i need to think about you more. sometimes i fall into the trap of "oh this player is leading the thread and posting a lot" and chuck em in the town bin
Sure. I find mentally listing reasons why someone is town/why they could be mafia and seeing what's more plausible helps for me in these situations.
We also don't want the opposite trap of binning someone as scum because of paranoia of "loud slot is trying to lead obviously powerwolfing" vibes :p
Unlike some of these... quieter slots... I am an open book, a lot of my process is in my ISO, if anything confuses you I'll try my best to explain.
How would you say sheep's play this game compares to that game he linked, since you were in that?
doesn't feel that different but like i said im trying to get away from meta reads bc honestly a lot of the time it just winds up being me looking at differences in personality/vibe which is generally not the right thing to look for
Unexpected tbh.
I was reading that game this morning and it actually feels markedly different to me. In that game, sheep comes across as trying to have a logical reason for his moves. Whereas this game, he's just like "vibes lolidk"
That type of awareness of how you're going to look is something I do expect scum to be more concerned about, generally speaking.
Was hoping you'd see the same thing.
UNVOTE:
to be fair i was too lazy to go back and look at that game so mostly went off of memory. i think that's a decent take if it's true
How would you say sheep's play this game compares to that game he linked, since you were in that?
doesn't feel that different but like i said im trying to get away from meta reads bc honestly a lot of the time it just winds up being me looking at differences in personality/vibe which is generally not the right thing to look for
Unexpected tbh.
I was reading that game this morning and it actually feels markedly different to me. In that game, sheep comes across as trying to have a logical reason for his moves. Whereas this game, he's just like "vibes lolidk"
That type of awareness of how you're going to look is something I do expect scum to be more concerned about, generally speaking.
Was hoping you'd see the same thing.
UNVOTE:
to be fair I attribute sooome of that difference in me to this being a micro, I sort of pre-decided I'd go mainly off of vibes and stuff
but I think that's a very legit observation and still semi-valid
This reminds me of town ali though and its a part of her town game I think she struggles to replicate as scum.
She just feels so much more focused on achieving specific goals as scum and here it seems like she's not doing that. I associate sort of moon logic trying to fit the game together into solves with town ali play and I think that when she tries to do the same sort of stuff as scum it doesn't feel as real to me.
I mean, read her iso because I don't think she's literally doing anything but taking pot shots. She made one decent point that was bugging me about sheep, but it was kind of obvious and upon closer inspection from me, doesn't seen to hold up
YOUR AD HERE
Too busy with work to play mafia right now but I shall return some day!
In post 561, Thestatusquo wrote:
In business company I played with town ali and she does a lot of that there too.
Comes in. Bam this seems villagery, my team solve is {three names seemingly plucked from nowhere} we should quick lim them all.
4 pages later {other two players} are confirmed wolfy so actually the solve is {three completely different names from the first one}
Its rapid fire solving and I don't think its very effective for finding scum but I actually don't think she replicates this approach vry well as scum.
I thought u were talking about Sheep and I was for a solid 5 minutes looking back at games like "wtf is shea talking about" until I went back and realized you were talking about Ali bc I noticed the pronoun wasn't he
In post 566, Garlic Bread wrote:
@baltar can you kinda explain your read progrssion on hellbooks
I just saw hellbrooks as town when I was scum in our last game. My thought is her banter is kind of similar to there, though I feel like she's not doing as much pressuring this game as she was there.
I think I'm lean town on her now to some degree, but it's not a high confidence read. Feel like she hasn't really gotten much of a foothold yet this game.
YOUR AD HERE
Too busy with work to play mafia right now but I shall return some day!
In post 540, VP Baltar wrote:
Xof, can I get your take on alisae's town read of you as well? You feel like that's a reasonable conclusion?
Yeah actually, it is pretty reasonable. Ali's probably the person in this game who has managed to play with present playstyle xof most. And other than the game Ali modded when i was in a hydra with Pine, I've been town in every single one of those games. So Ali is somebody who would know how I play and be reasonably sure that i'm not doing anything outside of my meta, and would notice if I was. I don't think it's something Ali would do, but i do also roll town at an unreasonable rate, so just assuming i've done so again is a safe bet that could be adjusted after as needed.
Xalxe: this is xofelf sometimes we call each other names and other times we share emotions
MattyP: Ur an enigma tho when it comes to circadian rhythm and the traditions we hold dear when it comes to the sun and the moon Get to reknow a xofelf here
Discord is faster than PMs or sitechat: xofelf#1697
