Sunny 2: Rules of Im-peachment - Over!

[Something_Smart]

^If this style of post is better let me know if I'm doing it right.

It is better. I don't think the mega posts are bad per se, I just think you should include more line breaks when you do them so it looks less imposing.

[Zaiden]

I don't know if that was the line of thought S_S had

That was a teammate read. I can ask said teammate which post gave that impression, if you want.

Yes please.

[Zaiden]

user control panel -> Profile -> edit avatar

Thanks! Issue is it wants a specific pixel dimension. asdiufhqweiurhqwelrujbasdf. Not sure I can be bothered to resize an image through Photoshop rn.

[Zaiden]

@staypositivefriend, latest episode of Wonder Egg Priority just came out! Let me know what you think about this show. I think the second episode wasn't as good as the first episode because it doesn't have as much of the novelty factor anymore. But overall I'm really digging it so far.

[Untrod Tripod]

Votecount 1.8

Cheetory6
Gamma Emerald - 1 (Jake)
Gypyx - 3 (staypositivefriend, SirCakez, Zaiden)
Jake The Wolfie - 1 (midwaybear)
Jingle - 3 (noraa, MariaR, Spring Breeze)
MURDERSUNNY
MariaR
midwaybear
Morning Tweet
noraa - 3 (PrivateI, MURDERSUNNY, Pink Ball)
Pink Ball
PookyTheMagicalBear
PrivateI
SirCakez - 1 (Pooky)
Something_Smart
Spring Breeze
staypositivefriend
Zaiden - 4 (Cheetory6, Jingle, Gypyx, Gamma Emerald)

Not Voting - 2 (Morning Tweet, Something_Smart)

Day 1 ends on January 29th at 8PM EST. With 18 alive, it takes 10 to ask someone politely to leave.

If I make a mistake in the Votecount, please PM me or message me on Discord to let me know. Do not clutter the thread with posts about it.

[MURDERSUNNY]

@mwb - why is murder town?

good post

[midwaybear]

They remained actively involved but not at the expense of preventing others from speaking up and in retrospect I think that's been good.

I do think the overall attitude is townie. I also think she could be faking it which is why my read on her is more conservative.

But I don't know if I'd have the balls to say that as scum. +townpoints

I think this really just depends on the player. I do think most people would not claim scum. I've actually had experience on both sides of this. Scum and town claim scum.

I think MWB could have been more subtle about it? If you tell someone you plan to make them slip up on something, why wouldn't they just take that into account and do the opposite?

I mean what am I supposed to say in response to Noraa here. She directly asked me if I was shading her, so I gave my honest answer. There wasn't really any room to be subtle. WRT voting her, I did vote her pretty soon after.

I'm not very keyed in on why random voting stage is important and why it's such an issue to create a wagon (since isn't a wagon just eventually happen inevitably, inexorably anyway?). But I think there's some real intent to investigate underlying motives and get some thoughts out of people.

Heh looks like you came to the conclusion yourself. I think that is mostly why RVS happens.

That was a teammate read. I can ask said teammate which post gave that impression, if you want.

I'm guessing that this came from Datisi.

I don't know if that was the line of thought S_S had

That was a teammate read. I can ask said teammate which post gave that impression, if you want.

Yes please.

I like this.

[midwaybear]

@mwb - why is murder town?

good post

Why?

[MURDERSUNNY]

Also, you can probably BoP Murder this game. If he doesn't start driving scum hangs or at least change his current style, then he is probably scum.

I accept

[Noraa]

Also, you can probably BoP Murder this game. If he doesn't start driving scum hangs or at least change his current style, then he is probably scum.

I accept

Also I disagree but I mean y'all can do whatever u wanttttt

[MURDERSUNNY]

1004 is kinda scummy

we should kill this with fire

Oh cool Pooky is town

[MURDERSUNNY]

@mwb - why is murder town?

good post

Why?

I was thinking the same thing

[MURDERSUNNY]

Cake and Maria are scum together

VOTE: Cake

[MURDERSUNNY]

These are people I think are town to varying degrees of certainty:
{Gypyx, noraa, PookyTheMagicalBear, midwaybear, staypositivefriend}

These are people who's posts I'm not reading, please say less:
{Zaiden}

[Something_Smart]

These are people who's posts I'm not reading, please say less:
{Zaiden}

Can we not do this please

[MURDERSUNNY]

ok sorry, you can say as much as you want Zaiden

[Noraa]

These are people I think are town to varying degrees of certainty:
{Gypyx, noraa, PookyTheMagicalBear, midwaybear, staypositivefriend}

These are people who's posts I'm not reading, please say less:
{Zaiden}

YAY FLAREON!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Something_Smart]

I mean, Zaiden isn't even saying that much compared to people like Noraa. It's pretty unfair to not read his posts just because he organizes his thoughts in one long post instead of many short ones.

[Gypyx]

*throws a peach at gypyx's head*
can you come TR me?

nope, and don't make me feel compulsed to do so lol

(that's a correct phrasing right?)

...............I'd just say forced if I were you XD

me right now :


i'll answer relevant stuff in 1-2 hours

[Noraa]

*throws a peach at gypyx's head*
can you come TR me?

nope, and don't make me feel compulsed to do so lol

(that's a correct phrasing right?)

...............I'd just say forced if I were you XD

me right now :


i'll answer relevant stuff in 1-2 hours

XD

[MURDERSUNNY]

I mean, Zaiden isn't even saying that much compared to people like Noraa. It's pretty unfair to not read his posts just because he organizes his thoughts in one long post instead of many short ones.

This is fair. But I'm reading Zaiden based on the wagon and other interactions, I'm not just ignoring them.

[Cheetory6]

@Jingle:

1.

I don't think I've ever legitimately scumread you before, though. It's new and exciting.

can you walk through what you thought looked different here?
And also what changed in your assessment at this point:

I'm coming around on you being town, btw, PB.

2.

Despite this, there is like no effort put into convincing anyone that I'm actually scum.

Is this something that you expect from her town playstyle?

3.

Combining that with the fact that she's scumreading mwb for sheeping a Nancy read while ignoring PB doing literally the exact same thing

I don't really think this is an accurate assessment of this situation.
Noraa said that it was scummy to say that both Pooky and her are town as the assessment, not the sheeping itself which is very different.

4. Can I get some more words on why you and Dann are particularly confident in your MWB read? I would agree that they're being very protown, but I'd like an elaboration on why it's coming across as a given that he's town for the both of you.

======================================================
=this section serves as a transition from my isodive questions to my general thoughts=
======================================================

Will drop thoughts on Jingle himself later (probably when I get some answers to these), but I will say that during my Jingle dive I did feel a nagging thought in the back of my head on Noraa. Someone's probably already said this but her acknowledging that she's historically been elimbait as town while thinking that she should be obvtown feels like it should run up against her own expectations of her townplay?
Idk what to make of that.
Is logical dissonance scummy for someone who's got an extremely emotional playstyle?

[Cheetory6]

Oh also had this in my notes from the ISOdive and missed it,

@Jingle

can you elaborate on your Gyp trajectory this game?

[Noraa]

sure, but i find it funny that you're arguing that you are obvious town who should be townread by everyone here while simultaneously arguing that you're just so scummy as town that you end up getting chopped on d1 every game

don't those ideas seem a little contradictory?

No not really.
For the people that can read me(obviously not the people here), I am 100% obvious town.
For those who can't, they always SR town!me.

Most of MS in in the group that calls scum!me obvtown and town!me obvscum.
it's stupid as hell.

[Cheetory6]

Eh I probably should have held the thought until doing an ISOdive on you.
(but then I also kind of dread having to read that much while thinking (': )