Open 101 - Two of Four - Game over before 712

[SilverPhoenix]

Vote: veerus

I don't trust people that walk on ceilings and walls. They spy on me when I'm going to the bathroom!

[SilverPhoenix]

I've played in non-open games with millers before and the rule there is if you are a miller you should claim day 1.
It avoids the mess later on if the miller is investigated and then claims miller and, inevitably, no one believes them and they get lynched.

Wait, why would that happen in a non-open game? The players would have no clue if there was the possibility of a miller or not. It makes sense in a semi-open or open game when the possibility is explicit, but not in a non-open, as it is just futile.

[SilverPhoenix]

@ silverphoenix: if there is a miller in a non-open game it implies there is a cop.

That's highly subjective, isn't it? I mean, people are putting nurses without doctors, macho cops without doctors, etc. in games. The era of dependent roles is pretty much over.
But all of that is irrelevant, as this is an open game with the explicit possibility of a miller. If there is one, he should claim, as obviously there may or may not be a cop to prove that. But he should claim D2, and I mean right as D2 starts (not after a possible guilty investigation by the possible cop).

[SilverPhoenix]

EDWOP: (not after a possible

revealed

guilty investigation by the possible cop).