Newbie 2145 - Postgame

[Alianna]

1.07

Votecount 1.07

Spartan117 (2): Black, Bellaphant
CCGeek (2): Andante, Gumball
Andante (1): CCGeek
Bellaphant (1): NicoleAndDime
Black (1): Spartan117

Not Voting (2): dareb, herodualies

With 9 players alive, it takes 5 votes to secure an execution.

The day deadline is in (expired on 2025-05-15 13:07:26).

[Andante]

Andante (1): CCGeek

I'd like to point out, that with 2 days left, CCG still has a nonserious vote up, called me null, and even said that vote was to poke at me, so I ask, where are the town intentions here? literally how is this town trying to find scum?

they're frozen scum I believe

[Black]

I can't quite get over how this post, while full of stuff, just feels blank to me. Caveats, riffing on previous comments rather than identifying anything new. I'm just feeling like this was an attempt to demonstrate reads that don't really exist in their head.

For the record you don't feel this way when reading Spartan's catch ups?

I'm looking over the games you linked in 257 and I'm noticing a couple differences but nothing that points in a strong direction. One of my main issues with the catchup this game is that he did a deep dive on pages he was previously apart of. He was present pages 1-7 and then in 234 he recaps pages 1-5, but I see that he actually did this in the first town game you linked. The other games are mostly inconclusive. They're either different types of recaps (player by player) or it's his first contribution to the game

[Black]

I won't fight a CCG wagon. My reads are pretty squishy in general and I wouldn't mind sheeping Gumball here

[dareb]

im more inclined to vote ccgeek as well, but i want to wait until tonight to see if nicole has anything to say from the past 3 days in case it changes what im thinking

what makes you sr ccgeek?

what i said before:

Quite a lot of stuff

I can't quite get over how this post, while full of stuff, just feels blank to me. Caveats, riffing on previous comments rather than identifying anything new. I'm just feeling like this was an attempt to demonstrate reads that don't really exist in their head.

this is the post after i tried to reanalyze that i wrote pinged me as scumleaning from ccgeek.
i think you incapulated most of what i was thinking at the time i was rereading but couldn't actually remember a couple hours later

correction btw i didn’t write it down in the message with the posts in specific. i did think it put me off though at the time though

52: ccgeek ~scum

Even though I don't feel 52 pings me as scum as much as before I feel like including it since it was what I was thinking while I was analyzing on page 11

and checking ccgeek's iso now bc i havent deeply analyzed the post yet: i feel like ccg hasn't given any thoughts on reads other than in 280 and 226, and ccg said they have scumlean on bella in 226, but nothing really trying to get more of a read on bella.

i think checking the iso helped me why i have a scumlean on ccg: they arent really pushing anyone or giving anyone much reason to interact with them

[dareb]

i feel like i was very similar in that regard from pages 1-10 but i digress

[dareb]

if there’s nothing revolutionary in the next three hours, i’m probably just going to vote ccg at this point

[Black]

brief thoughts for now: my limpool is {Bella, Black}. i do not see myself voting out of this today. i will read both of their posts in isolation, and also go through the past ~2 pages of posting line by line (esp Spartan's stuff), and then post reads and a vote.

If you are town you should drop this now before they murder you

[Spartan117]

Hey guys, sorry I've been super busy today not had a chance to be present, I'm gonna be reading up on the thread tomorrow when I get in from work, appreciate your patience

[dareb]

i'm ready to vote ccgeek atp
VOTE: CCGeek

E-2

[Gumball]

I can't quite get over how this post, while full of stuff, just feels blank to me. Caveats, riffing on previous comments rather than identifying anything new. I'm just feeling like this was an attempt to demonstrate reads that don't really exist in their head.

For the record you don't feel this way when reading Spartan's catch ups?

I do. Just to a slightly lesser extent, I think I felt like there were some things in there that looked a bit fresher and spicier. I have no motivation to go reanalyse it and set it out, but if you think it's helpful then push me on it and it will probably be enough motivation for me to put the work in.

I have little (but nonzero) confidence I'm going the right way on this, and I can certainly see myself changing. However, I'm also slightly cautious that as soon as people start making my decisions for me I'm risking that this is how scum escape, like if I give two options I'm happy with and allow myself to be swayed cheaply, then my chance of hitting scum is zero (unless both options are scum...)

As to the game state I think my pools are pretty set right now so I'm struggling to find motivation to spend hours reanalysing stuff, unless someone has some significant new thoughts or CCG pops back in. I'm thinking (obviously unless I start to think there's a genuine possibility I might push outside spartan/ccg) to save sorting the rest of the slots for tomorrow when there'll be more information to go on.

[Gumball]

One of my main issues with the catchup this game is that he did a deep dive on pages he was previously apart of. He was present pages 1-7 and then in 234 he recaps pages 1-5

This is a somewhat interesting aspect.

I'm wondering if this means something like in his head, he'd been in the thread on those pages, but hadn't been like properly engaging with all of it, or just felt like he hadn't spoken about it. And what does that indicate? I'm not sure I know, but I think it will niggle at me tonight.

[dareb]

For me, Spartan's catch up posts were so much more in depth, and compared to CCG's catch up we see much more interaction

For example, CCG's view on page 6:

- page 6 -

- learning that the voting meta is significantly different is a bit of a doozy, i'm with spartan on this one

- not much else on this page

Compared to Spartan's view on page 6 (265, not interested in quoting full post here)

[dareb]

probably not the fairest comparison in regards to ccg, but even then a comparison of the page 9 catchups i feel spartan has more

[NicoleAndDime]

Catching up, bottom of page 11 rn

Liking spartan's catchup, feels +town because it kinda seems more scattershot than scum trying to justify a certain read. Feels more likely from genuine solving

I don't think scum!Bella like triples/quadruples down on people tring me. I think scum would worry about how it inherently doesn't look great to just kind of dismiss someone's reads out of hand. Not sensing any of that kind of worry from Bella so far.

[NicoleAndDime]

Also sorry about not being online for a while, hit with a 1-2 punch of a family member graduating and the associated real life commitments to getting sick right after (Mostly ok now)

[NicoleAndDime]

Will get fully caught up by end of tonight

[herodualies]

i think andante/spartan is probably either w/w or t/t

Can you elaborate on this?

pure vibes lol

[herodualies]

early game reads are not my strength

[herodualies]

i do. not remember who i have voted for but i also don’t want to vote black until after monday. so i’m just UNVOTE: ing for now

@literally everyone tr ing Nicole, pls explain the read

shrugs? i agreed with her logic and reads, and she at least tried to start discussion. seems fairly townish to me

what are your thoughts on the game?

honestly? still trying to figure out what to do when days are a week long. also i feel like i probably need to reread everything 7 times

[dareb]

i think andante/spartan is probably either w/w or t/t

Can you elaborate on this?

pure vibes lol

i’m assuming u typoed s/s right? just want to make sure that’s what i’m interpreting

[herodualies]

i think andante/spartan is probably either w/w or t/t

Can you elaborate on this?

pure vibes lol

i’m assuming u typoed s/s right? just want to make sure that’s what i’m interpreting

??? isnt the phrase wolf/wolf

[Black]

i think andante/spartan is probably either w/w or t/t

Can you elaborate on this?

pure vibes lol

What makes you think they could be partnered?

[dareb]

i think andante/spartan is probably either w/w or t/t

Can you elaborate on this?

pure vibes lol

i’m assuming u typoed s/s right? just want to make sure that’s what i’m interpreting

??? isnt the phrase wolf/wolf

oh i was thinking scum/scum but at least i know you meant what i thought

[Alianna]

~•~