Demon Slayer - Kimetsu no Yaiba (Game over)

[Mislim Bait]

So I haven't read anything
Just found out I was poisoned after I subbed kek

[Mislim Bait]

Anyways my poisoner is probably mafia and probably the same person who poisoned furtive too
since town poisoner is already dead its very likely that they're mafia.

[Mislim Bait]

Are you an alt of someone? I like the profile pic

alt but it's been years since I played on my main

[Mislim Bait]

so did klick caught drew or what?
Is there any claims I should know about?
It might be a good idea to massclaim we need to kill this poisoner

if I die and other 2 town dies by kp or elim
tomorrow might elo

[Mislim Bait]

drdrew's iso sounds very fluffy
fire prolly looks the best out of everyone

part of me thinks bluesnek being scum is too simple and other part of me just wants to do a reset after being wrong on imaginality.

also wish black would have stayed would have loved her input in this game

But why are the reads on two different players related?

And are you saying that Imaginalty being town makes you town read blue a bit?

Just want some clarification on what you mean.

this one in particular sounds like drew is trying to get fire to push another miselim after imaginality

[Mislim Bait]

Scum are going to start having to deal with Klick-Fire-Flavor trio sooner rather than later.

If one of them are scum, I’d eventually start to realize it as the game went on, and I’m sure they have precautions with me, but we catch a scum or 2, I’m not worried we can’t successfully town block.

Your confidence seems weird here

What do you mean?
I think it's fine

Drew if you have any reason to think FL is a wolf here I would love to hear it

I don't get how they lock towned you and Fire so quickly.

And they seem to be setting up the buss if things go awry.

My gut is not a fan.

based of this post and the previous one
fire is prolly my first TR

we're slowly getting there

[Mislim Bait]

MB, we need to know what night actions Kawaii submitted

only 1 action
jail on enchant

[Mislim Bait]

these vcs sucks there's like no real counter wagons the whole game
everyone sleepin

[Mislim Bait]

just n2 the one kawaii claimed

[Mislim Bait]

kawaii got the option to choose kp or jk and he chose jk
not sure how balancing works here but that might have hurts town killing powers

[Mislim Bait]

Second ability is day: It cancels effect of all blood arts and gives Immunity to them for day and night. It's called Exploding Blood and i have no way to explain how it explodes.
Only time i used it is when Furtive was poisoned, so when poison didn't cancel i learn that poison is human doing. Again i am not weeb, no chance me to guess which character poisoner, so thanks to Ranger for deducing.

If poisoner is human how did they poison me immediately after furtive?
how much stamina does human start with
does this have to do with training breathing or smth how does that even works
I know that a human poisoner already flipped with 3 stamina requirements

[Mislim Bait]

nvm it was a town demon fk
this human demon thing confused me

probably have least stamina requirements as human

[Mislim Bait]

why not both?

[Mislim Bait]

1. I don't know poisoner directly, just roughly idea who it is like 50/50
2. I know mafia with 99% certainty, but killing them first will not prevent poison.

who

[Mislim Bait]

From the looks of it poisoner probably got 2 stamina requirements
so even if we miss the poisoner there'd be no poison the next day.

but hey if we get poisoner then you got this 100% town win rate doge right here

[Mislim Bait]

UNVOTE: hebichan

I'm inclined to believe that both Enchant and hebi are scum here, but I want to parse this through with the rest of the playerlist (mainly GIF and Klick).

I don't have any context on how enchant claimed happened
why would you trust grandpamo over him?

[Mislim Bait]

GrandPaMo. I redirected them to a kill, and GrandPaMo denies redirect while should had noticed effect.


About poisoner, it's either Pink/Firebringer/GIF

... Ah yes it's 1/3 oh well.

there is also a chance that mafia roleblocked ur role , but idk .

like @pink ball said there is probably many scum mechanics that we aren't thinking of.

why cant enchant just be mafia?

[Mislim Bait]

From the looks of it poisoner probably got 2 stamina requirements
so even if we miss the poisoner there'd be no poison the next day.

but hey if we get poisoner then you got this 100% town win rate doge right here

I actually started to believe that the optimal play here is to NOT eliminate the poisoner to see what you flip. If you're scum, the poisoner is confirmed 3p. If you're town, the most logical thing to believe is that the poisoner has some sort of restriction to poison because why the fuck does the poisoner targets furtive and Kawaii

how does knowing that poisoner have restriction helps
If theres anyone who actually believes that this slot is scum I'll fight you

[Mislim Bait]

Is FL an expected mafia kill target?
why did enchant target FL

[Mislim Bait]

If enchant is saying the truth then granpamo cant be poisoner
Enchant's redirects all actions

[Mislim Bait]

If enchant is saying the truth then granpamo cant be poisoner
Enchant's redirects all actions

Enchant claimed that they redirected Grandpa to Flavor, how does Kawaii end being poisoned. Unless Enchant can redirect only ONE action which makes no sense?

?
I dont think anyone said anything about grandpamo being poisoner

[Mislim Bait]

like being next to the player in the playerlist, which would mean you're the poisoner based on positioning.

pls dont make a read like that haha. im pretty sure that would be bastard mechanics or some type of unknown unfair mech that is very unlikely to occur

Read Empathice's role

just noticed that grandpamo is actually in the middle of me and furtive lol

[Mislim Bait]

are you saying I'm scum? lmao

[Mislim Bait]

No. I have you as conftown.

not you

[Mislim Bait]

I don't know, and I don't care. Today we eliminate hebi, who's not the poisoner

p-edit the poisoner clearly has a stamina restriction

p-edit I'm saying that I don't have to solve you because you're a dead man walking

why is hebi not poisoner?

[Mislim Bait]

are you saying I'm scum? lmao

no we are saying that ur flip get solved on death

and it wilgive us info

if ur scum, that confirms third party poisoner
if ur town, that confirms scum poisoner

So you're saying that its better to allow someone who is most likely town to die over someone who's 100% evil regardless of whichever they are
like why not just kill the poisoner than letting me die
unless you have a good reason to believe that I'm mafia and that 3ps even exist

[Mislim Bait]

Hit me pinkball cmon

[Mislim Bait]

what tf is isolator and why is it confirmed

[Mislim Bait]

Hit me pinkball cmon

If you're scum, it's obvious that the rethoric that the scumteam will push is the lack of existence of a 3p and that "it makes no sense" and "ridiculous" which is exactly what both you and Enchant are doing. Enchant, who contradicts Grandpa's claim, who is 1v1ing hebi, who from my perspective is obvscum.

It's not hard to follow!

shouldn't it be the opposite?
mafia should be afraid of 3p

Town should be the one ignoring 3ps it just distracts them from hunting mafia especially when 3ps are not even confirmed to exist.

[Mislim Bait]

isolator

Who brought this term right now? Were did you get this?

enchant's iso

[Mislim Bait]

17 players setup
only 8 players left
only 1 mafia caught

pinkball here getting anxious cause of 3ps existence lol

[Mislim Bait]

anyway why is hebi mafia
I still haven't heard why

I might backread later but not now

[Mislim Bait]

17 players setup
only 8 players left
only 1 mafia caught

pinkball here getting anxious cause of 3ps existence lol

3rd party is confirmed to be here , if this is 3 mafia game

that leaves 5 town and 3 mafia

town mislims today its 4 town and 3 mafia

3 mafia kills town and now its 3 town

they win bruh ofc we would be anxious

bru 1 mafia caught so only 2 left

[Mislim Bait]

If Kawaii is scum, the only way the scumteam wins is pushing the 3p!poisoner.

If you're scum, it's obvious that the rethoric that the scumteam will push is the lack of existence of a 3p and that "it makes no sense" and "ridiculous" which is exactly what both you and Enchant are doing

we should just ignore the 3p or poisoner and hunt mafia then
poisoner cant really poison tomorrow so if the case is good I would vote them even if they're confirmed not poisoner

[Mislim Bait]

17 players setup
only 8 players left
only 1 mafia caught

pinkball here getting anxious cause of 3ps existence lol

3rd party is confirmed to be here , if this is 3 mafia game

that leaves 5 town and 3 mafia

town mislims today its 4 town and 3 mafia

3 mafia kills town and now its 3 town

they win bruh ofc we would be anxious

bru 1 mafia caught so only 2 left

is this a tmi slip?? lol

but nah fr , 17 player game, most likely 4 mafia. 1 caught that makes 3

you called it a 3 mafia game and thought you failed at math

[Mislim Bait]

12 town + 4 scum + 1 SK style 3p

That's were I'm at

doubt it
but if thats the case game's over for town if i die

[Mislim Bait]

We still don't really know about 3ps wincon if it exists
It could be to kill all demons cause me and furtive are both demons and if that's the case then it's possiblr for 3p to win with mafia

[Mislim Bait]

I feel like they quickly decided to skim wolf PT before posting in thread, I don't know how they would have known that I caught drew otherwise

I don't have to read 100+ pages to know
I literally just have to iso the only flipped mafia.
I'm asking if everyone is convinced that you have caught drew cause I have zero context.

Idk if you really think I'm mafia for this or you're just making up reasons because you think the slot is mafia before I subbed

[Mislim Bait]

I still don't know why everyone thinks hebi is scum
no one would tell me

[Mislim Bait]

what does that even mean

[Mislim Bait]

I still don't know why everyone thinks hebi is scum
no one would tell me

PB and I are both trackers
Fire is a PGO that only shoots demons.
GiF is cleared via PB
Enchant is a town redirector w/ that does a lot more than the town redirector that flipped.

That just leaves Grandpa you and Hebi

Why is PB town tracker?
I know I TR fire but why him being PGO makes him town? is his role confirmed?
how did PB clear GiF?

I really need alot of context here
I know I could backread myself but I'd have to dig 180 posts just to find an answer to a single question

[Mislim Bait]

I still don't know why everyone thinks hebi is scum
no one would tell me

Read page 172

Is the case against hebi just because of drew ignored hebi?

[Mislim Bait]

PB Tracked GiF

track is not a cop check

[Mislim Bait]

PB Tracked GiF

track is not a cop check

the only way either of those players are wolves is if they're wolves together with enchant

Again you're speaking with someone who got zero context on any claims.
Posts like these just sounds gibberish to me

[Mislim Bait]

grandpamo tell me why you think hebi is scum

[Mislim Bait]

im starting to buy the theory that grandpa is 3p

but who do you think is mafia

[Mislim Bait]

im starting to buy the theory that grandpa is 3p

Sanity left chat

this chat was sane?

im starting to buy the theory that grandpa is 3p

but who do you think is mafia

idk one of hebi/klick has to be scum. I lean towards Hebi as town for play here and im lost with Klick.
Other scum you i guess but u don't make sense as a team with Klick to me.

you don't believe that klick caught drew?

[Mislim Bait]

grandpamo tell me why you think hebi is scum

also if ur town, u always vote hebi here lol

because like rn hebi should see u as part of the scumteam.

there is always one scum between yall from townpov imo

Your case against hebi is decent I guess
still need to take a closer look though
I haven't read a single hebi post yet so I might need to iso her

[Mislim Bait]

I'm on pc now so I'm gonna try to read

[Mislim Bait]

how do you multi quotes I'm old and haven't played since they changed it

[Mislim Bait]

nvm found it

[Mislim Bait]

I might be jumping around a bit here, so my apologies.

Klick, why does not picking up a role pm make GrandMo more likely town?

Pre Edit: Top posting for a second please lol

ok im back

hi back im dad

im grandpa

now update me

actually i dont want to hear from u . i dont trust u

dont say no further

Wut

Explain?

i havent looked at klicked and i feel like they have been on the emerging perspective , but it feels like they are attacking this game too fast paced idk

Wut.....again.

Really don't know what you are saying here.

like think about it. klick doesnt talk for majority of the game, and now they are an active part of the game? that means they are in a emerging perspectie (someone who wants to start being more active) now that is more of the nai part. the POSSIBLE ai part is that they are emerging too fast, meaning they are out there too fast and wanting to draw attention to certain areas of the game.

do u know what i mean now?

Yes now I get what you were trying to say.

But I really don't see what is AI in regards to that. There are a few players here that haven't done much, just because they decide to go nuts and post that doesn't make them iffy per se.

These are weird convos to have if the three of them are scum
So Klick can't be s/s with Granpa
Enchant too with his push on grandpa and maybe hebi but idk

These associations might not be important now but maybe later

[Mislim Bait]

Scum are going to start having to deal with Klick-Fire-Flavor trio sooner rather than later.

If one of them are scum, I’d eventually start to realize it as the game went on, and I’m sure they have precautions with me, but we catch a scum or 2, I’m not worried we can’t successfully town block.

Your confidence seems weird here

What do you mean?
I think it's fine

Drew if you have any reason to think FL is a wolf here I would love to hear it

I don't get how they lock towned you and Fire so quickly.

And they seem to be setting up the buss if things go awry.

My gut is not a fan.

Another one with Klick and Fire
I doubt drew would be against this read if both klick and fire are scum

[Mislim Bait]

Honestly drew's reaction is pretty bad for it to be planned bus if klick is scum

Spoiler:

Pre Edit: Oh I would love to hear this guilty

Claim

Why?

You don't have a guilty on me.

Pre Edit: Oh I would love to hear this guilty

Claim

Why?

You don't have a guilty on me.

I have a very real guilty on you
you should claim

I don't see how you can claim a guilty and try to rolefish at the same time.

Pre Edit: Lol, ok wolf.

your funeral.

I saw Drew visit Ranger and IceDragon

Wrong and wrong.

I did visit someone though.

Listen, all I know is that I attempted to visit GiF.

Why the fuck would you visit a claimed commuter??????????

Why would I lie about it?

I felt like GiF was towny and possibly could have been hiding their ability by saying they were a commuter. My role can assure their ability would go through before anything other night action(though probably doesn't matter if they actually are commuter).

If they are lying and scum, I could have rushed the NK and Klick is scum with them trying to protect them, and think I would be easy to rail road because of my position on the elim yesterday.

[Mislim Bait]

my mechanic read rn says that you are mafia.

Mechanically I feel Enchant is mafia too, I jailed Enchant last night, only one kill happened in the night...
VOTE: Enchant

Just to correct kawaii here
I can't stop or protect someone from factional kills
I only stop breathing techniques

[Mislim Bait]

I want to locktown klick because everyone was just coasting after he claimed guilty on drew and he was the only one pushing really hard on it

[Mislim Bait]

I want to locktown klick because everyone was just coasting after he claimed guilty on drew and he was the only one pushing really hard on it

ur slots been coasting too tho

yeah and it would be funny if most town was just coasting while mafia is trying hard to push an elim on their partner

[Mislim Bait]

How am I already outted

This feels kinda town though. It's just inane enough.

I feel like at least one of the serious reads on furtive could be scum.

Maybe icedragon

VOTE: icedragon

this is a bad first post tbh

[Mislim Bait]

Whats wrong with that post

so scum get a debuff on their reading comprehension because they don't have to solve they just have to act
They called the scumreads on furtive serious on page 2 of the game
only 1 other person who voted furtive and it was drew with a fluffy reason

[Mislim Bait]

VOTE: black

I feel like the slot is too quiet and maybe lurking.

P -edit- I was posting this before you said anything fb lol

heichban why r u town?

VOTE: Hehichan

Cause my role pm was green.

Also not sleeping you...I specifically started typing out that post forgetting anyone was voting black.

-10 town cred

didnt get the sarcasm from firebringer

Would it help if I said I'm autistic and sometimes can't read sarcasm right?

OH SHI
Am I gonna get cancelled for saying that they have a debuff reading comprehension if they flip town?

[Mislim Bait]

so u think hebi and drew were coordinating to push furtive?

nah more like tmi on both drew and furtive to push ice

[Mislim Bait]

lol honestly hebi sounds pure tonally it sounds like they believe what they're saying but other than that I have no impression of their posts
might need to read more

[Mislim Bait]

did i get jailed

also i really want to hear from ranger and ali right now

Also this right here proves I did not get redirected. I jailed firebringer last night.

as a pgo how did you know that you were isolated @fire?

[Mislim Bait]

Okay fire and hebi probably not s/s from that misunderstanding
so hebi's role is real regardless of alignment

[Mislim Bait]

I just got to the part where pink tracked klick to hebi
this one probably needs to be resolved first before everything else likely 1 mafia here
pink claimed the guilty on hebi first so I'll vote hebi over him

[Mislim Bait]

if theres 3 scum left and hebi is one then enchant and gif is probably the team

[Mislim Bait]

Does anyone know GIF's discarded role?
who chooses doctor thats a lame role

[Mislim Bait]

if ur town, can u like iso me again tonight, i dont wanna die

We need 2 more blood for me to do it again, since I was told upon waking up we were down to 1. I have no issues isolating you though.

Wait why does hebi have 1 blood after using her ability last night? shouldnt it be zero?

is this a slip

[Mislim Bait]

actually nevermind
furtive was poisoned

[Mislim Bait]

grand can be scum if hebi is town
Don't think grand and hebi are partners
hebi and grand had this weird convo about scum target after hebi isolated them

[Mislim Bait]

btw enchant why do you think I'm town

[Mislim Bait]

if pink is town then its likely that fire is poisoner based on the claims and targets so far

grandpa elim looking better tbh
if hebi is town then I'm fairly sure their mafia

[Mislim Bait]

the guilty against hebi is just very pinpoint like klick visiting everyone except her 2 out of her 3 claimed targets.

If not for that I wouldve resolve enchant vs grand first

[Mislim Bait]

You don't have to wait for me
I'm just on and off the game doing other things

[Mislim Bait]

wait a damn min

@mislim bait

can u repeat to us what ur role is ?

kawaiis block on enchnat n2 might have caused it if it has perm effects

No permanent effects or whatever just a JK for human abilities

[Mislim Bait]

I just got to the part where pink tracked klick to hebi
this one probably needs to be resolved first before everything else likely 1 mafia here
pink claimed the guilty on hebi first so I'll vote hebi over him

grand can be scum if hebi is town
Don't think grand and hebi are partners
hebi and grand had this weird convo about scum target after hebi isolated them

why cant pink or grand understand my posts?

I'll vote hebi I'm just not rushing things
I literally just subbed and I 100% die cause its confirmed that hebi is not poisoner
If you guys dont care what I have to say before I die then go ahead and hammer

[Mislim Bait]

you know what no one would probably read my posts after I flip anyway kek

where is fire and klick

[Mislim Bait]

just remember to blast one of grand or pink if hebi is town
if not try gif or enchant
fire could also be 3p idk

[Mislim Bait]

Those posts meant nothing unless hebi flips town
You shouldn't be so worried about those since you think that hebi flips scum 100% right?

[Mislim Bait]

Even if I went ahead with grand elim
I would still die cause it's almost confirmed that he's not poisoner
you think as scum I would go for non poisoner?

[Mislim Bait]

hello how can I be of service to you

Is there like only 1 person posting in this hydra

[Mislim Bait]

ya

who you voting

[Mislim Bait]

It does look better but mechanically hebi have to be resolved first
like I said in the post you quoted

[Mislim Bait]

I think Hebi gave up

you gonna vote or nu

[Mislim Bait]

lemme break it down
if grand is scum then there's a good chance that both enchant and hebi are town

hebi isolated grand and fire on n3 and theres no kill n3 idk if both grand and fire are viable mafia targets on n3 prob not
enchant redirected grand to fl and fl is dead
theres a chance grand got caught twice and town are memeing

[Mislim Bait]

VOTE: Hebi

just hammer bro
ignore everything I said about grand if this is mafia

[Mislim Bait]

I won't be using my abilities just to be clear
So you don't get any science theories about me blocking someone next day

[Mislim Bait]

kek not only I subbed in poisoned it was also lylo shiiiii

[Mislim Bait]

Idk maybe the wording with the roles might be bastardy maybe not intentionally
Hebi's role "If anyone else out of infinity castle is targeting these 3 players, they will fail. This skill has priority over all other skills and modifiers."
Klick's "No skill can stop players from being marked with this skill but the killing can still be stopped by other skills."

[Mislim Bait]

Idk maybe the wording with the roles might be bastardy maybe not intentionally
Hebi's role "If anyone else out of infinity castle is targeting these 3 players, they will fail. This skill has priority over all other skills and modifiers."
Klick's "No skill can stop players from being marked with this skill but the killing can still be stopped by other skills."

mod clarified that some skills could get through mine even if I acted first, and I brought up the theory that klick's role was one of them but I couldnt square it with why it did not go through to firebringer and grandpa

unlucky you picked 2 scums lol

[Mislim Bait]

So many coincidences happened for that to happen
It was much easier to say that you lied

>You picking 2 scums
>Pink tracking Klick
>Klick choosing to mark the same night
>Klick breaking priority orders

[Mislim Bait]

n1 icedragon should have just been the shot. Only person who actually tries to stand up to me.
n3 (irrelevant) PB should have been demoned over GiF. Killing PB is probably fine but I should have listened to my gut and kill Kawaii.

Nah killing Kawaii is bad, otherwise mislim would't replace in and hardcarry game for mafia.

calm down kid
otherwise I would roast your ass

[Mislim Bait]

Game was already pretty hard to win after that hard bus

[Mislim Bait]

Scum also played well 2 highest posters are scum. They flooded the thread so much plus the complicated game setup

It's a literal headache trying to catch up in this game

[Mislim Bait]

I hated blood because it fcked up the vcs
Everyone just wants to get into the elim wagons regardless of their own reads

[Mislim Bait]

I hated blood because it fcked up the vcs
Everyone just wants to get into the elim wagons regardless of their own reads

Being on wagons had no effect. Only being the hammer vote would give extra blood

yeah thats what I meant

[Mislim Bait]

I can no longer claim that I have 100% town win rate in this account fk

[Mislim Bait]

mafia is more fun when its like a private puzzle for urself instead of like having to actually argue and try to get others to do what you want.

more fun as a passive participant

this tbh

[Mislim Bait]

Easy to get fun when others trying.

What happens when no one will true?

not sure what you mean

[Mislim Bait]

mafia is more fun when its like a private puzzle for urself instead of like having to actually argue and try to get others to do what you want.

more fun as a passive participant

this tbh

Well yes...that is why I was trying to play it mechanically. But at that point why not just do puzzles. We want the social interaction but sometimes it bites us

When I see an argument coming up I always try to dismiss it before it starts unless it might be helpful for my solving

[Mislim Bait]

I agree with Ranger

Sorry for replacing out, but this game started on the weekend and in

two

days there was already 40 pages and a D1 elimination. That's just not the type of game I want to play

Very well played scum. And thank you for modding FA. Hopefully next time the game starts under different circumstances and I can play

That doesn't sound like a valid reason for subbing out
though I'm not so sure about mafiascum's rules

[Mislim Bait]

Demon slayer is lit but
I'm more of kuma kuma bear kind of dog

[Mislim Bait]

I guess that is why theres alot of sub out in this site.

[Mislim Bait]

I've played like 100 games and I only subbed out once.

[Mislim Bait]

Enchant you literally have loli avatar wtf
you can't get more weeb than that

[Mislim Bait]

Enchant you literally have loli avatar wtf

HOW DARE YOU IT'S ANIMATION STYLE


ATLEAST IT'S NOT SORT OF CATGIRL LIKE SOME WEEBS LIKE

atleast catgirls are legal

[Mislim Bait]

I agree with Ranger

Sorry for replacing out, but this game started on the weekend and in

two

days there was already 40 pages and a D1 elimination. That's just not the type of game I want to play

Very well played scum. And thank you for modding FA. Hopefully next time the game starts under different circumstances and I can play

That doesn't sound like a valid reason for subbing out

To the contrary: that's the

most

valid reason to sub out.

This is just me but I think subbing out is just for OOG reasons including mental health
I'm sure everyone knows that replacements ruin games for everyone including the host
like maybe if you didn't have a clueless town subbing into d5 elo then maybe town would've won this game.

Randomness is also part of the puzzle like you don't get to pick your alignments your role or your teammates and enemies.
You'll have zero clue how things will go and just solve the puzzle with what you're given.
It might not always be true but giving players the choice to subout for a game related reason already leaves the remaining players an info to speculate whether them subbing out got something to do with their alignment
afterall they already saw what their alignment is before they subbed out.
People may not say it in thread because it's not allowed but it will always be at the back of their mind.

but thats just me ranting why subs are bad
I may hate subs out but I like subbing in
just hot drop me in a middle of a warzone
Even if my wincon is to cure cancer I'll fcking do it

[Mislim Bait]

This is just me but I think subbing out is just for OOG reasons including mental health
I'm sure everyone knows that replacements ruin games for everyone including the host
like maybe if you didn't have a clueless town subbing into d5 elo then maybe town would've won this game.

It might not always be true but giving players the choice to subout for a game related reason already leaves the remaining players an info to speculate whether them subbing out got something to do with their alignment
afterall they already saw what their alignment is before they subbed out.
People may not say it in thread because it's not allowed but it will always be at the back of their mind.

but thats just me ranting why subs are bad
I may hate subs out

Respectfully, that's a you issue, not a site issue.

Replacements don't ruin games. They're certainly an inconvenience, especially if the replacement isn't going to do what is the necessary bare minimum in the gamestate. However, that's an issue with the player replacing in, not with the idea of a replacement. The onus is on the player replacing in to put in the necessary time/effort.

The site does have an issue with many replacements refusing to do so. This is never the fault of the slot subbing out. It can be understandable to not want to read a 200 page game when subbing in. It is still a choice to choose not to.

People generally don't question replace-outs anymore.
The site punishes players replacing out strategically. The site punishes players who announce the reason why they're replacing out. The site punishes players who have a repeated history of subbing out in circumstances which can lead to a trust tell. If there are grounds to suspect one of these applies, it can enter people's minds as something they report to the authorities (and then they can and should immediately move on after they have filed reports of their concerns).

Otherwise, it doesn't, because it shouldn't. Players don't speculate. They don't do so inthread, but they also don't do so in their mind. You might. You're in the minority. As it should be, because speculation on motives for replacing out doesn't belong in the game. The site rules make that clear.

I don't understand why you think subs doesn't ruin games.
I have had many many instances as scum that I was this close to mislimming lhf town but they subbed out because they think they aren't good enough so an experienced player showed up then suddenly all the effort that I did pushing the slot gone wasted.
As town It's also pretty hard to push subbed slots like you might have questions or misunderstanding but no one can answer them so you're just stuck thinking that way because the previous person subbed.
I've also seen hosts forced to modkill players because they couldn't find a sub

You can't claim to be all knowing and say people won't do it in their mind.

Not sure I understand what you mean here.

Black rep out was 98% "fuck this game I'm out." How D1 ended was favorable to scum.
I'm only guessing of course but I'm inclined to believe that's what happened.

This is literally this game
if I saw a slot get subbed more than once then I just can't help but get this feeling that they're scum.