Would this work? Would this be fun?

[Corsato]

Call me naieve, but wouldn't it be a matter of trusting the players not to cheat? I do not believe there's a way to prevent it, so why bother trying?

The idea itself is interesting, missed Harry Potter mafia, so I do not know how it turns out.

[Corsato]

Somehow I don' t like too much randomness in mafia games.

I like the idea mentioned by Stewie. That would make cheating very hard. But I'm afriad it's indeed to time consuming......if you ever consider modding this game, count me in.