hiraki vs Herta, it cannot be TvT. I'm choosing Hiraki's side.

Null:
Rockhopper - Someone who plays this way is hard to figure out but if I squint my eyes at a certain angle, I guess I can see why they TR some people? For now I think he's null.
Not_Mafia - There is one post that pinged me as town, but the rest is null. So null it is.

Scum lean/ scum read:
TheFuzzylogic99 - Still think this slot is scummish.
Herta - Whatever Shoshin is selling, I'm buying. Especially when I compare Shoshin's 654 with Hiraki's 386. I didn't initially think much about his claim of not contributing much because this was only D1. But the more I looked at their posts, the more they looked like coasting. There are other players who don't post much, but I can see their thought process to some extent. While Herta is just non-committal, which, if he's town, isn't helpful to town at all.

I'm putting TGP aside for the Day. I'm obviously prejudiced against them and I don't think that's good.

VOTE: Herta

[Tayl0r Swift]

i still prefer the TGP wagon but i think herta's push on me probably doesnt come from town
VOTE: herta

[Zurel]

@Jackson, your vote on me is pure paranoia. If you still think I'm scum, you can do something about me later. For now, come join one of the wagons.

[JacksonVirgo]

I just think that flip turns green rather than red.

if golden flips red, we are limming you immediately the next day no question.

We're not flipping Golden, they're Town

[JacksonVirgo]

Infact, you should vote TGP

No, scum would have claimed PR. TGP is town

I almost always claim vt as scum bc of this train of thought so absolutely not. Jacko, ur partner equity with golden just went up.

also he claimed when
1) he wasn't at E-1
2) no one even declared intent

That's towny behavior?

NU UH

Seriously? Just because you do something doesn't mean it's normal to do. You're reaching pretty far

[JacksonVirgo]

TGP did claim Vanilla Townie and they are obviously Town for it. What mafia would NOT claim PR if pushed to be yeeted D1

hmmm
Hiraki/Jacko/Golden/Shelly

it sounds quite plausible if u ask me.

VOTE: Noraa

[JacksonVirgo]

Noraa is discrediting all that disagree with them

[JacksonVirgo]

I am starting to think that Noraa is tunneling and quite stuck in there. She is reading scum anyone who goes against her, but I don't think Jackson is scum. Just looking at the vote placement, if Jackson was scum, why would Jackson vote me when there are many other wagons they could push and get a town eliminated?

At the risk of getting her scumread, I VOTE: Unvote: TGP

Quit pocketing me. And if you want to unvote. Use the appropriate tags please
Which is

Code: Select all

[unvote][/unvote]
[uv][/uv]

UNVOTE: Noraa
UNVOTE: Noraa


VOTE: Noraa

[JacksonVirgo]

I screwed up the format, but that was an unvote.

Oh lmfaoo

[JacksonVirgo]

I am starting to think that Noraa is tunneling and quite stuck in there. She is reading scum anyone who goes against her, but I don't think Jackson is scum. Just looking at the vote placement, if Jackson was scum, why would Jackson vote me when there are many other wagons they could push and get a town eliminated?

At the risk of getting her scumread, I VOTE: Unvote: TGP

Hello! You have fallen into Hiraki's trap then :/

Again discrediting those that disagree with Noraa

[JacksonVirgo]

VOTE: FuzzyLogic

That's the best wagon I can see right now. Everyone else is either my town lean or I can't yet understand why they're voted.

This is such a bad vote LOL.

mislims are not, in fact, good for town. furthermore, you CONSISTENTLY tunnel town, so consistently, over and over again, you are wrong, and consistently, you still KEEP DOING THIS.

Can you not shade me based on my literal like three newbie games?

Look at this hypocrisy

[JacksonVirgo]

Scum bin: Golden, Hiraki, Shelly
Null bin: geraint, Taylor, Shoshin, Herta, Jacko, Rockhopper
Town bin: Fuzzy, NM, Zurel

If golden flips scum, the team is Golden/Hiraki/Shelly Welly/mystery person
Myster person is most likely in : {Jacko, Shoshin, Taylor} <- subject to change. its a gun to head pool that I threw out there.

So, I'll explain a bit about the changes.
Shoshin recently had some things that pinged scum a bit to me. It has brought to my attention the following pairings: Golden/Shoshin and Herta/Shoshin
So, Shoshin goes from TR to null.

NM town bin I never really explained, I realized. It's just that I agree with almost everything he says and I'm p confident in a red golden flip and if golden flips red, he has had the closest thought process to my own this entire time and has supported it a shit ton. Scum would support it and then maybe "get distracted" half way thru and switch off.

Zurel is pretty meh but I dont sense any scummy vibes at all which could be a red flag but I'm willing to town bin for now.

If Golden ever flips green, all my reads reset and I reread this entire game. If golden is green, something went really wrong somewhere and I will figure out what it was that went south.

You shove me in a scum-bin earlier and yet throw me out of it just like that. Means you do not have genuine town thoughts

[JacksonVirgo]

Currently, I dont believe golden EVER flips green here.

Faking confidence

[JacksonVirgo]

who wants a noraa wagon?

Yes

[JacksonVirgo]

I can easily see a Zurel/Noraa scum-team

[JacksonVirgo]

I need Jackson back I think bc they seem to have sensible takes.

Howdy

[JacksonVirgo]

I don't like Noraa's discrediting and shading of those that disagree with them as well as their super confident tunnel on TGP. Zurel's constant pocketing of me I don't like either, especially when they are super aware that it may be seen as if they are which isn't a townie mindset also them trying to sway me onto a top wagon is scummy.

[Shoshin]

I can easily see a Zurel/Noraa scum-team

Unlikely.

[Zurel]

I need Jackson back I think bc they seem to have sensible takes.

Howdy

Me trying to evaluate people the best I can even when I'm called shitty and scum, is pocketing, but this isn't?

Get off your high horse, Jackson. I have no appetite to pocket you.

[Shoshin]

I don't like Noraa's discrediting and shading of those that disagree with them as well as their super confident tunnel on TGP. Zurel's constant pocketing of me I don't like either, especially when they are super aware that it may be seen as if they are which isn't a townie mindset also them trying to sway me onto a top wagon is scummy.

Nora's clueless. It might means she's scum, I'm not sure, but I'd rather go for the obvious scum in Herta.

Zurel's town, and I'll stake the game on that. Pocketing isn't scummy, and if you think it is, you should be willing to vote Herta as well.

[Shoshin]

Zurel's constant pocketing of me I don't like either, especially when they are super aware that it may be seen as if they are which isn't a townie mindset also them trying to sway me onto a top wagon is scummy.

I don't think trying to sway people to your thinking is scummy, either. These are bad reasons to suspect Zurel.

Why haven't you commented more on Herta or Taylor?