Open 872 | Citadel Conflict | Postgame

[Elements]

Herta
, why do you want to be number 2? And you don't contest to me being number 1?

For whatever reason I thought we were popcorning. I don't really care where I fit in I don't think. I do wonder why you want to be first though.

also kinda ew, but not so much

[Radical Rat]

Popcorn's not a bad way to get everyone's preferences tbh

[Taly]

Herta
, why do you want to be number 2? And you don't contest to me being number 1?

For whatever reason I thought we were popcorning. I don't really care where I fit in I don't think. I do wonder why you want to be first though.

I mean, I have incentive to be first since that gives my choice immediate precedence and to see people base their choices

after

me. So I focus more on observation than not.

But the order list with me at first was an example, rather than an actual call for order. Unintentionally, it served more as a mechanism to see how others feel about the ordering.

Why don't you care where you fit?

Taly may be a hot mess, but the mess is the most colorful mess you've ever seen.

pedit

oh shit, 5+ quotes came up

what is the "ew",

Elements

? (for

Herta

and

Drew

)

[Taly]

herta

i

m siggin

g that col

orful me

ss quot

e after t

his game

[Elements]

what is the "ew",

Elements

? (for

Herta

and

Drew

)

Guess I got a bit too excited lol.

Can I back out of my spot? Or am I stuck there forever?

I do wonder why you want to be first though.

[Taly]

rat

reads, analysis, or observations: go

[RH]

@RH, can votes be redacted or changed?

No. Once you select a location, you are locked in, unless it's invalid. (Like if you chose Dungeon and it's filled, I'll let you change just that one time.)

[RH]

Day 1 Count I

Court

- N/A

Dungeon

- Doctor Drew

Palace

- N/A

Not Voting

- Elements, Bellaphant, Nona1510, Farren, Herta, Taly, Radical Rat, MegAzumarill

Notes

• The combined mod ISO is here.
  
• With 9 remaining, it takes 5 to form a majority.
  
• I'm doing the VC by hand because the VC counter is broken. Let me know if any errors exist.
  
• Also, a reminder that once you select a location, you are locked in for the rest of Day 1.

The

Day

concludes in (expired on 2023-01-31 16:45:00).

[Herta]

Why don't you care where you fit?

That goes for after Day 1 ofc assuming we can't group the scums. Day 2+ it's just mafia, and I don't see the advantage of being in one group or another.

herta

i

m siggin

g that col

orful me

ss quot

e after t

his game

<3 <3 <3

[Elements]

I think grouping 3 scum should be our priority

[Doctor Drew]

Honestly, didn't really think about the setup and thought it was best to not allow scum to choose where they want to go(I think we all are in agreement there), and in my haste thought that it was best just to choose a place before them.

Guess I got a bit too excited lol.

Can I back out of my spot? Or am I stuck there forever?

ew

Do you think with a scum PT I would make a faux pas like that?

Something the truth is just the truth.

[Doctor Drew]

*sometimes, not something

[Elements]

it is the first line of the opening post so I'm amazed you missed it at all...

[Elements]

*first bullet point of the mechanics section of the setup

[Elements]

not sure how that became "first line of the opening post"

[Doctor Drew]

it is the first line of the opening post so I'm amazed you missed it at all...

I rarely read the entire setup, just a general gist of the setup before I sign up.

And I noticed that someone else asked the same question and I hadn't skimmed through to see if it was answered yet, so I just asked again.

I mean, again, wouldn't I ask that in a scum PT to risk looking bad in game chat? Did you say ew to them as well?

Yes I know that is all wifomy, but I feel like you have seen my scum play elements(I think), and i definitely dot all the i's and cross all the t's much more as scum.

[Elements]

I don't have a long enough memory to remember people's town/scum games unless I've finished a game with them in the last month at a push, more like 2 weeks

[Doctor Drew]

But I don't want to big down the game with me defending a dumb move, so put whoever you want in the dungeon with me, a little wotc if you will.

Pre Edit: That is fair Elements, I have been mia from here for well over a year as well, maybe if I am ambitious I will search it out later if you want.

[Doctor Drew]

*bog down, not big...... I need a new phone lol

[Elements]

Your defence of yourself has given me pause to think, I'm not sure if you'd be in my 3 to win anymore

[Farren]

I think I'd rather focus on the order of who states their preference/joins for any dungeon rather than looking at the intent of the dungeon itself. If we don't group all 3 scum, the goal never changes since the scum will make every group 2:1 anyway.

That's the problem with Drew jumping in. It's too easy now for mafia to just declare dungeon, and boom it's over.

Could you explain this a little further? I'm not quite getting what you mean here.

[Herta]

I think I'd rather focus on the order of who states their preference/joins for any dungeon rather than looking at the intent of the dungeon itself. If we don't group all 3 scum, the goal never changes since the scum will make every group 2:1 anyway.

That's the problem with Drew jumping in. It's too easy now for mafia to just declare dungeon, and boom it's over.

Could you explain this a little further? I'm not quite getting what you mean here.

Town wins if all three scum are grouped into the same box. With someone (Drew) declaring a box, that leaves two spots in that box of course.

If Drew is Town, scum just needs one scum to declare the same box as Drew and there's no way we can group the scum together and hit the grand slam.

If Drew is scum, scum just needs to avoid placing another one of themselves into that box.

Either way scum has the advantage as far as the grand slam wincon goes. (grouping the 3 mafs in the same box)

[Taly]

So

Herta

, wanna destroy all concern regarding that and we join

Drew

in the dungeon?

[Herta]

Those eyes.

I guess if Drew's town and you're town that would increase the chances of grouping scum.

But if one of you isn't town then that wincon is forfeited.

Are you that confident that Drew and I are town? Willing to take that leap?

I don't know that I am.

[Doctor Drew]

Like I said, put anyone you want in the dungeon with me.