In post 1420, geraintm wrote:
In post 1416, Klick wrote:
That may seem weak. That's because it is!
Because I don't have a strong scumread on you. I have never claimed a strong scumread on you.
In post 282, Klick wrote:
Vig should shoot geraintm he's probably scum but not at a level where it will be anywhere near conclusive by the end of D1
In post 1111, Klick wrote:
My working theory of this game is at least two scum in {geraintm, Herta, PenguinPower, redFF} with one potential deepwolf in {Taly, Shirou, Firebringer, Andante}
In post 1208, Klick wrote:
See I think there's actually a nonzero chance the scumteam is exactly redFF/Herta/geraintm and they really didn't like the look of my PoE.
In post 1209, Klick wrote:
But optically {redFF, Herta, geraintm} feels like a very very good pool to lim in today
bullshit on it being a weak, gut feeling.
you don't keep bashing a player the way you do on a weak feeling.
you don't get to weasel and say i never had a strong scum read on you when you keep saying i am who you want to eliminate and vote for me.
and i am not allowing you to back track, say you don't have a strong read on me but oh yeah i want you to claim and i want to vote you.
Zero of those things say that I have a strong scumread on you.
All of them are justified with the reasoning I posted in my last post.
The first post you quoted even SPECIFICALLY SAYS '
but not at a level where it will be anywhere near conclusive by the end of D1.
You are seeing the conclusion you want to see, not the conclusion that's there.
In post 1416, Klick wrote:
At what point do you think it is acceptable for someone to put a vote on you? At what level of confidence must they feel that you're scum?
Because when you play the way you're currently playing, you do not produce much content that is alignment indicative one way or the other.
If you're scum, am I meant to just keep you alive indefinitely because I'm not *confident* that you're scum?
Or am I meant to use what IS there to read you and ride with it?
Because when other players' odds of being scum go
down
, your odds of being scum go
up
.
when there is a preponderence of evidence that i am scum. and there isn't anything like that now.
If I went by that logic to decide who to vote I would basically never vote anyone in any game.