Open 319: Jungle Republic - Day 5: Calamity *GAME OVER*

[Thor665]

Like you are doing so now?

Careful, you might be scumhunting there.

::facepalm::

[whispersilk]

I don't think you're one to preach about scumhunting, Thor.

[havingfitz]

What reasons?
In this type of game how does the fact two people aren't considered the same alignment negate one or both of them being scum?
Why DK or DJ? Your patented PoE?
BB..agreed...especially if by some miracle you flip town.
CM...WTHell not?!!!!!! Especially with the "changed my mind" flip intentions towards you after co-hosting the Thor-CM mutual appreciation society.

[Thor665]

@Whisper - considering what I'll flip and how I've been saying for a while he's scum and you just noticed - I reckon I have as much right as anyone.

@fitz
1. Already stated, fitz, get over your bad self.
2. Because of the other locations scum need to be - why, planning to mislynch her later?
3. Yes, PoE, as clearly explained already.
4. Hurm...
5. Because he's obviously not mafia and if Wolves wanted me dead they could have just shot me - derp.

[Shadowmod]

Hi there, it's me again, your friendly cuddly alpha-wolf... Just siddling a bit around the village, making sure you are alright, I mean not trying to leave us or something... You should be quite relieved to hear that I feel much better now. So let's see if every one's still there... One snack, two snack, three little snacks... four snacks.... five... Could you please stop moving around while I'm counting? ... Thanks. six, seven.... snacks...
... ?!? ...
There's some one missing .... DonJosh, that wimp! Must be trying to hide somewhere, spineless chicken. But don't worry, I shall find that dastard for you.

DonJosh has been prodded.

Thor665 (4/5) - havingfitz , whispersilk , BBmolla , DeityKabuto DeityKabuto (0/5) - Thor665 CMPunk (2/5) - DonJosh , Sky BBmolla (1/5) - CMPunk havingfitz (1/5) - Thor665 Not Voting (0/8): With 8 Players alive it requires 5 Votes to lynch / 4 to nolynch. Deadline will be reached on Monday September 19th 2011, 6:00 p.m. Forum Time [UTC-6].

(expired on 2011-09-19 18:00:00)

till Day 3 Deadline

[DonJosh]

Im here, but on my ipod. V/LA til tomorrow or friday

[Sky]

What do you think of my commentary about wolf/mafia hunting and how it relates to CMPunk as a viable lynch candidate for today?

It's confusing the hell out of me. Probably because I'm a newb. Firstly, what is PoE? And I think scum is scum, kill em all. I don't really want to speculate about who's a wolf and what not. If I understood it, then the reason for this would probably be more clear.

But I just don't see how CMPunk can't be scum. She's threatening to hammer without any valid reason whatsoever other than she just changed her mind. The only excuse she has is being a newb like myself, but I cannot tolerate that as reason not to lynch her.

[Thor665]

PoE = process of elimination.

As regards CM specifically - he voted to hammer a town immediately adjacent to a now proven Mafia. On average scum tend to naturally distance themselves in voting, at least a touch, from their buddies. Therefore, due to his presence next to Fool it is fairly unlikely that CM is Mafia. Now, he may be scum, but if he's scum he's a wolf, and in the general sense of today, due to lack of being mafia, he would not be a good lynch today since he's overall less likely scum than someone else.

Make sense?

And, he *might* be scum buddying me. But, if so, his reverse is pretty weird as it functionally throws out all the "gains" he would have made from buddying me. Therefore, again, in general he's less likely scum.

Later whisper will tell you my inability to go "he's obv. town" makes me scummy (nothing but love whisper - but mocking post game will happen if you're town. If you're scum I grok the play)

I strongly think a fitz or DK lynch should happen today. I'd settle for Josh, but I don't think that's as likely to serve us.

[DeityKabuto]

I don't think you're one to preach about scumhunting, Thor.

How cute. Anyways I expected Thor to be lynched by now, srsly.

[whispersilk]

PoE = process of elimination.

As regards CM specifically - he voted to hammer a town immediately adjacent to a now proven Mafia. On average scum tend to naturally distance themselves in voting, at least a touch, from their buddies. Therefore, due to his presence next to Fool it is fairly unlikely that CM is Mafia. Now, he may be scum, but if he's scum he's a wolf, and in the general sense of today, due to lack of being mafia, he would not be a good lynch today since he's overall less likely scum than someone else.

Make sense?

And, he *might* be scum buddying me. But, if so, his reverse is pretty weird as it functionally throws out all the "gains" he would have made from buddying me. Therefore, again, in general he's less likely scum.

Later whisper will tell you my inability to go "he's obv. town" makes me scummy (nothing but love whisper - but mocking post game will happen if you're town. If you're scum I grok the play)

I strongly think a fitz or DK lynch should happen today. I'd settle for Josh, but I don't think that's as likely to serve us.

The problem with you Thor, is exactly what I pointed out when I highlighted the newbie game we were in together. You were scum, yet you came off as town right up until the lynch scene. You didn't freak out when you were at L-1. You kept up the whole "well guys, you should do this tomorrow and blah blah blah", pretending the entire time that the game wasn't about to be over when you were eventually lynched. I don't buy the helpful, calm, logical town routine you're trying to pull now. You're desperately, but clamly trying to avoid being lynched, and I don't think it's because you are town, but because you are scum.

Hey, if I'm wrong, then you're welcome to mock me all you want afterwards. But it's not only the fact you've led two townies to their death, it's also your attitude right now that grates me. If I was about to be lynched today, I'd be kicking and screaming and doing everything in my power to stop it. But hey, that's just me.

[DonJosh]

@DonJosh: Do you think Thor is town? How do you feel about him thinking you are town but wanting to lynch you?

I do think Thor is town with two honest mislynches on his record.
He's explained the contradiction. He has a town read, but if DK is town, his PoE makes me scum. I don't see what the big deal is.

[DeityKabuto]

@DonJosh: Do you think Thor is town? How do you feel about him thinking you are town but wanting to lynch you?

I do think Thor is town with two honest mislynches on his record.
He's explained the contradiction. He has a town read, but if DK is town, his PoE makes me scum. I don't see what the big deal is.

If Thor is scum, you just went out of your way to shield him.

That gives me three theories.

1. You are a confused town who is going by basic facts to decide whether Thor is town or not, seemingly as Thor pushed hard on the ML wagon D1, that is reason enough, no need to let his text and defense persuade you even further.
2. You are a scum who is trying to get your partner off the hook, I'm going with this one.
3. You are a scum who thinks by defending your partner, it will look like a normal towns people post, where every man has his/her own opinion, and it would be more of a bus / distance sort of thing but a more calm, straightforward thing to get your partner off the hook.

[DonJosh]

@DonJosh: Do you think Thor is town? How do you feel about him thinking you are town but wanting to lynch you?

I do think Thor is town with two honest mislynches on his record.
He's explained the contradiction. He has a town read, but if DK is town, his PoE makes me scum. I don't see what the big deal is.

If Thor is scum, you just went out of your way to shield him.

That gives me three theories.

1. You are a confused town who is going by basic facts to decide whether Thor is town or not, seemingly as Thor pushed hard on the ML wagon D1, that is reason enough, no need to let his text and defense persuade you even further.
2. You are a scum who is trying to get your partner off the hook.
3. You are a scum who thinks by defending your partner, it will look like a normal towns people post, where every man has his/her own opinion, and it would be more of a bus / distance sort of thing but a more calm, straightforward thing to get your partner off the hook.
4. You are a town member answering a question honestly. You also want to avoid a third mislynch.

FTFY

[DeityKabuto]

@DonJosh: Do you think Thor is town? How do you feel about him thinking you are town but wanting to lynch you?

I do think Thor is town with two honest mislynches on his record.
He's explained the contradiction. He has a town read, but if DK is town, his PoE makes me scum. I don't see what the big deal is.

If Thor is scum, you just went out of your way to shield him.

That gives me three theories.

1. You are a confused town who is going by basic facts to decide whether Thor is town or not, seemingly as Thor pushed hard on the ML wagon D1, that is reason enough, no need to let his text and defense persuade you even further.
2. You are a scum who is trying to get your partner off the hook.
3. You are a scum who thinks by defending your partner, it will look like a normal towns people post, where every man has his/her own opinion, and it would be more of a bus / distance sort of thing but a more calm, straightforward thing to get your partner off the hook.
4. You are a town member answering a question honestly. You also want to avoid a third mislynch.

FTFY

Care to explain?

[DonJosh]

Exactly what part needs explaining? It's pretty damn clear.

[CMPunk]

I said I was going to hammer to see reactions, no one seemed to react. I was hoping someone would be over eager for a hammer. Tried a gambit, it failed.

Sorry

[DonJosh]

I said I was going to hammer to see reactions, no one seemed to react. I was hoping someone would be over eager for a hammer. Tried a gambit, it failed.

Sorry

Why is CMPunk not dead?!?
*cries in a corner*

[CMPunk]

Because you don't have enough evidence nor have you been able to convince anyone to? you seem to want my lynch but have done nothing what so ever to say why you want it.

[DeityKabuto]

Exactly what part needs explaining? It's pretty damn clear.

It's like stealing candy from a baby. rofl.

[whispersilk]

You know what? This game is so fucking boring, I'm willing to lynch anyone right now just to get some action going.

[CMPunk]

but a lynch now would stop all action for 72 hours..... your arguement is flawed.

[DeityKabuto]

You know what? This game is so fucking boring, I'm willing to lynch anyone right now just to get some action going.

epicmafia.com

[whispersilk]

@CM As opposed to another 10 days of waiting around for someone to hammer thor? Yeah, I'm totally up for that.

[whispersilk]

I'm up for lynching BB, DJ or DK.

[DeityKabuto]

I'm up for lynching BB, DJ or DK.

jaja why is my name on your list?

For all we know, you could be scum, scum can't form opinions!