Open 315 - Quack Mafia (Game Over)

[DonJosh]

Does everybody agree that we should claim whom we protected N0?

Yes, I agree.

Anyway, RVS VOTE: jilynnne1991

[DonJosh]

Sure izak, I'm pretty sure pretty much everyone is for a claim

[DonJosh]

I protected popsofctown

[DonJosh]

I protected popsofctown

Why?

Same as IceGuy, just random

[DonJosh]

I protected popsofctown

Why?

Same as IceGuy, just random

Vote: Don

There are three or four people who protected randomly. Why am I so suspicious?

[DonJosh]

I voted Don because scum are more likely to not put thought in who they'd like to protect.

If you'd said that the first time I'd be okay with it, but still. Why don over iceguy? Both seem to randomly chose someone to protect.

1.

Don did it second

2. Ice is generally useful

Where do you see me presuming don is town? That sentence had the emphasis on your reasoning for a vote instead of Don's innocence in receiving a vote.

You presumed Don had the ability to protect.

Don did it second? Really? We both protected at the same time, we just claimed at different times. Bull reasoning

This is not an OMGUS vote, it's a genuine "I think your scum" vote... VOTE: Empking

[DonJosh]

DonJosh:
- Why did you post whom you protected, but not your justification?
- Why do you think Empking is scum?

Sathoris:
- Why this post? You didn't choose your target randomly.
- Why did you defend DonJosh against Empking's attacks?

Anyway, VOTE: Sathoris mostly because of gut feeling, and

FoS: DonJosh

.

I did post my justification. It was random protection, same as yours. Personally, I don't see how posting a reason two posts later makes me scummy...

I think Empking is scum because of his excessive attacks with BS reasoning. For example:

How is it lying nonsense? Scum could easily have taken some time to deliberate over their fake protect-claim.

Wow, so its gone from "will" to "could". Somebody's scum aren't they?

[DonJosh]

Another example...

I protected popsofctown

Why?

Same as IceGuy, just random

Vote: Don

No reasoning at all, I told him I randomly protected, and he voted me. Wtf. Again, not OMGUS on my part.

[DonJosh]

Also, I just realized that Empking and I both protected the same person.

[DonJosh]

Also, I just realized that Empking and I both protected the same person.

Nice fluff from Don "Protests too much about OMGUS" Josh.

Thought you would point that out. Ignore all my other posts and even avoid responding to them. Typical scum play.

[DonJosh]

Yeah, so he's not as big a contributor as some of us. But if you're going to have a go at people for that, take a look at Uncle Pain. Or forest_air. Or popsofctown. Or jilynne. All of them have been less use than Don. So misrep or no misrep, you are again doing this horribly wrong.

Posting fluff > Posting nothing in the scumminess stakes.

Even if it wasn't its own post the randomness and irrelevance would still be scummy. Give me a town motive for posting it.

I posted it to see if you would nitpick about it and avoid my real points, which you did. Give me a response to the posts before the "fluff"

[DonJosh]

I posted it to see if you would nitpick about it and avoid my real points, which you did. Give me a response to the posts before the "fluff"

Oshit, missed that. No. Not buying that. Emp, I still read you as scum, but I agree that Don is trying to find a reason after doing it.

The only big thing that gave me a town read on Don was that Emp is scummy and Emp had no good points on Don, so it didn't look like bussing. Now there is a real point against him, the read vanishes.

I want to see his reaction before I put a vote down (on anyone) again.

Fine, don't believe it was a trap (it was), but I still want Empking's response to my other posts! He's been avoiding them!

[DonJosh]

DonJ:

If it really was a trap why didn't you say so in your first post responding to Empking's quote of said 'trap'?

In post #78 you accuse Empking of ignoring your other posts and later in post #90 you proclaim it was a trap in which you would see if Empking avoided your other posts. Why not mention your 'trap' in your first post because Emking aparently did precisely as you'd hoped. Surely it would have been a better time to inform us about your trap then?

Also, I just realized that Empking and I both protected the same person.

Nice fluff from Don "Protests too much about OMGUS" Josh.

Thought you would point that out

. Ignore all my other posts and even avoid responding to them. Typical scum play.

[DonJosh]

I think Empking is scum because of his excessive attacks with BS reasoning. For example:

How is it lying nonsense? Scum could easily have taken some time to deliberate over their fake protect-claim.

Wow, so its gone from "will" to "could". Somebody's scum aren't they?

Explain your reasoning.

[DonJosh]

@empking: see above post

[DonJosh]

You're not answering my question DonJ. I ask again, why didn't you said it was a trap in your first post? Cause I think you just made that up.

I did answer it.

DonJ:

If it really was a trap why didn't you say so in your first post responding to Empking's quote of said 'trap'?

In post #78 you accuse Empking of ignoring your other posts and later in post #90 you proclaim it was a trap in which you would see if Empking avoided your other posts. Why not mention your 'trap' in your first post because Emking aparently did precisely as you'd hoped. Surely it would have been a better time to inform us about your trap then?

Also, I just realized that Empking and I both protected the same person.

Nice fluff from Don "Protests too much about OMGUS" Josh.

Thought you would point that out

. Ignore all my other posts and even avoid responding to them. Typical scum play.

The bold is pretty much saying "I planned that"

[DonJosh]

Not buying it. If it really was a trap then why the need to point it out later?

Because, if you look back and re-read, Empking (or anyone else) obviously didn't catch what I said (the bold). He was still referring to it as "fluff"

[DonJosh]

Your 'trap' was really weak. Empking saying fluff was weak aswell, but you claiming it as some kind of trap is just awful. Your suspicion of me is laughable aswell? Just cause I'm voting for you?

DonJ needs to go.

Please tell me when I stated I found you suspicious.

[DonJosh]

Please tell me when I stated I found you suspicious.

Oh woops, that was Iceguy with the lame vote, sorry. Changes little though.

Changes more than little. Now your only reason for suspicion is because of my trap claim?

[DonJosh]

If DonJ flips quack then Empking is a doctor and seeing as I have a townread on Uncle and Pops the remaining scum must be Jylinne/Iceguy/Glowball or Jylinne and a combination of Izak and glowball or iceguy.

What if Littlegrey or zMuffinMan protected popsofctown?

[DonJosh]

...wow. Way to put me at L-1 on my vacation.
Obviously I don't totally agree with the plan, but as long as I'm helping the town and not being lynched because of scumminess, I guess it's alright. Plus, I'm going camping again for another 3 days so I'd be V/LA for a while anyway. Anyways, Your guys plan is really solid, and just a heads up, I think I may be quack. Good luck catching scum!

VOTE: DonJosh

[DonJosh]

Yes, I know, I meant *purely because of scumminess

[DonJosh]

yzxyzyxyzxyyzyxyzyyxyyzyyxyzxzxzxzyxzxzxzxzxyzxzyzxyyxyzzyxyzyyzxzyyyxzxzyzyxzxzxzzzxxxxyxyxyzyxyyzyxyzyzxzxzxzyxxyyyyyyzxzxzxxzzyzyzyzyzyzyyzxzxzxxzxzyzyyzyzyyzxzxzxzyzyzyzyxxzyzxzyxzyzxyzyzxxzyzxzyxzxzyzyxzyzyxzyzxyzyzxyzyxyxyxyyyyyzxzxzxzxxyzyxzyzxzyxzyxzyzxyzxyzxyzx

[DonJosh]

I'd be in, I think I could improve on my performance in this game. I didn't do too well.