Open 331: No Lynching Town - Game Over!

[Packbat]

or HELL we can get me today so you guys can drop this hiplop scumteam thing and then tomorrow all of you sheep me to victory EVEN if I am dead you will kill PackBat> Izak>CSL

Yeah no way is it a glow/hip team

WHY THE HELL NOT?

For the sake of all that is holy, if you're going to make pronouncements, include

some hint

of what your reasoning is. There are automatically two players in this game lying to everyone - make them

work

for it. Anyone can say "no way" or "confirmed" or whatever absolutist sentiment - but if everyone is forced to give reasoning, scum will be forced, too, and that'll mean that they have to bullshit, and forcing them to bullshit

helps us catch them.

glowball: why are you maintaining that I am scum? Include references to specific posts.

Empking: why is hiplop town? Include references to specific posts.

Empking: why is a glowball/hiplop team impossible? Include references to specific posts.

Ellibereth: are you still of the opinion that CSL is the player most likely to be scum? If so, explain why. If not, who is your top suspect, and why?

Include references to specific posts.

Pre-Edit: glowball: specific posts.

[glowball]

I'm too lazy for all of that you should re read the game and look at yourself.

[Packbat]

I'm too lazy for all of that you should re read the game and look at yourself.

I did reread the game. That's what #168 was about. If you want to dispute the material in that post, that's

your

job.

[Packbat]

Or, in short: references or STFU.

[glowball]

Thanks, but I am okay.

[Empking]

If you make town make stuff up then you won't be able to catch scum when they do it.

Hip is town for being on the CSL wagon. Glow is town for his sensible reads in his last post.

[Packbat]

If you make town make stuff up then you won't be able to catch scum when they do it.

FAIL.

Town does not need to "make stuff up." In an all-vanilla setup like this, the

only

way town players acquire opinions is by honest reading of the thread. In the course of honest reading of the thread, these town players will make observations which incline them to various opinions about the players in the game.

What I am demanding is that they

state these observations

- be they as simple as "this post was slimy". What this allows is for

other

town players to repeat these observations, and form their own opinions on them, opinions which are likely to be correlated between players when they are well-founded and based on genuine reading and

not

when they are not.

Hip is town for being on the CSL wagon. Glow is town for his sensible reads in his last post.

Why does being on the CSL wagon make him town? I can ignore the glowball bit for the moment - I can understand it, even if it is a complete reversal of your statements for the past few pages - but in what way is voting for CSL on page two a marker of towniness?

[Empking]

If you make town make stuff up then you won't be able to catch scum when they do it.

FAIL.

Town does not need to "make stuff up." In an all-vanilla setup like this, the

only

way town players acquire opinions is by honest reading of the thread. In the course of honest reading of the thread, these town players will make observations which incline them to various opinions about the players in the game.

What I am demanding is that they

state these observations

- be they as simple as "this post was slimy". What this allows is for

other

town players to repeat these observations, and form their own opinions on them, opinions which are likely to be correlated between players when they are well-founded and based on genuine reading and

not

when they are not.

No because you had a problem when I quoted Glows post and called him town. That's really no different from your slimy example.

Hip is town because of the scums original fight against the CSL. How can scum be against it when they're on it?

Hip is town for being on the CSL wagon. Glow is town for his sensible reads in his last post.

Why does being on the CSL wagon make him town? I can ignore the glowball bit for the moment - I can understand it, even if it is a complete reversal of your statements for the past few pages - but in what way is voting for CSL on page two a marker of towniness?[/quote]

[Ellibereth]

ugh something feels wrong about this game...
I'll just skim through it now and look more when I have more time tomorrow...

[Ellibereth]

Oh yeah
Why did people think CSL was scum? the reasons I did don't apply to most people.

[Packbat]

I tried to explain my reasoning in #168, Ellibereth - let me know if there's any part of that that requires elaboration.

[Ellibereth]

I still don't like goomba's freaking the fuck out at an L-1. His "what twisted world is L-1 on third post" seem and then insisitence on equating it with a hammer and then just dropping that and calling me scum repeatedly once I ripped that to shreds is meh.
Then his random ass empking bus comment when just calling us a pair
and then his "lolelliwantstoquickhammer, to stop we quicklynch him trolololol"

and for someone who seems to like "standard play" or whatever the hell it is
(taking everything emp/me says at face value, against fast wagons, blahblahblah)
He seems to be going off purely off gut, hesitates to say this, and just keeps saying blahblah is scum.

This just from quick iso skim and memory no context etc.

[Ellibereth]

I tried to explain my reasoning in #168, Ellibereth - let me know if there's any part of that that requires elaboration.

oh you wanted my reason?
again from memory
I didn't think townCSL would have legitimately thought I was scum at that point.
(his to troll comment was wtf)
and then his takeback -> 1 v 1 -> 1 v 1 would be beneficial if we were both town.

But the last is so ridiculous he's getting moved back to I don't know what the fuck you're doing category instead of scumz.

[Fenchurch]

Eleventh Vote Count of Day One

hiplop - 3 (Packbat, CSL, izakthegoomba)

Packbat - 2 (glowball, Empking)
CSL - 1 (hiplop)

Not voting: 1 (Ellibereth)

With seven alive, it will take four votes to lynch.

Deadline is: Thursday, 8 September at 8:39 am GMT.

[Ellibereth]

glow, if you hammer hiplop, I guarrantee I will vote Packbat tomorrow.

Yeah, no that's not doing it for me.

If you hammer CSL I'll sheep you for the rest of the game. (If he flips scum then I'll refuse to vote Elli though.)

What the fuck is this? Gambling ONE PLAYER being scum against your vote for THE WHOLE GAME?

AND THIS
DOODALOO

[Ellibereth]

and don't go "lol whole game vs. one day
practically the same thing.
From emp's "sheer insanity" just a step back.
KISHISHISHISHISHISHI

Vote: goomba

[hiplop]

I could comply with a goomba lynch.

VOTE: goombatheizak

[Ellibereth]

hiplop
don't look at my posts
why is goomba scum

[glowball]

Ellibereth that is simple : Hiplop thinks izak is scum because he's the other wagon and when hiplop was at L-1 he didn't have anything to say and has not responded to the accusations against him....

[glowball]

This game has taken a complete turn for me...

Ellibereth and Emp are town

Packbat, Hiplop, and Izak are playing a scummy game

CSL... is just worrying me.

[CSL]

glowball, I don't know about you anymore. You could be scum, you could be town.

But please, just HAMMER HIPLOP ALREADY.

[glowball]

why are you in such a rush CSL?

[Ellibereth]

Ellibereth that is simple : Hiplop thinks izak is scum because he's the other wagon and when hiplop was at L-1 he didn't have anything to say and has not responded to the accusations against him....

I have some thoughts on hip, most are in the "fucking useless" zone but I'll let him comment and then we can start dancing.

Csl
shut up
you're terrible at this

[Ellibereth]

oh and why pack again?
I have him as town.

(TOWN: Elli, Emp, glow, pack
PEOPLE LEFT: Hip, CSL, izak)

[glowball]

He's been opportunistically putting people at L-1. His join date suggests he should have more sense than that. It's like he switches to whatever wagon he thinks will be lynched. THEN when I called him out for it and voted him, he OMGUS me without the vote but by association claiming that I am Hip's scumpartner.