Dannflor's Mini Normal Review, December 2022 (Released)

[Ausuka]

I think town here isn't like that powerful here in isolation but the roles have a lot of synergy in terms of like, when mafia make a kill it seems like there are a lot of reasons for things to go wrong. The roleblocker does not get that much info here but it still seems like it is helpful in terms of stopping kills and lategame. I agree with mastina that the strongman is absurdly strong enough to make this scum sided but I feel like it is town sided with just goons also?

I think the idea to give town something completely different is a good one tbh

[Ausuka]

hi

[Ausuka]

I mean i guess i just don't see how commuter and bulletproof and hider and even roleblocker accomplish protecting the best town players unless town is really lucky? i tend to think of roles like doc/watcher/maybe jk, and yes bodyguard, as being more suited to that purpose?

i do think this current setup would likely be frustrating to play as mafia sorry?

[Ausuka]

As of 10 I believe Dannflor plans to submit a different/revamped setup at some point?

[Ausuka]

Yeah i think 16 is probably better and seems fairly balanced

There's still an element of like, prs being difficult to kill for the scum I guess but that's sort of inherent to the idea of 'game with lots of protective roles'

Do you find the idea of a simple doctor or something like that objectionable?

[Ausuka]

Yeah sure, if this is what you want I think this is a good application of that

[Ausuka]

Hi - are we still doing this?

To be clear we're looking for Role PMs right now along with result PMs for the watcher and tracker

[Ausuka]

/pass

[Ausuka]

Hmm i think in terms of simple-ness it's borderline

Situations like this are difficult and I think maybee there should be a more defined version of what it means to be simple and complex. Which is my job now.

Anyway I lean towards yes this would be simple but would like input

[Ausuka]

(assuming mastina is still around)

[Ausuka]

It's pretty much simple

There are two concerns but both are like minor

1. macho is sort of counterintuitive for the protective roles (it's not that big of a deal because macho isn't exactly complex and roles failing is at least expected to happen sometimes)
2. lazy is a pretty new modifier (but still fundamentally a simple one)

and the rest of it is like perfect simple

so i lean towards yes

[Ausuka]

huh

[Ausuka]

Ok in the absence of mastina input I am going to run this as simple