i thought you were town at the beginning. i think you coming in hot with "IV scum" would've been a really ballsy move after literally doing exactly that as scum in TM LN
I've had him as TL. nothing about my read there has changed. but i have a lot of townleans atp so im reevaluating my tiers and stuff
In post 2470, Luca Blight wrote: In post 1222, innocentvillager wrote:if I’m scum Anya is probably more likely to be town lol this is a classic scum!innocentvillager WK situation.
It's funny how IV said this and yet is now like '
why would I save Anya as scum'
okay this was like way before i actually started WKing her DO NOT take this out of context for yourself or others. this was after i made like one throwaway post or something about how i kinda believed her claim. I didn't know i was going to start WKing her until I started thinking about it and actually doing it.
In post 2471, Luca Blight wrote:
IV, you were pushing this argument D1 so I have a question for you
Who is Icon's partner here? You don't seem to think it's gypyx, so who is it, and why aren't you asking this same question now?
this isn't a bad question and is something i obviously need to reevaluate. i still think this is kind of a different scenario because Ico has been the predominant wagon and sussed all day, whereas the Anya wagon kind of developed as a counterpush to GeorgeBailey. (which Iconeum was on, for example)
there's also 1 partner left instead of 2, and i think there's too much support for Ico at this point for the other partner to just come out aggressively defending him at SoD, so there's less scum that can go about influencing everything i think
this reminds me, if i ever get time, to go back on the Anya pushers, because if she's town then there's very likely at least one scum helping that push go through. Ico could fit the bill but that's not the only possibility ofc.
In post 2472, Luca Blight wrote:
This vote was actually forced at this point
because Baltar and Datisi were calling IV out for not committing to a viable wagon. IV was already voting Not_Mafia which no-one else was really interested in and he couldn't justify going back on Anya rather than George after everything he had said
okay but then why am i WKing Anya in the first place. what is my scum plan. If Not_Mafia isn't really a viable wagon what is scum!me trying to do here?? lolpush NotMafia only for people to start compromising on my buddy? your arguments are confbiasing to fit your narrative of scum!me
the town!me narrative is very simple and obvious without you having to twist all these things in your mind for it to make sense. I thought the way the wagons developed around Anya was slimy and made her unlikely to be scum. I wasn't sure of WHO specifically was scum, despite people harrassing me for an answer. I kind of weakly sussed NM at the time which is all you can really do for NM so I was pushing there. Datisi and VPB forced me to compromise on George who I had mixed feelings about so i did.