PRACTICE: Votecount Analysis

[Irrelephant11]

Like the title says, practice your votecount analysis. These are real MS games from the past three years, with all usernames changed.
I'll post some votecounts, in the order they appeared in the game (though some may be missing) with some flips colored in, and it's your job to find scum. Then I'll post the reveal and we'll go again with another set of votecounts.

DISCLAIMER: I'm not that good at VCA, so I'm not aiming for anything in particular when I gather votecounts. I'm just grabbing some and seeing if y'all can get somewhere with it.

Round 1

There are two remaining anti-town, one groupscum (on a team with the flipped red players) and a serial killer-type 3rd party (no idea if you can find 3rd parties with VCA but good luck).

Spoiler: early day votecount

[3] Lightning_McQueen: Araceli, Sushi Go, BabyFace
[3] Sushi Go: ZzZZZz, Cleopatra, ExclamationPoint
[1] BabyFace: Borp
[1] ExclamationPoint:

PowPow

[1] Borp: JustinTime
[1] JustinTime:

Todd

[3] Not Voting:

Avengers_assemble

, Lightning_McQueen, Storm

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to eliminate.

Spoiler: mid day votecount

[4]

PowPow

:

Avengers_assemble

, Araceli, Cleopatra, Sushi Go
[3] JustinTime:

Todd

, Storm, Borp
[2] Cleopatra: Lightning_McQueen, ZzZZZz
[2]

Avengers_assemble

:

PowPow

, JustinTime
[1] Lightning_McQueen: BabyFace
[1] Sushi Go: ExclamationPoint
[0] Not Voting:

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to eliminate.

Spoiler: final votecount

[7]

PowPow

:

Avengers_assemble

, Araceli, Cleopatra, Sushi Go, BabyFace, ZzZZZz, Borp <––– HAMMER
[2] JustinTime:

Todd

, Storm
[2] Cleopatra: Lightning_McQueen, JustinTime
[2] Sushi Go: ExclamationPoint,

PowPow

[0] Not Voting:

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to eliminate.

If you recognize the game, please just skip this round.

Current round in post 19

[Irrelephant11]

This seems interesting but I don't think I could solve the puzzle with any reliability haha

Same tbh

[Irrelephant11]

with some flips colored in

It might not be clear but

Spoiler: hint

the reason [Todd/Avengers] are colored in is because they were shot during Night One so you can do some NKA with your VCA :>

Spoiled the info for those who might not want the hint ~Irrel

Impressive memory! For fairness' sake I spoilered your piece of info, as it's kind of a hint earlier people didn't have. I might include similar info in future rounds, though.

[Irrelephant11]

borp mafia, justin sk

This is definitely the closest! Justin was mafia, borp the sk.

round 2

There are two remaining mafia.

Spoiler: early day votecount

[6] Borp: Ingrid,

Innit7

,

Cowabunga

,

Snoot_doot

,

Slurp

,

ABCDE

[3] Olives_r_YUM:

Topaz

, Marrakesh, Colorful Kirbys
[3]

ABCDE

: whale, Koopa, Jud
[1] Colorful Kirbys:

Dinoco2

[1] Jud: Olives_r_YUM

[4] Not Voting: Borp,

Gotcha321

, LMNOP, Keeper12

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to eliminate.

Spoiler: mid day votecount

[4] Keeper12: Colorful Kirbys, Koopa, Jud,

Slurp

[4] Borp: Ingrid, Marrakesh,

Topaz

,

ABCDE

[3] Marrakesh: Olives_r_YUM, Keeper12, Borp
[2]

ABCDE

: whale,

Snoot_doot

[1] Colorful Kirbys:

Dinoco2

[1]

Topaz

: LMNOP

[1] Not Voting:

Cowabunga

,

Innit7

,

Gotcha321

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to eliminate.

Spoiler: final votecount

[10]

Gotcha321

:

ABCDE

, Koopa, LMNOP,

Slurp

, Olives_r_YUM,

Dinoco2

, Ingrid, Jud, Keeper12,

Cowabunga

<----- HAMMER
[2] Keeper12:

Topaz

, Colorful Kirbys
[1] whale: Borp
[1] Koopa: Marrakesh
[1] Olives_r_YUM:

Innit7

[1] Jud: whale

[2] Not Voting:

Snoot_doot

,

Gotcha321

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to eliminate.

[Irrelephant11]

Spoiler: Which were Nightkills? a hint

Snoot_doot, Slurp, Dinoco2, Topaz,

and

Innit7

[Irrelephant11]

i think i'll go with ingrid and olives

borp and koopa

tied winners for round 2! Mafia was Ingrid and Koopa

Round 3

There are two remaining mafia.

Spoiler: day 1 final votecount

[7]

Diane

:

DripDrop12

, H3lp, Octopiiii,

radicalHonesty

, Lin_Manuel_Miranda_Cosgrove,

Coffee

, Tea

[3]

Borp

:

DottedEyes

,

DoingIt_4TikTok

,

Diane

[1] Popsicle:

Borp

[1] Tea: Popsicle

[1] Octopiiii:

fartsfartsfarts

with 13 alive, it's 7 to eliminate.

Spoiler: day 2 final votecount

[6]

DottedEyes

: Tea,

Coffee

,

DripDrop12

, Octopiiii, Popsicle, Lin_Manuel_Miranda_Cosgrove

[1]

Borp

: H3lp

[1]

Coffee

:

DottedEyes

[3] Not voting:

fartsfartsfarts

,

radicalHonesty

,

Borp

with 11 alive, it's 6 to eliminate.

Spoiler: day 3 final votecount

[5]

Borp

:

Coffee

, Popsicle, Tea, H3lp,

Borp

[1] Popsicle: Lin_Manuel_Miranda_Cosgrove

[1]

Coffee

: Octopiiii

[1]

DripDrop12

:

radicalHonesty

[1] Not voting:

DripDrop12

with 9 alive, it's 5 to eliminate.

Spoiler: day 4 final votecount

[4]

DripDrop12

: Tea, Popsicle, H3lp, Octopiiii

[1] Popsicle: Lin_Manuel_Miranda_Cosgrove

[1] Tea:

DripDrop12

[2] Not voting:

radicalHonesty

with 7 alive, it's 4 to eliminate.

[Irrelephant11]

you forgot to change the name of the person who got voted out day 2

I blame the mod of that game for typing it inconsistently

[Irrelephant11]

Help and octopus

fully correct! new one

tomorrow

later

edit: link to game

[Irrelephant11]

Round 4

There’s 1 remaining mafia

Spoiler: day 1 early votecount

[3] Bard: Ranger,

Warlock

,

Druid

[2]

Druid

: Cleric, Bard

[2]

Warlock

:

Paladin

, Rogue

[2] Not voting:

Fighter

, Barbarian

With 9 alive, 5 votes to eliminate

Spoiler: day 1 final votecount

[5]

Druid

: Cleric, Barbarian,

Warlock

, Bard, Rogue <--- HAMMER

[3]

Warlock

:

Paladin

,

Fighter

,

Druid

[1] Barbarian: Ranger

Not voting: No one

With 9 alive, 5 votes to eliminate

Spoiler: day 2 early votecount

[2] Cleric:

Fighter

, Ranger

[1] Barbarian: Rogue

[1] Ranger: Barbarian

[1] Rogue: Bard

[2] Not voting: Cleric,

Warlock

With 7 alive, 4 votes to eliminate

Spoiler: day 2 final votecount

[4]

Warlock

: Barbarian, Cleric,

Fighter

, Bard <--- HAMMER

[2] Rogue:

Warlock

, Ranger

[1] Barbarian: Rogue

Not voting: No one

With 7 alive, 4 votes to eliminate

[Irrelephant11]

been sick, will return

The right answer was

Spoiler:

cleric

[Irrelephant11]

y'all this is very embarrassing I cannot find the newbie game that the last round was based on

you'll just have to trust me ig

[Irrelephant11]

round the next

1 mafia left

Spoiler: day 1 final

Pow

(5):

Splash

, Boom,

Crash

,

Bang

,

Tink

[HAMMERED]
Squeak (1): Blorp

Splash

(1):

Tink

Crash

(1):

Pow

Not Voting (1): Squeak

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to reach a majority.

Spoiler: day 2 final

Bang

(4): Boom,

Splash

, Blorp,

Tink

[HAMMERED]

Tink

(1):

Bang

Blorp (1):

Crash

Not Voting (1): Squeak

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to reach a majority.

Spoiler: day 3 final

Tink

(3):

Splash

, Blorp,

Tink

[HAMMERED]
Not Voting (2): Squeak, Boom

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to reach a majority.

[Irrelephant11]

My takeaway so far is datisi and ausuka are pretty good at this, on average. If they were both in a game and agreed on a vca case on someone, I'd sheep it

[Irrelephant11]

Oops sorry regular updates are hard

It was boom! The only unflipped player to be on every town wagon and 0 scum wagons

game link and next round coming tomorrow

[Irrelephant11]

viewtopic.php?p=13265617
previous game ^

[Irrelephant11]

sorry new round probably isn't happening from me for like 2 weeks actually. Going on a 10 day vacation soon and trying to get lots of things done to prepare.

It's not that hard to do, though, if anyone else is interested in setting up a few rounds while I'm gone! Just copy some VCs into a Word document, use Find > Replace, to change the usernames and add the colors, and format it all for easy reading! It's fun coming up with the usernames, even

[Irrelephant11]

Sure!

[Irrelephant11]

I agree with FL