Mini Normal 2375: Creepily Normal Pumpkins (Game Over)

[Aureal]

Vote Count 2.01

Dunnstral (3/6)

-> Gimli (767), MariaR (887), Roden (892)

Elements (2/6)

-> Finite (732), Marshmallow Marshall (803)

Black (2/6)

-> Elements (739), Alianna (1005)

Gimli (1/6)

-> Dunnstral (861)

Alianna (1/6)

-> Black (1003)

Not Voting (2)

-> Immortal Technique, chibiyali


The day's deadline is 7 days ((expired on 2025-10-20 11:58:41) remaining)

Mod Notes:

I totally could've had that post 1000 if I'd wanted it...

[Immortal Technique]

You are welcome ladies for setting you up for pagetops

I am such a gentleman

[Black]

Apologies again if I was too snappy earlier

No worries. I wasn't exactly being very welcoming to you in the thread but I really wanted to hear your thoughts on things and you weren't trying to do that lol. So I got kinda annoyed but it's fine

Working my way into getting a hold of the claims today, and I like that Alianna is here at the same time

I only wish Gims was here as well now

He's in the scum PT cooling off

[Immortal Technique]

Apologies again if I was too snappy earlier

No worries. I wasn't exactly being very welcoming to you in the thread but I really wanted to hear your thoughts on things and you weren't trying to do that lol. So I got kinda annoyed but it's fine

Working my way into getting a hold of the claims today, and I like that Alianna is here at the same time

I only wish Gims was here as well now

He's in the scum PT cooling off

I probably agree with you here

[Alianna]

This isn't going to be an essay, but reads are approximately this.

{

Alianna

}
{

MariaR

}
{

Roden

}
{

Finite

}
{

Elements

}
{

Black

}
{

Marshmallow Marshall

,

Immortal Technique

}
{

chibiyali

}
{

Gimli

}
{

Dunnstral

}
{

Aureal

}

Spoiler: a few random notes

Finite - currently voting
CrepeGuy - would vote
Marshmallow Marshall - won't vote
Gimli - won't vote
MariaR - won't vote
Roden - won't vote
Immortal Technique - could vote
Alianna - could vote
Black - won't vote
Dunnstral - could vote
geraintm - won't vote
chibiyali - won't vote

Elements putting 7 people in the "won't vote" category this early is mildly towny.

Marshmallow has nice vibes, but other than the point made in 424, etc. about my wagon, I'm not getting anything concrete.

279 feels super transparent and I like that.

Crepe you should hardclaim

This is me declaring intent

Ye actually nevermind

Im not hammering crepe we should keep yappjng

Crepe you should hardclaim

This is me declaring intent

Ye actually nevermind

Im not hammering crepe we should keep yappjng

UNVOTE:
How do you feel about e-1 ing crepe?

VOTE: crepe

Okay sure

if elly wants to hammer crepe without a claim thats her decision and her problem

You literally enabled her to do it. Right after you said we should talk more. The fuck?

VOTE: CrepeGuy

This is a hilarious exchange and Gimli gets extra scumpoints for it lol.

771 isn't necessarily scummy, but it is a weak reason to scumread Finite imo. I've definitely defended townreads as town and gotten scumread for it.

I don't know how that is possible considering a bunch of the posts before that one was about the guilty

Why did you skip everything and then pick out 929 to respond to?

I barely had time to check the thread while at work, I tried to pop in here and there but the thread was moving so fast

And I like to catch up going backwards, so when doing that I will point out something that jumps out at me.....or can help me in my catch-up?

Why are you all in my shit about this?

This is reminiscent of the whole argument you had with Ame about how you don't read posts that happened while you were sleeping.

[Alianna]

chibiyali is technically null tier, but there's a decent chance I have a scum above that.

[Alianna]

@IT - have you explained why you townread me? Meta?

[Immortal Technique]

@IT - have you explained why you townread me? Meta?

Feel like the push on you was weird on D1

And when Black mentioned how busy you were, there could be a smidge of you two being partnered

But, you being busy and still putting forth effort to play the game.....is +town for you imo

[Alianna]

@IT - have you explained why you townread me? Meta?

Feel like the push on you was weird on D1

And when Black mentioned how busy you were, there could be a smidge of you two being partnered

But, you being busy and still putting forth effort to play the game.....is +town for you imo

Interesting. I feel like that last sentence is quite different from how others have perceived my play this game.

Not drawing a conclusion from that, just noting it.

[Immortal Technique]

@IT - have you explained why you townread me? Meta?

Feel like the push on you was weird on D1

And when Black mentioned how busy you were, there could be a smidge of you two being partnered

But, you being busy and still putting forth effort to play the game.....is +town for you imo

Interesting. I feel like that last sentence is quite different from how others have perceived my play this game.

Not drawing a conclusion from that, just noting it.

You usually are tepid when scum, and not busy

But if you have an excuse, it makes sense

Hence why i said there is a bit of you and Black partnered here.....but I err on the side of you town here

[chibiyali]

Short update: yesterday around gameday start, my grandmother passed. I'll take another 24h to spend time with family and say our farewells. Then I'll be back.

[chibiyali]

Also: I was right on my Dunn sus?!

*fistpumps*

[MariaR]

Take your time Chibi thoughts are with ya.

[chibiyali]

I'll 100% vote Dunn btw but I also want to take the time we have to clear my null status when I return from our mourning day.

[MariaR]

Just because the execute is clear doesn't mea we need to vote right away.
If anything we should take the full phase to talk everything out more so
really there should be no rush to begin with. Ya know, unless I am just
reaction testing.

Surely my ego isn't that big
right?

[Dunnstral]

Condolences, chibiyali.

[Elements]

11 pages and 3 claims
Thanks gang
Ima need a laptop for this

[Elements]

Spoiler: vote stuff

Spoiler: Gimli

Has voted: Crepe, Alianna, MariaR, Dunn
Has been voted by: Roden, MariaR, Elements | Roden, Black, Dunn

Spoiler: MariaR

Has voted: Gimli, Elements, Black, Alianna, MM, Dunn
Has been voted by: Dunn, Gimli

Spoiler: Roden

Has voted: Black, Gimli, Crepe | Gimli, Dunn
Has been voted by: Gera

Spoiler: Dunn

Has voted: MariaR, Finite, Crepe | Gimli
Has been voted by: MariaR, Chibi, Gimli | Black, Roden

Spoiler: Permutations and thoughts on them

Spoiler: All green

Roden is roleblocked (I don't believe Gimli gets protected N1 ever) and MariaR is reaction testing. We have 2 pseudo-investigative PRs which could be possible depending on other pr claims later on. I don't think this is likely.

Spoiler: 1 red

Gimli - Roden hit gimli, MariaR is reaction testing. Indistinguishable from all green mechanically unless MariaR tells us she was reaction testing which I don't think she should do. More likely than all green given my current read on Gimli.
MariaR - Doesn't make any sense for MariaR to distract from the Gimli guilty.
Roden - doesn't make any sense for Roden to randomly fake a guilty here
Dunn - Roden was roleblocked and MariaR has a guilty. I can see that.

Spoiler: 2 red

Gimli, MariaR - MariaR fakes a guilty on Dunn to save Gimli for a day, hoping to be able to pass it off as a reaction test. High risk low reward.
Gimli, Roden - Roden just gives a guilty on Gimli because.....?
Gimli, Dunn - Roden and MariaR are true claiming.
MariaR, Roden - no, just no
MariaR, Dunn - as above
Roden, Dunn - Roden fakes a guilty only for MariaR to provide a real one. No reason for roden to do this

Spoiler: 3 are red - honestly not worth reading

Gimli, MariaR, Roden

,

Dunn

- MariaR gives a fake guilty on Dunn to save Gimli from a fake guilty from a teammate which will be resolved from the flip and put MariaR under suspicion..... Too complicated

Gimli, MariaR,

Roden

,

Dunn

- MariaR gives a fake guilty on a teamamate to save Gimli from a real guilty. Which still would keep suspicion on Gimli tomorrow anyway leading to a final 7 with just mariaR alive - unnessecarily risky

Gimli

,

MariaR

,

Roden, Dunn

- Roden fakes a gulity on a partner for some reason then MariaR come out with a real guilty or reaction test - literally zero reason for Roden to do so

Gimli

,

MariaR, Roden, Dunn

- what? how? the whole red team putting themselves in the limelight

The most likely mechanical scenarios to me are:
all green with a roleblock and reaction test
Red!gimli with a reaction test
Red!gimli and red!dunn
red!dunn with a roleblocked roden

Roden is always town here.
Gimli is almost always mafia.
I don't think MariaR should reveal if it was a reaction test or not but I agree we should slow roll the day up until the point it starts getting stale.
I think we should vote Gimli today, the Roden shoots Dunn in the night. If Dunn dies we avoid a mislim and if not we vote Dunn tomorrow. I don't see any reason we don't just vote Gimli into Dunn.
Vanilla Cop gimli could also just be a mafia PR.
Then tomorrow we're at likely either 2:6 with doubt on MariaR or 2:7 with a guilty which is nice.
I do find it hard to imagine MariaR doing this as mafia though.
VOTE: Gimli

[Black]

Short update: yesterday around gameday start, my grandmother passed. I'll take another 24h to spend time with family and say our farewells. Then I'll be back.

<3

[Black]

Alianna not townreading me makes me think she's more likely to be town

[Black]

I still think we follow the hard guilty today. It's the more sure bet. If Maria ends up backtracking we go Gimli

[Black]

I got some minor town pings from IT last night. Part of me felt like he could have been playing up a clueless act but after reading it over again I think that is less likely

[Black]

1042 feels townie

[Black]

Not buying the outrage

I agree with this

If Gimli is scum I think he was hoping his spat with Roden got bad enough for him to garner some townreads

[Black]

Aww Gimli didn't wish us a gm today. Must be mad that we caught him