HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Eiralox]

Well. I mean.


Kind of limited scope?

[Gamma Emerald]

Eh, if we are wagoning lurkers I'd rather do enchant.

Passenger's posts have made no impact on me at all, which is often a scum tell

• The Town are called Crew, VTs are called Loyal Sailors, Town PRs are called Officers - whose flavours are derived from traditional roles on ships, and/or piracy in popular culture. At least half of the Crew are Loyal Sailors.

what officer could be miller

Oh cool selfmeta.

I aleays say, if you can say how different you are as mafia and town, then you can manipulate it.

I like Passenger, congrats you are now doublevoter.


... Whew, mafia is hard.

VOTE: HighPrincessErinys

The first...three posts are townie and the last two are gross. I particularly don't understand the hpe wagon at all and it seemed like a distraction to progress. Also, singling out passenger is just strange to me

Wayward son, passenger and action Dan have made even less of an impact on mw than enchant/elements. Nothing memorable

What’s the thought process here?

[Eiralox]

Elemenys, after Killing Fenrir I can dig that from crew.

I just don't think you're crew.

You still have that one chance tough so eh.

Maybe I'm limited.

Maybe not.

[Elements]

I forgot mala existed. Mala should get checked with a claimed vt right?

Why settle for less?
With any sort of Parity checking you always want as much information as you can get so you always target 2 new people each night.
The collective information from more people makes it more powerful as the game goes on and people flip.

[Eiralox]

Why be sure about Mala, in any way?

[Eiralox]

Claims Day 1: Mala, Joker.

target Joker, only see scum in Joker.

Elements gives no indication where other mutineers might even be.

Am I being obtrusive? No.

I just don't trust this.

[Elements]

Why you didn't target claimed Miller as well then

I don't scumread Mala

[Gimli]

I believe in elements claim but it could be a scum vanilla parity cop as well, I think it's probably more reasonable as a mafia role than as a town role

Pedit: actually yeah why is elements targeting a claimant

[Gimli]

If you're a town vanilla parity cop why are you targeting KJ who actually kinda hard claimed not VT?

oOoOO

It's bullshit elements is scum

[Elements]

If you're a town vanilla parity cop why are you targeting KJ who actually kinda hard claimed not VT?

because I didn't believe the claim...

[Killing Joke]

I forgot mala existed. Mala should get checked with a claimed vt right?

Why settle for less?
With any sort of Parity checking you always want as much information as you can get so you always target 2 new people each night.
The collective information from more people makes it more powerful as the game goes on and people flip.

@Elementd, you need to claim rn who you targeted, because if you die tonight, we need to know the other two players because one of the two is scum and hopeless a protective?

Yeah I changed my mind, I believe the claim, they’re just dead wrong on us.

Mala’s done enough to be obvtown.

~H

[Eiralox]

Uhhhhhhhhhh.............

What has Mala done?

Why is Elements town for this?


I think I need to know.

[Eiralox]

Because. Not trusting this.

[Gamma Emerald]

Why you didn't target claimed Miller as well then

I don't scumread Mala

Still a good idea to try and build a body of work as parity vanilla cop
Best way to do that on your first check is to start with a claim

[Radical Rat]

I forgot mala existed. Mala should get checked with a claimed vt right?

Why settle for less?
With any sort of Parity checking you always want as much information as you can get so you always target 2 new people each night.
The collective information from more people makes it more powerful as the game goes on and people flip.

@Elementd, you need to claim rn who you targeted, because if you die tonight, we need to know the other two players because one of the two is scum and hopeless a protective?

Yeah I changed my mind, I believe the claim, they’re just dead wrong on us.

Mala’s done enough to be obvtown.

~H

Nope. I don't know where you're getting any of this, but Elements should be following normal cop rules here. No claiming unless the result matters, and right now it doesn't.

[Eiralox]

I forgot mala existed. Mala should get checked with a claimed vt right?

Why settle for less?
With any sort of Parity checking you always want as much information as you can get so you always target 2 new people each night.
The collective information from more people makes it more powerful as the game goes on and people flip.

@Elementd, you need to claim rn who you targeted, because if you die tonight, we need to know the other two players because one of the two is scum and hopeless a protective?

Yeah I changed my mind, I believe the claim, they’re just dead wrong on us.

Mala’s done enough to be obvtown.

~H

Nope. I don't know where you're getting any of this, but Elements should be following normal cop rules here. No claiming unless the result matters, and right now it doesn't.

I don't care about rules. The universe mocks lesser systems.


What I care about is Elements not hunting, not seeming to care who the mutineers are, at all. Do you agree?

[Gimli]

We’re VT. Joker was trying to bait the nk.

This is way before elements comes up with her claim.

So.

Titus claims both herself and elements visited KJ

KJ then hardclaims vt

Elements then comes up with a vanilla parity cop claim, claiming to have targeted both KJ and someone else

But she presumably did that while knowing KJ had a hardclaim. If you're a town parity cop, how do you pair anyone with a hard claimant? KJ could easily be a scum PR so you don't catch them with it, and you might as well pair KJ with a different PR giving a non-vt result just the same.

Elements either botched her NA or is just some kind of scum roleblocker or something scum

[Gimli]

VOTE: elements

The claim smells I don't fucking buy it

[Killing Joke]

Uhhhhhhhhhh.............

What has Mala done?

Why is Elements town for this?


I think I need to know.

Because. Not trusting this.

Joker may or may not agree but as extremely off the chart’s scummy as their play has been, nothing in either Titus or Elements’ claim fails to line up with ours: vt.

However Elements’ isn’t thinking, because if they were, they should notice. that I claimed vt well before their claim and furthermore if Elements was looking at anything logically, they should realize that if we’re goon and heavily sussed, we’d be the logical choice make the kill if we’re scum here, so they’re understanding of every seems assbackwards upside down.

[Elements]

Why do I not check something I don't believe?

[Gimli]

If it's a vanilla parity cop you have to try and target vanillas with it, not a D1 hardclaim that you think might be scum with some other player, it makes no sense

[Elements]

why do I have to try and target vanillas with it?

[Gimli]

Why do I not check something I don't believe?

KJ could be whatever mafia role that isn't giving a vanilla result, and you still get a false positive by targeting someone else cause you're a parity cop. Seriously elly

[Elements]

I find PRs equally as easily as vt/goons

[Elements]

However Elements’ isn’t thinking, because if they were, they should notice. that I claimed vt well before their claim and furthermore if Elements was looking at anything logically, they should realize that if we’re goon and heavily sussed, we’d be the logical choice make the kill if we’re scum here, so they’re understanding of every seems assbackwards upside down.

hmmm
UNVOTE: