Describe the Playstyle Above You

[Korts]

The one game I played with you, very lurkish. Annoyed the heck out of me, since we were scumpartners. Still, it worked pretty fine up until you got caught on some faulty logic.

The things you gotta work on are thinking through arguments, and the thing that made you be that lynch in Desperate Mafia, don't lose your head. There's always some way to get what you want, you just have to keep at it.

This may be out of date, though, that was more than half a year ago I think.

[Korts]

roflcopter. impulsive gut player, very aggressive, DGB-style badgering; simply awesome. He has no faults.

[Korts]

LG: the one time I played with him, in Mushroom Kingdom Mafia, I was impressed. He ruined the scumteam's chances pretty easily, along with populartajo. He had mostly gut reads, if I remember correctly, but they were pretty much spot on.

PF: again, the one time I played with him, he gave me a lot of heat. I replaced out of that one, but PF and rofl almost made it a town win. Analysis-based play, level-headed and reasonable arguments. Proactive posting. I'd like to play again sometime.

[Korts]

To be fair, I haven't played a lot with Xtoxm, but while a lot of people say he's a very active and quirky player, I haven't really encountered a lot of that; for the main part, he lurked in those games. Probably out of disinterest, but still.

Max: I haven't played with him. Good ideas for setups. Hear he's lurkish.

[Korts]

A good player, as much as I've seen of him. Keeps active and fairly aggressive. Also, he nommed me on the GTKAS <3

[Korts]

Lazy, weak willpower, doesn't take things real serious. Has some good insight. All in all a mediocre player.

[Korts]

Follower. Has some good insights, but mostly relies on others' opinions for directions.

[Korts]

Havent played a game with him but Ive heard he is good and so win. Looking forward to play with him.
(Here is me hoping you havent confused me with DGB or with Vi)

Asks good questions, probes motives, relatively short poster (which is refreshing after some wall-of-texters); all in all a well-rounded player. gets lurkish sometimes though, and has a slight habit of not answering points against him.

[Korts]

I think what malthusis means by established, going by context, is "people I've played with".

[Korts]

inherently scummy, from what he tells me.

[Korts]

Xyl is roflcopter v0.5. His posting is confrontational, to the point and relevant, but I get the feeling his gut still needs some fine tuning.

ortolan is an analytical player, but gets lost in details.

[Korts]

bump

never played with.

[Korts]

bump

never played with bigmc or crypto.

Goat is a thorough player; he has no problems being or faking being pro-town; he doesn't rush decisions, and when he does make them they always seem to have been made based on an in-depth analysis of options and scenarios. His scumdar is barely above average, I'd say, but what he lacks in gut he can make up for in passive pro-town activity (as in, not getting lynched--actually, I believe I've never seen him lynched, at all). I'd say he's definitely in the top 30, if not 20 players I can say off the top of my head whose competence I admire.

[Korts]

dammit, slow internet!

ani: I seem to recall you lurking a lot, and what you posted was at best borderline game relevant. I don't know how much you've improved since then, but if those are still problems, you need to confront and solve them.

[Korts]

I've never played with him, but shaft.ed is a good scum player from what I hear, and an adequate enough town player to not be an obstacle to scumhunting.

I love him as a mod though.