Sorry, took me longer than I expected.
Alma
: Seems to be pretty much active lurking, popping in here and there, dropping some rather innocuous ramarks and disappearing again. I really want to hear more from him, at least some opinion about every player or something like that to start with.
Anti
: Some shallow conventional conversation, than attacking Fate for playstyle, dangling around it, unvoting, finally jumping on the most poular waggon. Seems also pretty concerned about not receiving any unwanted attention an dmore or less disappears when under pressure.
Conc
: I don't like her early attack on Baltar. He never really explains how Baltar's bad scum hunting tactic could actually be scummy.
I don't really get this remark:
Voting is a tool, not a liability.
So you do not need to justify your votes?
Jarti
: I really didn't like his opening, just droping in, throwing what seems like random names around and some setup speculation that entirely uninetersting in the current state of the game (don't get me wrong, I don't say he shouldn't have brought it up, but I consider this kind of stuff entirely null). I don't know. His latest posts seem better to me. Also some one I need to see more of.
Percy
: Has provided two actually useful posts so far. His first post seems kind of dodgy. It seems to go nowhere, no clear suspicions, no vote... His next post gets a bit more of a direction, but one I absolutely do not like. His case against Baltar seems really stretched and twisted to me, especially the alleged "noob-scum" dilemma.
Sim
: His attack on Ythil seemed really forced (I don't consider setup speculations a reliable town tell, but I definitely consider attempts at inhibiting them for whatever reason scummy). His final statement
Better way of putting it: setup questions are fine. "I haven't read the thread, but here are some ideas about the setup, discuss them now" isn't.
is really flimsy IMO. His attack on LL for what is most likely just personal posting style is also suspicious. Later he says about Ythill, after excusing his "bad play so far":
I had a problem with Ythill, but I was barking up the wrong tree.
Seems like backing out of an unpopular waggon without further ado. I don't buy his case against LL at all. His latest posts seem a bit better, though, so I'll give him the benefit of the doubt that it was really just a bad start.
I don't know. I still like the Anti waggon, but that's not going to do much in the near future as it seems and Percy and Conc, though derserving more pressure, don't even have a waggon O_o. So I'll join the Alma waggon (
vote count please
)
unvote. vote Alma
