Eminence in Shadow: Season 1 [Game Over]

[Big Chungus Gaming]

Looks like 4 of my top 5 town say Dunn could be scum or have him in the bottom quarter/third of their readslist. Wheme is the one that thinks town!Dunn

WHO CARES HOW MANY PPL THINK IT THAT YOU TOWNREAD

townreads and reliability of reads are 2 separate metrics

hell if a scumread of yours presents a read that is well made, you can follow that too because it could be, wait for it, TMI of their partner too!

[Klick]

but also i would atp put money on dunn flipping town so i hope you eat a heaping pile of crow for it bc it seems like thats the scum agenda wagon now

Instead of this sidelining tell me who the scum is pushing the Dunn agenda so I can vote them pls ty.

[Big Chungus Gaming]

ssbm_Kyouko
Sakura Hana
Whemestar
Klick
KawaiiKame
Luka
Pookythemagicalbear


Cephrir
jjh927
Save the Dragons
Gamma Emerald
Dunnstral
SirCakez


Alisae
T3
Penguinpower

ok admittedly this is where I'm at and I guess dunn technically fmpov isnt a toss to resolve, expected to have a more solid bottom 4 that I felt good about, but this is where I'm at and I think Cakez/Alisae have difficulty fitting together which is why I find it awkward lol


still think PP is like the easiest to figure out is a guaranteed hit from an objective standpoint

[ssbm_Kyouko]

objectively i am one of the most cleared players off dunn mafia but please keep pushing the silly surface level assumption that "defended them d1 so must be mafia"

stop using whos on the wagon and preflips to determine your reads

but also i would atp put money on dunn flipping town so i hope you eat a heaping pile of crow for it bc it seems like thats the scum agenda wagon now

I'm not SRing you, I think I've found a good block of town players I'm confident in though, and they all seem to agree Dunn is scummy. I've got him at null myself, can't say I have any idea how to read him. The one time I caught him as scum was in Isekai where I tracked him to the NK. The only reason I even tracked him was because I thought he was so town he'd get killed later on and I was an activated Watcher that had to track my target before I was allowed to target them with my Watcher ability. I was literally setting up to catch the scum that killed Dunn in the game where he was scum because he had me and the rest of the playerlist that snowed.

When I was looking at why you were voting Gamma it seemed pretty clear the reason was because you think Dunn is town, which also explains why you'd be voting PP now. It's not a crime to misread scum as town, or to defend your TRs by voting the counterwagon at the end of day, but if he flips scum, it

does start to look bad

. No denying that.

[Big Chungus Gaming]

but also i would atp put money on dunn flipping town so i hope you eat a heaping pile of crow for it bc it seems like thats the scum agenda wagon now

Instead of this sidelining tell me who the scum is pushing the Dunn agenda so I can vote them pls ty.

admittedly just looked at the VC and realized JJH was the one in the lead and is the scum agenda push likely rather than dunn and I rescind this statement

[Big Chungus Gaming]

objectively i am one of the most cleared players off dunn mafia but please keep pushing the silly surface level assumption that "defended them d1 so must be mafia"

stop using whos on the wagon and preflips to determine your reads

but also i would atp put money on dunn flipping town so i hope you eat a heaping pile of crow for it bc it seems like thats the scum agenda wagon now

I'm not SRing you, I think I've found a good block of town players I'm confident in though, and they all seem to agree Dunn is scummy. I've got him at null myself, can't say I have any idea how to read him. The one time I caught him as scum was in Isekai where I tracked him to the NK. The only reason I even tracked him was because I thought he was so town he'd get killed later on and I was an activated Watcher that had to track my target before I was allowed to target them with my Watcher ability. I was literally setting up to catch the scum that killed Dunn in the game where he was scum because he had me and the rest of the playerlist that snowed.

When I was looking at why you were voting Gamma it seemed pretty clear the reason was because you think Dunn is town, which also explains why you'd be voting PP now. It's not a crime to misread scum as town, or to defend your TRs by voting the counterwagon at the end of day, but if he flips scum, it

does start to look bad

. No denying that.

I don't think PP and Dunn are incompatible by any means and I think you completely missed where I felt dunn has town plausibility but not high enough to bin town, but high enough to pass on day 1 to me.

I feel in a game like this with mechs he will only improve in content if he is town after n1 and that a chance to show himself would be worthwhile

I like elimination orders and I think PP is the correct one to go first here

[Big Chungus Gaming]

pee pee poo poo tldr mixed up jjh and dunn's names in my thought process for a bit but still Nuance

[Cephrir]

Idg why pp is happening

Everything feels wrong now I'm gonna VOTE: pooky uselessly for a bit

[ssbm_Kyouko]

but also i would atp put money on dunn flipping town so i hope you eat a heaping pile of crow for it bc it seems like thats the scum agenda wagon now

Instead of this sidelining tell me who the scum is pushing the Dunn agenda so I can vote them pls ty.

Do you agree dunn is a proscum wagon or are you just looking for more meaningful commentary from BCG?

[Big Chungus Gaming]

Idg why pp is happening

Everything feels wrong now I'm gonna VOTE: pooky uselessly for a bit

he isn't, dunn/jjh is the primary wagon battle rn. It's my preferred elim for day 1.

[Big Chungus Gaming]

but also i would atp put money on dunn flipping town so i hope you eat a heaping pile of crow for it bc it seems like thats the scum agenda wagon now

Instead of this sidelining tell me who the scum is pushing the Dunn agenda so I can vote them pls ty.

Do you agree dunn is a proscum wagon or are you just looking for more meaningful commentary from BCG?

nothing to agree with as I had made a faulty statement based on a misconception

[Big Chungus Gaming]

as is I have my preferences in this order for viable wagons at this point:

PP>dunn>alisae>jjh

and then if t3 was to become a flashwagon I would put that above dunn

[ssbm_Kyouko]

Idg why pp is happening

Everything feels wrong now I'm gonna VOTE: pooky uselessly for a bit

Dunn wagon is also happening, in fact it's happening moreso than PP, Dunn's leading on 6 votes (E-3) - do you include this in "everything" that feels wrong? You just moved from jjh (dissolving wagon) to Pooky (no wagon)

[Cephrir]

i'm actively against the dunnstral wagon

[Sakura Hana]

i'm actively against the dunnstral wagon

Explain?

[Klick]

but also i would atp put money on dunn flipping town so i hope you eat a heaping pile of crow for it bc it seems like thats the scum agenda wagon now

Instead of this sidelining tell me who the scum is pushing the Dunn agenda so I can vote them pls ty.

Do you agree dunn is a proscum wagon or are you just looking for more meaningful commentary from BCG?

The latter
BCG's comment looked empty
And in theory if BCG was right the scum should have been easy to identify
Turns out it was just inaccurate

I find it quite funny how the reins for the elimination today are being actively avoided

[Firebringer]

With his sister saved. Everything turned back to normal, until the garden informed him of their departure to expand and grow their organization. He took this to mean they grew bored of him...he couldn't have been more wrong.

Day 1 - Our Story Begins
Vote Count 1.20

Dunnstral [6][E-3] - PookytheMagicalBear, Luka, Sakura Hana, ssbm_Kyouko, Penguinpower, Save The Dragons,
PenguinPower [3][E-6]- Dunnstral, Gamma Emerald, Big Chungus Gaming,
Alisae [3][E-6] - SirCakez, KawaiiKame, T3,
jjh927 [2][E-7] - Alisae, Whemestar,
PookytheMagicalBear [1][E-8] - Cephrir,



Lurking in Shadows (Not Voting - 2) : jjh927, Klick,

With 17 Alive, It Takes 9 to Eliminate.
Deadline is (expired on 2024-01-07 15:45:00)

Mod Note: Seeking replacement for KawaiiKame

[Klick]

Ty flamepup

[Sakura Hana]

I find it quite funny how the reins for the elimination today are being actively avoided

What does this mean? Do you mean no one is taking the lead for eliminating someone? Or the people eliminating someone arent taking the reins to drive it?

[Sakura Hana]

Btw Cakez has also vanished which i'm not sure what it means in the context of this game, since according to pooky scum Dunn means town Cakez

That being said, i'm open to switching to PP or Cakez, I just think Dunn has the highest chance of scum flip right now.

[Alisae]

Koba how helpful is my death for your reads?

[Gamma Emerald]

@Gamma I'm just going to need the name of a game you were town and got mad at Alisae's bad faith play I don't have time to run it down
As for my vote toDay it doesn't look like Gamma or Cakez will be it so I'll probably just join some TRs on a wagon that I don't TR

Booneytoonz XVII: The Winston Chronicles is the main one
I think it also happened in Legend of the Buisness Company

[Firebringer]

Seeking replacement for KawaiiKame

[Cephrir]

i'm actively against the dunnstral wagon

Explain?

i think dunnstral is town, as i stated early on and have only mildly wavered on. im not big on preflipping but if it helps, consider that my viewpoint is coming from a universe where pooky is not town.

[SirCakez]

I lost my grasp on this game