Newbie 2145 - Postgame

[Alianna]

1.06

Votecount 1.06

Spartan117 (2): Black, Bellaphant
Andante (1): CCGeek
CCGeek (1): Andante
Bellaphant (1): NicoleAndDime
Black (1): Spartan117

Not Voting (3): Gumball, dareb, herodualies

With 9 players alive, it takes 5 votes to secure an execution.

The day deadline is in (expired on 2025-05-15 13:07:26).

[dareb]

CCGeek (2): Andante, dareb

oh i unvoted ccgeek in 279 (i did vote/unvote 3 times since the last vc sorry if i confused you)

[Alianna]

CCGeek (2): Andante, dareb

oh i unvoted ccgeek in 279 (i did vote/unvote 3 times since the last vc sorry if i confused you)

Thank you! Fixed.

[Alianna]

NicoleAndDime is being prodded.

[Spartan117]

Not Voting (4): Spartan117

I should be voting Black

Pretty pooped from all of that, defo feel like this is VOTE: Black's scum game.

[Gumball]

Quite a lot of stuff

I can't quite get over how this post, while full of stuff, just feels blank to me. Caveats, riffing on previous comments rather than identifying anything new. I'm just feeling like this was an attempt to demonstrate reads that don't really exist in their head.

VOTE: CCGeek

I feel like Spartan is well within his scumrange and townrange but I just can't tell. Dareb is kinda all over the place but not in a way that particularly pings me. Herodualies...despite quite liking what there is, the slot worries me, so quiet, could easily just be hiding. I'm feeling a bit better about Bella, I don't agree with Spartan I feel like Bella was implying the point I typed out. I feel like Andante and Black have contributed to the thread in a way that improves it overall. Nicole is fading for me, it's decision time and there's been no thoughts in three days.

[Alianna]

Not Voting (4): Spartan117

I should be voting Black

Pretty pooped from all of that, defo feel like this is VOTE: Black's scum game.

I wonder if I skipped a page by mistake or something lol. Fixed.

[dareb]

Quite a lot of stuff

I can't quite get over how this post, while full of stuff, just feels blank to me. Caveats, riffing on previous comments rather than identifying anything new. I'm just feeling like this was an attempt to demonstrate reads that don't really exist in their head.

this is the post after i tried to reanalyze that i wrote pinged me as scumleaning from ccgeek.
i think you incapulated most of what i was thinking at the time i was rereading but couldn't actually remember a couple hours later

[dareb]

incapulated

i completely misspelled encapsulated lol

[dareb]

Herodualies...despite quite liking what there is, the slot worries me, so quiet, could easily just be hiding.

I wouldn’t say hero is quiet atp since hero only had 3 or 4 days of time so far compared to our 6 or 7 days. not something i’m worried about for now

[dareb]

i do need to proofread before posting bc i’m letting so many mistakes through

post after i tried to reanalyze

[Bellaphant]

@dareb, can you explain your reads a little more? Just a sentence or two summarising why you are where you are

[dareb]

Quite a lot of stuff

I can't quite get over how this post, while full of stuff, just feels blank to me. Caveats, riffing on previous comments rather than identifying anything new. I'm just feeling like this was an attempt to demonstrate reads that don't really exist in their head.

this is the post after i tried to reanalyze that i wrote pinged me as scumleaning from ccgeek.
i think you incapulated most of what i was thinking at the time i was rereading but couldn't actually remember a couple hours later

correction btw i didn’t write it down in the message with the posts in specific. i did think it put me off though at the time though

[dareb]

@dareb, can you explain your reads a little more? Just a sentence or two summarising why you are where you are

I’m townreading gumball bc of 28 and 151 for the most part
I haven’t touched on why i’m scumleaning black yet: i wrote that i agreed with your 179 and didn’t like black’s 230 but for 230 i definitely feel i missed the context. Looking back i’m not much of a fan of 125 either

[Black]

102 Black why do you think its more likely from a townie place than a scummy one? Most of it just feels a bit too forced for me.

I try to look at these situations from a perspective of whether or not I believe what they are saying. In this instance I felt like Gumball was more likely to believe what he was saying than not

[Black]

i think andante/spartan is probably either w/w or t/t

Can you elaborate on this?

[Black]

I like their 110 too, would be far to easy to just throw shade back at me for what has happened, gives me townie vibes not to push for the sake of it and more trying to read situations for what they are. I also like that they didnt simply town read bella/nicole for agreeing with them throughout the convo, and while Andante doesnt feel like much has developed because of it I think while the convo may not have opened anything up completely, i think with some comparisons to similar dynamics later it could be an interesting comparison to see if the same sides are chosen.

it's kinda easy to not care when nothing is happening in a game, and like now I'm at the, I'm gonna give minimal effort cause literally no one else even seems to care.
I get we're all busy with life, but we all said we could play this game, where's everyone's interest in finding scum here?
and then like, one of the absent voices comes in with a readslist calling me null (while still leaving a vote on me)
like I am the only person here actively trying to drive conversations, yet we're calling me null? like you can very clearly either see me as scum trying to control thread or town trying to get literally anything to happen at this point, but I would argue no one should be null reading me, I should be leaning one way of the other, BUT that's only if you're actually trying to scumhunt...

VOTE: CCGeek

I like this vote tbh

I disagree with the premise that no one should be null reading you. I can't speak for others but I have a hard time committing to reads, and that is amplified when it comes to players like you who are good at the game. I think I lean town with you but I don't think anything you've done is outside of any scum ranges. Would you disagree?

[Black]

Ok I guess I am wondering if your read is similar to mine or if you have a different one?

I think I'm mainly underwhelmed in general? There's a lack of hard stances overall, but also the drive isn't there. I know I'm not doing much better and that bop isn't a great strategy, but the drunk mind wants what it wants

What did you think of Spartan's catch up post?

[Black]

CCG's catchup feels better than Spartan's. I think there's more self-doubt present when working through his thoughts. They feel more genuine, whereas some of Spartan's thoughts feel like he is forcing himself to believe in them or something

[Black]

on that note, does mafia have daychat? because i think that would probably clear gumball a bit if they did

Why?

[Black]

I've been taking a look at CCGeek's other games. I feel there is a noticable difference between the first ISO (scum) and the second and third (town) (inverted date order, sorry, but the post is written now)
viewtopic.php?p=13916088&f=52&t=91649&u ... #p13916088
viewtopic.php?p=13870549&f=174&t=91394& ... #p13870549
viewtopic.php?p=13509536&f=174&t=89939& ... #p13509536

The first has very few explicit reads, compared to the second which flows more and offers more, first seems to be more mechanical discussions and comments about particular actions "this is unusual" type thing rather than explicit decisions about what the read is. The third appears to be first game on-site, and few posts, but still I'm feeling it a little more than first game.

There's unfortunately very little to go on this game, but I feel that they're potentially readable. Right now I feel the current game reminds me more of the scum game, there's a chunky (re)entry post, not much flow, though that could be a symptom of having to take a break in the game. I think I am seeing a bit more solving than in the scum game, which blunts my enthusiasm a bit.

+town

[Black]

I had this post ready 80 or so minutes ago, I just now realized I didn't post it yet

I finished trying to put together everything. Honestly my reads are still the same, even though I pretty much kept my prior reads out of it for the most part. If anything, I townread Bella slightly more.

also i just realized i still have my rvs vote from page 1 active UNVOTE: CCGeek until i analyze the thread

I'd rather be honest here, I didn't know how to go about making it known my RVS vote was becoming less RVS even though I don't have much reads so far. Then I just decided to unvote before I reread the thread so I can see if my opinion changed

For now, VOTE: CCGeek

I kinda think this vocalization of worrying about his optics is +town. Scum tend to keep that self-conscious thought in their head

[Black]

Pretty pooped from all of that, defo feel like this is VOTE: Black's scum game.

What do my town/scum games look like?

[Andante]

I still think CCGeek is scum, nothing has convinced me otherwise

[Bellaphant]

Do you have more fully formed thoughts on others, Andante?