NorwegianboyEE's Mini Normal Review, April 2022

[Ircher]

In normal games, mafia already know that a traitor exists, so giving that information to them by informed is redundant.

[Ircher]

I think this is in the acceptable range. It's definitely going to be swingy with 80% of town's power invested in the cop, but I think it works out. I would consider dropping the informed townie though; doing so gives mafia more room to fake claim and would likely lead to more guessing than the setup as is.

[Ircher]

1: Win cons need to include "and at least one townie (mafioso) is still alive."
2: You should have players confirm their alignment too.
3: The 1-Shot Neighborizer pm needs to be more explicit that the ability is one use.
4: The miller description for Miller Vengeful is wrong. Millers only give unfavorable results to cops in normal games.

[Ircher]

Which means need roles/rules/result PMs/etc.

I need to do something else?

Yes. We need your ruleset which should include things like "default multitasking" or "default daytalk" if applicable. We also need result pms such as for a cop, "Player X is guilty/player X is innocent."

[Ircher]

Fruit Vendor successful:

Action successful.

This is part of the reason we check result pms; fruit vendors should not be informed whether their action succeeds or fails.

[Ircher]

Everything else looked good to me.

[Ircher]

Yes; don't send them a pm at all.