Open 875 - The Kindgom of Zeal: The Queens Chosen - DAY 2

[Umlaut]

The thing that makes me question now whether Ranger's post comes from mafia is just that it's such a

weird

response to one vote and sticks out badly in a way Ranger should know better than to do. I find it hard to believe scum!Ranger sounds the alarms and goes into flail mode the first time she gets voted.

[Radical Rat]

The major sticking point for me is the self-vote. A premature claim in response to an inflated perception of a threat is one thing. Choosing not to engage with LLD on it is one thing.

As a PR that's guaranteed a chance to act tonight if she lives through the day, actively making it easier for her to get eliminated is quite another. And then to just leave her vote parked there the whole time instead of even trying to vote for scumreads is just incomprehensible to me.

As Town with a PR, ESPECIALLY when we know it's either a Cop or a Doc, her priority should be using it. I don't believe Ranger seriously thinks her sitting around waiting to die is actually helpful for anyone, and I definitely don't believe she thinks self-voting is going to do her any favors as Town.

[Radical Rat]

The thing that makes me question now whether Ranger's post comes from mafia is just that it's such a

weird

response to one vote and sticks out badly in a way Ranger should know better than to do. I find it hard to believe scum!Ranger sounds the alarms and goes into flail mode the first time she gets voted.

I think it's a WIFOM AtE. She knows it doesn't make sense to do, and is hoping doing it anyway makes her look like frustrated Town

[Save The Dragons]

i can't believe i'm spouting mech in a game so devoid of mech but ranger is a mechanically bad vote because of our current situation

if ranger is a n1 doc, she protects furtive and gets killed because scum think she could be a n1 cop.

if ranger is a n1 cop, she dies because scum think she could be a n1 cop.

if ranger is mafia, we can lim her tomorrow. scum aren't going to leave a potential n1 cop alive.

[LavosCore]

The Queen is Perfect...

...and absolutely did not forget to add a list of currently players anywhere... Added to the game events post

[redFF]

i can't believe i'm spouting mech in a game so devoid of mech but ranger is a mechanically bad vote because of our current situation

if ranger is a n1 doc, she protects furtive and gets killed because scum think she could be a n1 cop.

if ranger is a n1 cop, she dies because scum think she could be a n1 cop.

if ranger is mafia, we can lim her tomorrow. scum aren't going to leave a potential n1 cop alive.

We have an n1 cop claim - furtive

[Save The Dragons]

you know that there can be multiple right

[redFF]

yes, but mafia can't kill more than one

[Save The Dragons]

so mafia are going to kill furtive instead of ranger when ranger could be a doctor

[Save The Dragons]

it's optimal for scum to kill ranger because ranger is a potentially a n1 cop or a n1 doc. if they don't kill her, she could have a result. if they try to kill furtive, ranger could potentially block the kill and they've wasted it.

[Cephrir]

There could be another n1 doc

[Save The Dragons]

i guess someone could doc ranger n1 that's a potential flaw but i'd recommend not doing that

[Cephrir]

I feel like if we play this way our odds of hitting mafia today are so bad we might as well nolim

[Save The Dragons]

why

[Cephrir]

any scum run up will just claim something we won't elim

[Save The Dragons]

that's not necessarily true

we have enough N1 claims to decide to be dubious of another one

[Cephrir]

im not sure that's really how probability works

[Save The Dragons]

like i have a plan to leash the scum kill my work here is done i'm ready to kill someone regardless of claim

[Cephrir]

i dont think that plan will work but maybe you're town for thinking it will

[Save The Dragons]

wow

[Save The Dragons]

my plan is brilliant 10/10 no flaws

[Umlaut]

i dont think that plan will work but maybe you're town for thinking it will

Emptyquoting

[Save The Dragons]

let me have this

[furtiveglance]

How do I help to progress this day

[Radical Rat]

StD's right, and I'd had the same thought myself. I do think hitting scum should take priority over being mechanically safe, but I would move for another strong scum candidate.

Honestly kinda not liking Cephrir's reactions here