Chemist1422 - shellyc PT

[Hectic]

huh, there's a pretty hefty wagon on Ydrasse/luez here, isn't there

this should be interesting

[Hectic]

Fire, Fire, Fire...

I generally have an "unsure" read on him. I just know he can power solve and have very accurate reads as town, which has been lacking so far.

I'll give him a more proper ISO when I'm caught up with the thread

[Hectic]

Yeah, Fire plays more like this as scum. Less WIM and motivation, while town!him can be a monster.

[Hectic]

deluez (hi mena!) did you want to have a conversation with me, I noted that from my skim

Brutal... did he claim Mene in-thread? I don't think he has.

[shellyc]

deluez (hi mena!) did you want to have a conversation with me, I noted that from my skim

Brutal... did he claim Mene in-thread? I don't think he has.

sorry mena

i actually thought he claimed it

[Hectic]

Ah, whoops

[shellyc]

Yeah, Fire plays more like this as scum. Less WIM and motivation, while town!him can be a monster.

is fire just the tonereadable type?

luez still giving me townvibes - interactions with you sound pretty genuine. luez!scum scumming with me decided to pocket ydrasse though (and sorta succeeded?), so he's aware how to pocket her

[Hectic]

Oh yeah, I know of that Normal game. You know, I just saw the final 5 for that and just knew Menalque was scum from the basis of him being UTR and still alive. Tragic how much people ignore NKA. Well played there though.

I guess leuz going for another pocket Ydrasse play is really bold if he's scum? and maybe kinda mean as well. I do just want to say that pairing is T/T

[Hectic]

Fire is more jokey and fun as town, and also just more proactive in solving

[shellyc]

Oh yeah, I know of that Normal game. You know, I just saw the final 5 for that and just knew Menalque was scum from the basis of him being UTR and still alive. Tragic how much people ignore NKA. Well played there though.

I guess leuz going for another pocket Ydrasse play is really bold if he's scum? and maybe kinda mean as well. I do just want to say that pairing is T/T

thanks, i have some Doubts about luez but it'll be apparent with my experience with him + what ydrasse reports

I kinda think overall my strongest TRs are taylor, ydrasse, followed by bell

[shellyc]

Fire is more jokey and fun as town, and also just more proactive in solving

busy and lazy to meta

I'm going to read that iso again probably. at first glance it seems pretty blunt which is prob sliiiiiightly town!AI

[Hectic]

I'm a little worried by Ydrasse's lack of solvely wall posts that spew her as town - you know the type, we saw plenty of them in that Datisi/IV scum game, but i think she's just been less active recently across the site

[shellyc]

im not worried

my Ydrasse tone reads are like, of a very high accuracy

I think at a cursory glance of towngame experience amount of solving can vary

[Hectic]

Mhm, I still like my reasons for the tone in her early posting + reaction to seeing Pooky flip scum. That would just solidify the read

[Hectic]

it's a little alarming that leuz reads both of us as null-scum

[shellyc]

it's a little alarming that leuz reads both of us as null-scum

i was going to say this


GALAXY MINDMELD

i think luez scumreading me for "not doing anything out of scumrange" is weird given my scumrange's pretty wide at times, and even as town i don't townslip/obvtown
and scumreading you for altouting is eh...

[shellyc]

*not altouting

it sounds a very weird point that is convoluted and not following normal townie logic to get to an SR on you
feels reversed, like scum!luez was trying to find reasons to push our pair

[Hectic]

That's exactly it, yeah. His reasoning feels tinfoily in a bad way, like it's just a really weird reason to justify a scumlean.

[Hectic]

(scumleans)

[Hectic]

You can tell me if you're scum btw. I'm fully pocketed, so I'll be happy to willingly play as 5th Impostor if you just come clean. Transparency is good when dancing

[shellyc]

My role PM says I'm aligned with the town, my love

[shellyc]

shelly whats your scumpool?

i'd say roughly ordered:
MariaR - The Bulge
OkaPoka - Firebringer (Fire here because I sorta like hectic's case there in the pt)
deleuzional - Ydrasse (luez here)
beeboy - Isis (beeboy here)
Dunnstral - Akarin (kinda null on both, could flip)

so uh...
maria's posting makes my stomach turn, very survivalistic, trying to make it to endgame. voting us then quickly pivoting to dunn/aka looks like a fake trajectory
bulge is more of a null-to-scum but I didn't really love the catchup

oka I'm townreading but I looked up a few FB games and I think I get what you saying?
deluez is going downhill as I said, keeping the SR to himself feels like "flip hectic without taking burden" and isn't from a town mindset imo.

beeboy - I know you TR but the iso has close-to-no content and isis hasn't said anything about content in pt so i'd imagine it not to be remarkable, which is alarming

I townleaned dunn and think this is solidified by scum!mariaR but akarin feels consistently like a middle-of-the-road takes person which is scummy

[shellyc]

Readslist:
Isis - IC
shellyc - obvtown
Tayl0r Swift - idk why people want to flip here at all? interactions with pooky, choosing bell over pooky, bluntness in tone

Ydrasse - tone, reaction to pooky
Hectic - I'm not sure scum!you posts paranoid theories here. based off content in pt warrants a TR
Bell - predance posting sounded really sincere in terms of pairing up + bell/pooky prob not s/s, an s/s pairing not the end of the world
OkaPoka - going against the grain and boldness

Dunnstral - I'm slightly concerned if the early TR on me was a pocket as it was based off vague reasoning like "shelly catches up from a town mindset" but looking back I think his thoughts are decent and scum!him prob doesn't hard push DGB like that?

Akarin - bit of a true null here, might let dunn/akarin evaluate each other. GTH scum based off weird shade of taylor? also very consensusy
beeboy - absence around key points of the game and ignoring the DGB wagon while posting when it was there doesn't exactly give me town!him confidence. but I could buy your Scum!Beeboy doesn't pair with isis theory

deleuzional - as said before, also when I was prodding him to give maria!town reasoning there was uh. none.

Firebringer - metadived, clear difference here, also little real content is concerning
The Bulge - passive play which is very scummy, catchup has some weird and unfollowed-up reads indicating scum lack of familiarity of the gamestate
MariaR - pretty much explained

[Hectic]

leuz is really annoying me but I don't think he's really even viable anymore, and I'm unsure how much of the annoyance means he's actually scum.

I'm not sure why they're all so convinced you're scummy. Maybe you've bussed too much.

[Hectic]

I agree a lot with your readlist. I would move Bell way down, and beeboy up, but other than that, that's where I'm at too.