In post 1878, Ydrasse wrote:Alisae, catboi, Charloux, Datisi, NorwegianboyEE, Bell, KittyTacky, Dannflor, Mistyx, SCRRRDBEAR, Titus, fireisredsir, Cephrir, Marashu, Shiro, Something_Smart, Val89, T3, PenguinPower
{catboi, Datisi, Dannflor} are always town here, 100%.
I believe the clan leaders are all town, and individually Charloux has decent reason to be town. So {Charloux, Shiro} both town.
{Marashu} is town by play here always even without the Shiro defense.
{Val89, fireisredsir, Bell} are all town by play. fire and Bell by meta, too.
{T3, KittyTacky} both are mislims in the making. KittyTacky in particular has actually been incredibly town, here. Posts look town, pushes look town, by meta is town, etc. And T3 is just...well, T3. And not the scum T3.
So like.
The scum pool is quite small.
Norwee, Mistyx, Bear, Titus, Cephrir, Something_Smart, and PenguinPower.
Mistyx feels town to me quite strongly.
And Cephrir feels town to me somewhat.
Which leaves a list looking a bit like this for the PoE:
{Mistyx}
{Cephrir}
{SCRRRDBEAR}
{PenguinPower}
{Titus}
{Something_Smart} (Something_Smart is about equal but slightly more scum to Titus. Titus is about equal but slightly more scum to PenguinPower. So these three were almost one line, but Something_Smart is notably more scum than PenguinPower so three different lines seemed apt.)
{Alisae}
{NorwegianboyEE}
8 possible names for 5 scum, and with the townread on Mistyx, I kinda want it to be 7. (I have to respect Cephrir enough to not eliminate him but I almost did so this was almost 6.)