Mini Normal 2207 | The End

[VP Baltar]

IV, I don't see you doing any actual scumhunting. Who do YOU want to yeet today?

[Luca Blight]

I find how consistently inactive George is to be scummy - he makes a post every day or two, just keeping himself out of prod range, and immediately disappears again. It seems somewhat calculated like he’s deliberately just doing enough to remain in the game

Is this scum meta for George?

I’ve never played with scum!George before but it certainly doesn’t align with his Town meta from what I’ve seen

[innocentvillager]

gth id kill any of {Iconeum, NM, GeorgeBailey}

but i want to reorient first before i commit to any scumreads

[Luca Blight]

i dont' really have Luca sorted yet which is why i asked

im also ~townish~ on him but i feel like i should have less doubt at this point

Do you feel that way because i obvtowned in the game you modded, Iv?

Because that was a very different gamestate given everyone was active. When the game is flat I also fall a little flat as a result

Still wondering about this @IV

[VP Baltar]

gth id kill any of {Iconeum, NM, GeorgeBailey}

but i want to reorient first before i commit to any scumreads

What are you reorienting from? When is this taking place? We have 3 days.

[Wooper]

committing to scumreads is great fun, esp if you aren't confident on them

[Wooper]

NM isn't interested in this game

George Bailey is mafia, like, rly ovviously

Datisi w/e if he's consensus townread I don't really feel like I won't be able to read him later but I don't have the time or inclination rn

Gypyx is slightly north of whatever bc I do feel like he's pressing more buttons than he does as scum!! but not many more, this would be an intuitive evolution of his scumrange and shit

gerain drunk town inb4 "wow I realy don't like wooper's reads"

Nor is probabslg town, he's my laziest read but If It Looks Like Town And Quacks Like Town......

Innocentvillager is null

Anya is null

Luca is town

I honestly don't remember who Alice is lol

Baltar is town unless my I'm being BAMBOOZLED!!!! On which caes he's in my blind spot bc he is very cool.

wooper is clearly maria

I think I deleted iconeum out of this by mistake but I haven't really been paying a lot of attention to ico this game


{Wooper}
{{geraint, Luca}
{Nor, baltar}
{Datisi??, Gypyx????}
{Iv, Alice, ico, Anya, NM}
{George}


who should I have a better read on in that nill pile

[Wooper]

I feel like Anya is generating a lot of polarised opinions but like.....I don't feel opinionated lol they're either scum or they're town whose head is glued to Goerge Bailey:a shoe lol

I'd rather kill George than kill Anya I guess but mostly BC I don't feel like Anya has like, done anything ai without flips,,,,

[Wooper]

actually I guess if Anya is the lim idrc. if that wagon = more content I am a happy boi.

[Wooper]

gth id kill any of {Iconeum, NM, GeorgeBailey}

but i want to reorient first before i commit to any scumreads

this makes me feel like either my reads are boring or iv and I are roughly equal levels of bored which is probably some kind of towntell or something I guess

This phase is a bit boring

[innocentvillager]

im not really bored?

[innocentvillager]

i dont' really have Luca sorted yet which is why i asked

im also ~townish~ on him but i feel like i should have less doubt at this point

Do you feel that way because i obvtowned in the game you modded, Iv?

Because that was a very different gamestate given everyone was active. When the game is flat I also fall a little flat as a result

Still wondering about this @IV

uhhh partially ig? idk without going into specifics let's just say i have this impression that you should be obvtown to me or you're probably scum

[innocentvillager]

gth id kill any of {Iconeum, NM, GeorgeBailey}

but i want to reorient first before i commit to any scumreads

What are you reorienting from? When is this taking place? We have 3 days.

yes i understand

if you guys kill Anya before i get a chance to do this then whatever

[innocentvillager]

okay serious question has anyone townread Anya at any point in the game?

besides GeorgeBailey's recent random 1-liner, i think the answer to this question is no btw. if someone disagrees please lmk otherwise im going with this interpretation

[Luca Blight]

Why does it matter whether Anya has or hasn’t been townread this game?

[innocentvillager]

because there are 3 scum in this game, not 1

[Anya]

i also townread myself

[Luca Blight]

...so scum would automatically townread each other?

That’s not how the game works. It’s not as if there’s been much reason to tr Anya, and her scum partners would be extra conscious of that fact

[innocentvillager]

Innocentvillager is null

the fact that im so bleh in your readslist despite me being fairly active this game and you engaging me a decent amt and taking opinions on my posting (i dont' even get an "innocentvillager???" tier like Datisi or Gypyx, im just with the lurkers and ico lol)

compared to the magnitude of your opinion on other players who i don't feel like you've interacted with as much

does stick out to me a little idk

[innocentvillager]

...so scum would automatically townread each other?

That’s not how the game works. It’s not as if there’s been much reason to tr Anya, and her scum partners would be extra conscious of that fact

let me ask you a question Luca

you're scum here with Anya and like one random person like me

is there any reason to let Anya just die here?

[Anya]

wooper seems wolfy in how he's treating my george townread as real even though i keep saying it's a joke

it's like he's basing his actual read on both of us based on it and ignoring that for some reason like he's some kind of corrupt politician

[innocentvillager]

okay better more direct question

do you think scum just lolbussed their troll partner Anya on D1 when it very easily could've been swung onto like, AliceK, GeorgeBailey, Not_Mafia?

[Anya]

wow troll partner

i'm like a godmother kind of figure

[Luca Blight]

...so scum would automatically townread each other?

That’s not how the game works. It’s not as if there’s been much reason to tr Anya, and her scum partners would be extra conscious of that fact

let me ask you a question Luca

you're scum here with Anya and like one random person like me

is there any reason to let Anya just die here?

That’s not really relevant to whether or not she has been townread

but if I were her partner I’d probably be bussing/distancing right about now. Maybe distancing while trying to pull away onto another lurker. It’s difficult to say really as I’d have to weigh everything up

The fact is that scum are very aware of how they will be perceived later on in the game and generally hope that townies will end up doing their dirty work for them

[innocentvillager]

like, geraintm may be wrong in that we shouldn't kill mafia D1

but i highly doubt he's wrong that killing mafia on D1 is < 3/13

i think a large reason for this is a lot of towns will decide on a sort of consensus PoE on the meh inactives if those exist. Probably some of those are town and some are scum (they're usually not all scum at least). so it's not that hard for 3 people to guide the town towards the wrong choice of those. Or, if town is already leaning towards a townie in the PoE, they can kind of backoff the wagon to look good down the line or something.

my point is Anya seems unaligned with other players in this plist given that we have sort of consensus-y inactive PoE. and in these situations i feel that the person it lands on is +rand scum, particularly when there's little to no resistance throughout the game or counterpushes