NY 118 - BBM's Large Normal Mafia (Game!)

[Flameaxe]

PS: Jay Dodge prodded.

[Xite91]

I apologize for the recent second thread explosion. It is apparent that trying to prove my opinion is useless because I can't get anything out of UA or xite other than a stating of their opinions. Anybody know how long until the day ends? If it's close, don't vote for anyone other than Frank or hiphop, so we can at least lynch someone today. Also, anybody disagree with nhammen's suggestions for my investigation (Wraith, hiphop, and bunny)?

You can't "prove" your opinion. That's the first mistake with this, second, why should we change our opinions to yours? Third, I would agree with bunny, I'm pretty sure wraith is the lynch for tomorrow, so how about hiphop and Jdodge being your other two choices?

[Mysterio]

The hiphop wagon looks weak. He hasn't had as many slips as Frank, however I agree that his earlier posts were totally worthless. The non-voters need to chime in, but I still see no reason to question a Frank lynch. Even if you want to peg him as a newbie, that's actually reason in favor of lynching him. Since he's taking attention away from actual scum, he's only hurting town. If he turns out to be scum, then all the better.

[Benmage]

Another pg down, still trucking...

Also, I probably doubt their is only one cop role in this game, since its 24 people probably their more invisitgating people

I could only see varying cop sanities...not multiple sane cops.

[Benmage]

Dunt dunt dunt another one bites the dust. Liking nhammen.

[danakillsu]

^^^Concur. With both posts actually. And with Mysterio's too. You nonvoters are stalling this game.

[Flameaxe]

DavidParker replaces Johnny Rotten as soon as he posts in thread.

[Flameaxe]

Votecount 1.8

Frank [9] (Xite, Prozac, danakillsu, UA, singersigner, mysterio, hiphop, robbnva, wraith)

hiphop [3] (Shanba, nhammen, Frank)
Wraith [2] (ConfidAnon, Bunnylover)
danakillsu [1] (JDodge)
Prozac [1] (WickedestJr)
Singersigner [1] (flinter)

Not Voting [10] (seth, Johnny Rotten, Orochi, Sebguer, Kise, Reck, benmage)

24 alive, 13 to lynch, 12 to no lynch.

[Xite91]

This is where I count votes.

I lol'd

[Flameaxe]

This is where I count votes.

I lol'd

Don't misquote the mod. I do not approve.

[Xite91]

This is where I count votes.

I lol'd

Don't misquote the mod. I do not approve.

Butbutbut.... you sir are truly evil

[Porochaz]

I drank cider tonight.

You need to know this.
I want some too. Thanks. -BBM

[Wraith]

DavidParker - my nemesis from Newbie 965 *shakes fist*

We must policy lynch this scum [/sarcasm]

[ConfidAnon]

Why did no one ever comment on my Wraith case?

My reasoning does not include "defends Furcolow," and yet everyone is saying that's the only reason for suspecting him. The post is here.

[nhammen]

OK, dispute this fact: As scum I do nothing more than simply make one liners
and I'm not doing that this game
so therefore I am not scum

So you are deliberately not playing to your scum meta. Thank you for informing us of this.

Wait a minute. Was Frank the first one to bring up multiple scum groups? On Day 1? Why is he not dead yet?

I didn't bring up multiple scum groups, learn to read. I said that they should have multiple kills in the night if this is balanced properly.

You're right. I distinctly remember reading that exchange with you and Prozac, not having a clue what you were going on about, and promising myself to go and look at it later. I just now figured out what you meant by it
1) When has this happened, ever?
2) We can't even begin this kind of speculation until we actually have a kill to analyze. Why in the 9 Hells did you bring it up?

QFT

However, I'll add that either way I think me voting Frank will end up as a lose-lose for me. I'll immediately get hit by a wall of bussing accusations, and if he flips scum I'll probably be the Day 2 lynch. If I vote for him and he flips town, I'll still probably get lynched Day 2 for suddenly flip-flopping on my stance and joining his very popular wagon. But whatever, I don't really care, because my lynch would save a PR from being mislynched. I still honestly think lynching Frank is a bad idea in the long run, but nothing ventured, nothing gained.

"Everyone is going to be suspicious of me no matter what. Boo hoo!" This just more AtE.

Why did no one ever comment on my Wraith case?

My reasoning does not include "defends Furcolow," and yet everyone is saying that's the only reason for suspecting him. The post is here.

I thought your Wriath case was great, but shanba's hiphop case was better. They are both higher on my list than furc. Also, can you explain why you are echoing shanba's "Is there a reason everyone is totally ignoring my last post?"

[Furcolow]

I have been emotionally drained, and I can't catch up on mafia right now, because I've had a very taxing day in real life. I will have to catch up tomorrow.

I am just a townie this game, so better me than a power role, though we already have 1 claimed

You all, if town, should honestly not lynch me, but my play is pretty bad in terms of helping the town. If you don't lynch me, I'll try to change.

[ConfidAnon]

I thought your Wriath case was great, but shanba's hiphop case was better. They are both higher on my list than furc. Also, can you explain why you are echoing shanba's "Is there a reason everyone is totally ignoring my last post?"

My Lindsay-Lohan-attention-needing-gene.

But seriously, it just felt like it was getting ignored, and I had a different viewpoint than what I was hearing throughout the thread. It's most likely due to getting swallowed up in the post count of the thread . . . if this game gets any bigger, it will be rivalling the size of Oprah's cult.

[Wickedestjr]

Yeah, UA seems to have been sliding by in the early game. Except why would he get involved in that huge argument if he was just trying to slide by.

I don't get the impression that he intended to get in the argument. It seems to me that he just gave his opinion and JDodge continued questioning him on it.

Hmmm... so you think Poro is opportunistically joining the furc wagon as it grows? Or distancing from a buddy? Or something else?

Answered in a later post: opportunistic.

It could be both opportunism and distancing from a buddy.

OK, dispute this fact: As scum I do nothing more than simply make one liners
and I'm not doing that this game
so therefore I am not scum

I thought you said you were really good at scum. You consider posting one liners to be a good strategy as scum?

I'll tell you why - There are a ton of scum on it because I'm suspicious of them.

It's not that they jumped on your bandwagon because you called them scum. They jumped on your bandwagon, and then you called them scum. Or at least that's what I remember.

I didn't bring up multiple scum groups, learn to read. I said that they should have multiple kills in the night if this is balanced properly.

Since when does one scumgroup have multiple kills?

@UA: THe breadccrumb I spotted was Xite's. I don't know why he's claiming at this point, but it's null-tell IMO. He could be scum trying to set up a future believable claim like Dana did, or he could be genuinely town. Either way, I don't think it should affect anyone's reads on him much.

Why in the world would you say that somebody breadcrumbed their role if not everybody knew?

If you don't lynch me, I'll try to change.

How? Also, why not change now?

[Wickedestjr]

I could support a Furcolow lynch. There are several good reasons to lynch him:

*Recently his posting in the last few pages has looked very bad.
*He is an annoying distraction imo.
*His lynch will provide a lot of information.
*He's claimed to be a Vanilla Townie and bandwagoning somebody else to a claim might not be a good idea today.

...However, I am not ready to end the day yet. Also, I think Wraith is town. I don't want to lynch him.

[Robbnva]

If anyone has any doubt about frank, I suggest you go back and read Xite's posts, the way he breaks down mafia scum tells is amazing and if I had not already voted for frank, I would based on those reads

2nd - we almost lynched a "cop" if he was telling the truth, now we have an admitted nilla townie. Tbqh if I had to choose lynch nilla or scumhunt more and risk exposing another pr, I'd say go with frank

also, I'm not buying frank's last post, seems too "poor me"

[DavidParker]

Hi guys, did a very brief skim read (took me 2-3 mins before deciding to replace in) but will catch up properly now. Just got off long shift at work, but have tomorrow off so expect something then!

[ConfidAnon]

Also, I think Wraith is town. I don't want to lynch him.

Why?

[Robbnva]

Also, I think Wraith is town. I don't want to lynch him.

Why?

this

if you are going to say somebody is town, it would be helpful for a reason so others can see if they agree or disagree

[Xite91]

I have been emotionally drained, and I can't catch up on mafia right now, because I've had a very taxing day in real life. I will have to catch up tomorrow.

I am just a townie this game, so better me than a power role, though we already have 1 claimed

You all, if town, should honestly not lynch me, but my play is pretty bad in terms of helping the town. If you don't lynch me, I'll try to change.

Here, have a tissue.
I'm still going to get you lynched today, I'm sorry.

If anyone has any doubt about frank, I suggest you go back and read Xite's posts, the way he breaks down mafia scum tells is amazing and if I had not already voted for frank, I would based on those reads

also, I'm not buying frank's last post, seems too "poor me"

[flinter]

2nd - we almost lynched a "cop" if he was telling the truth, now we have an admitted nilla townie. Tbqh if I had to choose lynch nilla or scumhunt more and risk exposing another pr, I'd say go with frank.

strange reasoning. I don't know why a townie would ever accept lynching another townie. I don't like the Furcolow wagon at all.