I think her thoughts seem incomplete in a lot of places.
I.e. it feels like she's starting with a conclusion and then writing the post to match and not the other way around. I pointed out an example of this where it felt like she had decided she wanted to shade a post of mine and came up with a plausible reason why you could say it was scummy, but didn't have the complimentary thought process of WHY scum fake doing the thing she was suggesting she would fake as scum and didn't seem to have any thought as to whether the comment itself was faked or not.
Re-reading the sheep-alisae interaction again, I think I agree with Alisae more to a degree. There is some post-hoc justification going on.
That being said, I do have a gut response because sheep's response is SO WAFFLEY. He's either completely floundering scum who doesn't know how to respond to slightest pressure, or he's town just pulling stuff out of the behind.
Sheep, how much experience do you have playing scum?
YOUR AD HERE
Too busy with work to play mafia right now but I shall return some day!
In post 266, Garlic Bread wrote:
Anyways I'm gonna form a towncore for d1 of Baltar/Myself/Shea/Tris/skygazer
Discuss
I do not really understand this post.
I feel like a lot of what garlic was doing early on felt pretty townie but this feels incredibly out of the blue in an alarming sort of way.
What is the basis for any of these town reads? I understand that GB moved me out of the scummy territory and I felt like that progression was well explained but I dont really have any idea how we go from there to me in the town core.
Same with VPB and I think the progression there is even less understandible.
This post basically just tosses out a bunch of town reads that I think are incredibly unsubstantiated.
VP has expressed a townread on you based on differences from a recent mutual scumgame. Do you feel similarly about VP here?
I Received 2 Delectables:
Spoiler: jummy snacks
In post 261, Skygazer wrote:
i don't think so, they don't feel very different to me (but meta reads that boil down to personality stuff aren't good meta reads anyways) but i mean i didn't pay too close attention to their posts that game either
In post 261, Skygazer wrote:
i don't think so, they don't feel very different to me (but meta reads that boil down to personality stuff aren't good meta reads anyways) but i mean i didn't pay too close attention to their posts that game either
I am broken.
I'm surprised though. I came into this game like "oh cool, should be an easy first read, I'll watch skygazer immediately. " you didn't consider something similar?
Despite the Resistance to my Cooking I will Trick People to Come in the Kitchen Eventually
I will Continue to Observe Everyone's Yummy Snacks
What exactly is this post supposed to mean anyway? I feel like you're saying "look I did things!" and then you're just pointing to random posts as evidence of *gestures vaguely*
Also, what is your read on xof?
YOUR AD HERE
Too busy with work to play mafia right now but I shall return some day!
I.e. it feels like she's starting with a conclusion and then writing the post to match and not the other way around. I pointed out an example of this where it felt like she had decided she wanted to shade a post of mine and came up with a plausible reason why you could say it was scummy, but didn't have the complimentary thought process of WHY scum fake doing the thing she was suggesting she would fake as scum and didn't seem to have any thought as to whether the comment itself was faked or not.
reading back on this exchange, I'm curious why you didn't follow up more. Seems like hellbrooks was distracted by a shiney thread emoji and never responded to your issue.
YOUR AD HERE
Too busy with work to play mafia right now but I shall return some day!
I.e. it feels like she's starting with a conclusion and then writing the post to match and not the other way around. I pointed out an example of this where it felt like she had decided she wanted to shade a post of mine and came up with a plausible reason why you could say it was scummy, but didn't have the complimentary thought process of WHY scum fake doing the thing she was suggesting she would fake as scum and didn't seem to have any thought as to whether the comment itself was faked or not.
reading back on this exchange, I'm curious why you didn't follow up more. Seems like hellbrooks was distracted by a shiney thread emoji and never responded to your issue.
Is that your only thought on it? I don't follow up on tons of stuff.
In post 383, VP Baltar wrote:
Re-reading the sheep-alisae interaction again, I think I agree with Alisae more to a degree. There is some post-hoc justification going on.
That being said, I do have a gut response because sheep's response is SO WAFFLEY. He's either completely floundering scum who doesn't know how to respond to slightest pressure, or he's town just pulling stuff out of the behind.
Sheep, how much experience do you have playing scum?
I.e. it feels like she's starting with a conclusion and then writing the post to match and not the other way around. I pointed out an example of this where it felt like she had decided she wanted to shade a post of mine and came up with a plausible reason why you could say it was scummy, but didn't have the complimentary thought process of WHY scum fake doing the thing she was suggesting she would fake as scum and didn't seem to have any thought as to whether the comment itself was faked or not.
reading back on this exchange, I'm curious why you didn't follow up more. Seems like hellbrooks was distracted by a shiney thread emoji and never responded to your issue.
Is that your only thought on it? I don't follow up on tons of stuff.
I mean, it wasn't some amazing point. I don't think hellbrooks is scummy for posting a half thought lol
YOUR AD HERE
Too busy with work to play mafia right now but I shall return some day!
In post 383, VP Baltar wrote:
Re-reading the sheep-alisae interaction again, I think I agree with Alisae more to a degree. There is some post-hoc justification going on.
That being said, I do have a gut response because sheep's response is SO WAFFLEY. He's either completely floundering scum who doesn't know how to respond to slightest pressure, or he's town just pulling stuff out of the behind.
Sheep, how much experience do you have playing scum?
a lot, I have many many completed mafia games
Can you link me to a recent scum game you had
YOUR AD HERE
Too busy with work to play mafia right now but I shall return some day!